McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
I take it all back ....

Yes, I was one of those who saw Pentax's new 'Full Frame' zoom, the D FA 28-105mm 1:3.5-5.6, as ... well ... a 'full frame kit lens' . And now I own one!

I did my research and realised that my initial impressions were wrong ... based on a few early sample shots that were probably unfairly representative of what the lens was capable of. Thanks to the SRS Bank Holiday Sale I am now the happy owner of this beautiful lens ....


Comment Image



Comment Image


OK, I'll come clean ... its not in the box! I took those shots WITH the new lens

What a lovely item .... The immediate impression is of quality and good design. It is solid without being 'heavy', an excellent size for the focal range, and considering its a 'Full Frame' lens, and has very secure and even feeling zoom and focus rings.

These few were taken with the little F35-70mm, which sadly might be getting less use from now on (its focal range having been well and truly absorbed by its new brother .... although its 'macro' feature, used for these shots here, will still be very useful) ......


Comment Image



Comment Image



Comment Image



Comment Image


I have already seen some good results from the lens, and I'll be posting some example shots here over the next few days, but its obviously a clear jump up from the 18-55 AL WR, which is already a very good 'kit lens'. I made this purchase as a long term 'investment' into the system, as I hope to get a future K1 or other FF model, and the deal was an opportunity. I see the focal length as still very helpful to me on APS-C in the meantime ... of course, I'm only able to assess the sweet spot areas of the optics, but reports based on K1 use indicate the edges are impressively sharp, with the main issue being vignetting ..... but that is fairly simple to deal with I think.

Handling is excellent ..... what I really like is the new placement of the focus ring behind the zoom ring, and its very easy to flick the fingers over to the focus ring for a bit of quick-shift. Focussing is smooth and very easy, but secure, and the zoom ring is solid and resistant to move, but reassuringly so, and very easy to grip and precisely set. Overall its a impressive piece of ergonomics I must say!

The autofocus is, perhaps inevitably for me, a revalation ..... my first move away from screw-drive, and it is clearly quicker ..... locks on in an instant ... and the lack of noise is amazing! Admittedly, apart from the DA18-55 my lenses are older and noisy anyway, which just makes the new DC motor even more of a pleasure to experience. I doubt the autofocussing could be heard more than a few feet away, and only then in very quiet conditions.

So ..... first thoughts very good indeed ..... I need more time to process some example shots, and I'll post some soon. Please add here any of your own impressions or questions about this new zoom lens ......

Nigel

Comment by McGregNi posted on HD Pentax D FA 28-105 at 01/09/2016 - 16:09

McGregNi
Blythman wrote:
..... Everyone is different, and others seem to prefer the others, but from previous discussions, I believe you'd prefer my honest views as opposed to platitudes
No! Give me platitudes, I want more platitudes

You're right Alan, there's far more interest and points for discussion when something critical is said, and that's exactly what I like .... David and Philip have offered those alterative responses as well, so that's all good.

I agree with all the points made, and they're all helpful, thanks all. I liked the general sweep of the Heath and its dense colour, and tried to show that in the wider ones, but equally I did try and get a 'point of interest' in some, which has added to those, and that's always a worthy ideal with landscapes .... this one from the previous set is probably what you were thinking of Alan ....

Comment Image


The ones with the rocks and the boathouse were all shot from the same position, and I experimented with different zoom settings, which explains why the tree was cut off .... and I suppose the wider ones work best with that as well.

The location will reward a lot more exploration, and it was a pity I couldn't spend more time there this trip .... fingers crossed for next time. I did get across the road and shot some small bays in Poole Harbour, just need to get the processing done ....

Comment by McGregNi posted on More from Studland Heath at 01/09/2016 - 13:52

McGregNi
Thanks Mike and David Pleased you both saw the photos.

Comment by McGregNi posted on More from Studland Heath at 01/09/2016 - 08:10

McGregNi
I'm sure there's no offense caused .... As the original poster I suppose I always try and refer to everyone's points, but its been a long thread, and of course you can be excused with the heart issues (and again I hope that goes well and helps you get back up to full speed with photography again).

Regarding the settings, then generally the fringing will reduce with smaller apertures ... But you don't have that leeway with BIF, and you don't want to go crazy with ISO either. It all adds to the reasons that I'm saying its best to move on from this lens for that type of shot. The lighting quality and angle plays a big part ... My example shots are in soft, side lighting ... That plays to the strengths of the lens.

But its hard to control that aspect when you've got birds darting around in the sky and contrast is often an issue. Whilst you're doing well against so many odds, I believe continuing with the Tamron for this purpose is a wasted effort and ' flogging a dead horse'.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Birds in flight shots using K-50 and Tamron 70-300mm f4-5.6 lens. at 31/08/2016 - 15:56

McGregNi
I really has Andrew and right through a long and warm summer. There are glimpses of the colour to be seen when traveling all around the area, but its on the Studland Heath where there's this great concentration and density.

Thanks again for your interest ...I know you would have had a laugh seeing me dashing around there like someone possessed, lumping my heavy loaded backpack plus giant Manfrotto across the dunes !

Comment by McGregNi posted on More from Studland Heath at 31/08/2016 - 09:14

McGregNi
Here's a few more hot off the press from my early morning visit in August to Studland Heath, Purbeck, in Dorset.

All with the K7, tripod, mirror up & remote control, ISO 100 .... I used the Tamron AF70-300 Di LD and the Pentax SMC A28f2.8 .....


Comment Image




Comment Image




Comment Image




Comment Image


Thanks for taking a look and for your comments and thoughts
Nigel

Comment by McGregNi posted on More from Studland Heath at 31/08/2016 - 00:08

McGregNi
Evocative images David, that capture the sense of place, all gleaming white stonework and barren openness. I like the use if foreground objects in Nos 2 and 4. Looks like you had a good trip !

Comment by McGregNi posted on The Essence of Santorini at 30/08/2016 - 23:57

McGregNi
Too good for the drawer, they need to be out and seen!

You've made the most of the colours here and got 3 strong compositions making the most of the little objects of interest.

Comment by McGregNi posted on 3 from Aberthaw at 30/08/2016 - 19:16

McGregNi
.... Oh dear, you're speechless !

Don't mind my forthrightness, it's in a good cause. I just want to help identify aspects of the lenses performance that can be harnessed to get the most out of it.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Birds in flight shots using K-50 and Tamron 70-300mm f4-5.6 lens. at 30/08/2016 - 19:00

McGregNi
That is absolutely rampant PF! I've said before, the lens has to be 'worked with', not against .... this type of shot is really 'against' and is wholly unsuited to the lens characteristics.

I get the feeling throughout this that you haven't wanted to hear what I was saying .... that you only wanted to hear what suited ..... (no unkindness, just an honest impression). You also didn't respond to the last four helpful posters, including myself and Peter who offered some new insights.

If you really can't get another lens, then fair enough .... but forget about these types of shots, especially in such light. Take another type of image that suits the lenses strengths .... here's a couple of mine where the lighting is such that the fringing does not occur, and I stopped down a little to F6.7 .... these conditions allow the great strength of the lens to come through, which is very good clarity and sharpness at the long end, even fairly wide open ....


Comment Image




Comment Image


I'm afraid that there is nothing to be done about the PF .... you might be able to reduce the colour but it has destroyed the outline of the subject with a haze. If you want to keep doing BIF in sunlight then you'll have to cough up and get another lens, as advised by the experienced people here. The autofocus performance of the Tamron also I feel will be relatively weak compared to some alternatives.

As has been said near the beginning of this thread, the Tamron AF70-300 is a poor choice for your intended BIF images.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Birds in flight shots using K-50 and Tamron 70-300mm f4-5.6 lens. at 30/08/2016 - 16:16

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo