All Forum Comments
Comment by golfdiesel posted on Poll - who would £1000 for a full frame K10D? at 29/11/2006 - 05:54
I had a play with my new nd filter
I always wondered how to capture the silky effect of moving water. I wish i'd had a tripod, but I'd say it isn't bad for 1/2 second handheld. What do people think?
This gallery is empty.
something isn't working properly..
Comment by golfdiesel posted on ND Grad filters at 06/12/2006 - 20:28
I am new to this subject, so I don't know exactly what to get.
I have seen a kit from Cokin, it a P system kit which features the adapter ring, holder and three gad filters, ND2, ND4 and ND8.
Will this make up for a nice kit to start with these kind of filters (perhaps I'll add in a polariser as well. what is best to buy? circular or linear?)
Comment by golfdiesel posted on ND Grad filters at 27/11/2006 - 16:16
Sadly they didn't have the sigma on stock with a Pentax mount, so I couldn't judge the optical quality.
I made my decision on the feel of the two units. The Pentax is quite a bit lighter and I must say that the DS feels good with the 16-45 attached to it.
The construction of the 16-45 is quite a bit better then the 18-55. It feels so much better. I didn't know that 2mm extra in the wide range would make such a difference. The 50-200 is great as well. It's nice and compact and it is nice and sharp as well.
So current line-up is:
DA16-45
DA50-200
A50-1.7
Sigma 50mm Macro 2.8 EX
Tamron 28-200
DA18-55
The 18-55 will not be used very much I'm afraid but putting it on ebay is useless as well since the price is so low when you buy it new.
The Tamron will be the lens I will use when going on long walks with a small bag. It's not the best performer, but hauling a complete setup around doesn't work very well.
Comment by golfdiesel posted on pentax 16-45 vs. Sigma 17-70 at 16/12/2006 - 13:48
I'll let you guys no the outcome, and I will try to find some ftp space where I can put up some RAW images so you can have a look at them as well.
[edit]
The 16th of december I am going make the testshots.
I am still in doubt which to buy.
If the construction of the Sigma is anything close to my Sigma 50mm macro then it would be hard to beat it in that point, that thing is built rock solid. The Pentax however is more compact and light.
Question to the 16-45 users, is the construction a lot different from the 18-55?
[/edit]
Comment by golfdiesel posted on pentax 16-45 vs. Sigma 17-70 at 30/11/2006 - 19:51
If the sun is shining I will point both lenses at the sun at different focal lengths. But since I live in the Netherlands, the sun isn't very much around... allthough it is now...
And I will make some shots at different focal lengths and different apertures.
I will be using a tripod offcourse.
Any other suggestions what to check out? I will offcourse check out the build quality and the overall look and feel of them.
Comment by golfdiesel posted on pentax 16-45 vs. Sigma 17-70 at 29/11/2006 - 14:03
I doubt if they are designed by the same people and/or produced in the same factory.
The new *lenses are designed the same, they even look the same. The debate is only if the coating is the same on both lenses, would think that the coating is the same, but it can very well be different.
I have visited a lens factory (for glasses and sunglasses) and there they produce different lenses for different customers on one production line with different coatings.
If they produce a batch of Tokina lenses and a batch of Pentax lenses the coating can very well be different without making it much more expensive.
Comment by golfdiesel posted on pentax 16-45 vs. Sigma 17-70 at 26/11/2006 - 20:29
Sigma claims having a new coating but I have still to see the first coating which can match Pentax' SMC coating in flare resistance.
Comment by golfdiesel posted on pentax 16-45 vs. Sigma 17-70 at 25/11/2006 - 09:54
People with a camera with a M42 thread couldn't use the K-mount lenses when they came out. The newer K-mount bodies could use M42 lenses through an adapter (has Pentax ever had a adapter by themselves?).
It could very well be a new step in the development, just like with the move from M42 to K-mount. I will not be surprised if the pre K10D bodies can't use the new lenses.
Making a lens with a USM motor and puting in the gears to make it work on an older body seems like a big effort and it will cost a great deal more I guess.
Comment by golfdiesel posted on pentax 16-45 vs. Sigma 17-70 at 24/11/2006 - 09:40
It will be a constant aperture zoom at f2.8
Anybody care to take a guess on what the pricerange will be? The 16-45 is at 389 Euro's now.
Looking at Tamron and Sigma lenses in the same focal length range and with a 2.8 constat aperture they are around 400 Euro's.
Tokina is allso scheduling a [email protected] for march 2007, but I don't know if it will be available for Pentax.
Perhaps I'll wait and see what the price on the 16-50 will be before shelling out cash for the 16-45...
[edit] I just found another site that the 16-50 will be a new DA* lens with USM motor, it looks the same as the Tokina lens... Will these USM lenses work on the older bodies? Or are they exclusively for the K10D and upwards?
[/edit]
Comment by golfdiesel posted on pentax 16-45 vs. Sigma 17-70 at 23/11/2006 - 20:42


I don't see the point of a full frame sensor, especially if you see the advances that are made with the aps-c sensors, the k10d is supposed to have less noise then the older units whilst having more pixels on the same area.
I see this whole discussion in the same light as the whole CCD vs. CMOS discussions that go around.
Every technology has pro's and con's. I am happy with a APS-C sized sensor, perhaps a pro would want the extra's you gain with a full-frame sensor but for the normal human beings like us here, I doubt that it will bring much.
People talk about the 5D as being in a complete different range in terms of image quality, but who says that it because of the full frame sensor?
These discussions go on and on and you will never know where it ends up. A couple of years ago a lot of people were hyped out about the then new sensor type from Foveon, the X3 in which every pixel can detect R, G or B so there is no interpolation done. In theory this gives a much, much better colour rendition. If it were all that great, why is Sigma the only producer which uses it in a SLR? To my knowledge there are/were only 4 consumer camera's which use this sensor. 3 from Sigma and one point and shoot camera from Polaroid...
I think you all know my conclusion, there is no chance whatsoever at this point in time that I will fork out around Euro. 1500 for a full frame camera body.