George Lazarette

Joined: 14th January 2004

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

George Lazarette
Feeb,

Over many years, the zoom ranges you mention became established on 35mm film cameras because a large number of people found them to be the ideal way to cover the most popular focal lengths.

On an APS-C body, the equivalent ranges are 16-50 and 50-135.

If you stay with Pentax, the 24-70 and 70-200 will not work very well because you will lose at the wide-angle end, and gain more than you probably need at the long end. You should probably, in other words, buy the 16-50 (or 16-45 or 17-70) plus the 50-135.

And you will find they are just as good as the Nikons you mention.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Why i am switching from Pentax to Nikon at 05/09/2009 - 14:03

George Lazarette
feeb wrote:
no your right, pentax have produced some brilliant lenses, but not the ones i want unfortunatly

if you can find me a 24-70mm f2.8 pentax lens - plus a 70-200mm f2.8 pentax lens then i will hang around for a bit hows that?
Well, there are such lenses, which you can get second-hand occasionally, but they were designed for film cameras. On an APS-C body, the equivalents are the DA* 16-50 and the DA* 50-135.

I suspect your tutor has the lenses you mention and uses them on a so-called full-frame body, which is where they belong. If he uses an APS-C body, then he has probably had the lenses for years and can't bear/afford to change them for something more suitable.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Why i am switching from Pentax to Nikon at 05/09/2009 - 13:51

George Lazarette
PentaxRocks wrote:
This is starting to get really sad now, I have both systems and which do I use more the Nikon if you must know.
That's fine, but I do note that you don't claim to own any of the best Pentax lenses.

Do you call yourself Nikonrocks on the Nikon forums you frequent?

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Why i am switching from Pentax to Nikon at 05/09/2009 - 13:46

George Lazarette
mikew wrote:
George with all due respect you can't know that Feeb has any sub-text conscious or subconscious.
Mike
You're right, I can't KNOW, which is why I said: "These "I'm changing brand" posts tend to have a couple of sub-texts (often subconscious, I'm sure):".

In other words, I was alluding to the genre of "I'm changing" threads, not Feeb's specifically, and the word "tend" leaves room for some such thread-starters NOT to have a sub-text.

Nonetheless, I do THINK that Feeb's post does contain such sub-texts, and if they are subconscious nobody can prove it one way or another.

It's my PERCEPTION, correct or incorrect, that the sub-texts exist that causes my irritation.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Why i am switching from Pentax to Nikon at 05/09/2009 - 13:44

George Lazarette
feeb wrote:

Plus a range of uber quality and beautiful lenses to boot
You clearly have no idea about the quality of Pentax lenses.

The 12-24, starred lenses, 50mm 1.4, and original Limiteds are not surpassed by any Nikon lens.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Why i am switching from Pentax to Nikon at 05/09/2009 - 13:34

George Lazarette
davidtrout wrote:
In the unlikely event of me ever leaving Pentax for another brand - I could only consider Nikon - I would just quietly do it without feeling the need to tell the world. It would be no one else's business other than my own.
As I closed the door behind me I would post a message on here thanking everyone for putting up with me and my pictures and for being such good company.
david
I think you have hit the nail on the head.

These "I'm changing brand" posts tend to have a couple of sub-texts (often subconscious, I'm sure):

1 "I'm a really good photographer, and need the very best equipment".

2 "If you're staying with Pentax, you're obviously not very demanding or not very good".

That's why I find them irritating, and the irritation is exacerbated by the fact that in some cases the reasons given for switching are not especially convincing.

In fairness to Feeb, she only started this thread because people had started questioning her on the "For Sale" thread. And I'm sure her sub-texts WERE subconscious.

But as a general rule, it is surely a better strategy to start a thread saying "I have such and such a problem" and then seeking opinions on the best way to deal with it. In some cases, the best advice would be to switch. But in some cases, it wouldn't.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Why i am switching from Pentax to Nikon at 05/09/2009 - 13:20

George Lazarette
"So go on, rip me apart - i'm ready for ya "

Sorry, I took your words at face-value. What I suspect you really meant was: "Tell me I have done the right thing because deep down I'm not sure".

And you're right not to be sure:

1. In a studio, you will normally get the best results using studio flash, not a Metz hammerhead.

2. Pentax flashguns allow synchronisation at any shutter speed.

3. Pentax picture quality at normal ISO is as good as or superior to just about any competing camera. And with a little practice you will find you can get very good IQ at high ISO too. See some of Peter Smith's pictures.

4. With few exceptions (like the current lack of a 200mm macro, and the range above 300mm) the Pentax lens range is now pretty good, and the quality is as good as or better than anybody's. Don't be fooled by the size of Canon's and Nikon's ranges. Some of the lenses are very old, and some only work on some models. Nearly all Pentax's lenses are new designs.

5. The point about Nikon lens "clarity" suggests that your PP technique needs work. You yourself expressed amazement at some parrot pictures by Unlocker recently.

link

6. A professional is somebody who makes their living from something. You have earned some pin money from selling some prints and seriously undercharging the going rate for doing a couple of weddings; which is, dare I say it, a bit "unprofessional".

7 You say that you want better auto-focus. Want and need are different things. Benjikan seemed to manage cover-shots for Vogue quite successfully with Pentax auto-focus, but if you DO need better AF then, as I suggested earlier, the K7 will provide it.

However, your mind is made up, albeit for rather dubious reasons, so off you go and good luck.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Why i am switching from Pentax to Nikon at 05/09/2009 - 12:46

George Lazarette
Well, you're not exactly modest:

"i am new at all this though a competent photographer as you can see by looking through the gallieries [sic] of my other work."

"i feel everyone deserves to have some wonderful pictures to take away with them on their special day."

Having looked at your site, I feel, like Nathan, that there is more to be got out of your gear than you are getting out of it at the moment. You are making a very expensive move, and in my view any perceived shortcomings of the K20D would be met by buying a K7 for a fraction of what you will pay for a new Nikon system.

But, it's your money.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Why i am switching from Pentax to Nikon at 05/09/2009 - 01:30

George Lazarette
Are you trying to correct the white balance on a small, already-reduced JPEG? If so, you would be better off going to the original, and working on that.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Photoshop RAW at 05/09/2009 - 01:04

George Lazarette
Sorry, Feeb, but I'm rather bored with people boasting about moving to another brand. Especially when they would do better to work on their own skills.

You can take snapshots with any brand of camera, so I don't suppose you will be any worse off, except financially.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Why i am switching from Pentax to Nikon at 05/09/2009 - 01:00

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo