George Lazarette

Joined: 14th January 2004

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

George Lazarette
Malo1961 wrote:
I am also confident HCB would have sacked the printer if that person wasn't capable of matching the final outcome to the idea of what HCB had in mind.
I'm sure that's true.

Quote:

Nowadays the field of play is so much larger. And so are the decisions that have to be made, before the file is ready. And with Raw you simply have to process afterwards to get the picture the way you want to.
I would agree that some adjustment is necessary to make the image look like what you saw. If you want an image that isn't like what you saw, then perhaps you should take up painting?

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Should we post-process? at 19/09/2009 - 19:43

George Lazarette
Hmm. I suspect that a career as a navigator is not in your future.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Not a plane at 19/09/2009 - 19:25

George Lazarette
You are going to lose a stop or two going to a 500mm lens anyway. Or, a few thousand pounds.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on SMC Pentax AF Adapter 1.7x TC from EBAY at 19/09/2009 - 19:11

George Lazarette
RR wrote:
I'm glad you answered your own Rhetoric there George. I thought it was going to be like picking teams for a schoolyard game.

your pick HCB, then I'd have picked AA, & so on & so forth. I wonder who the overweight unco-ordinated kid would have been left at the end ?
Good lunch, was it?

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Should we post-process? at 19/09/2009 - 19:04

George Lazarette
Malo1961 wrote:
If you want to stay on top of things, you have to PP your own work.
I cannot believe any photographer in his/her right mind would give away his files and leave PP to another. The big guys (Like David Noton) do, but those people are on his payroll. And even than, he has final control.

Sub-contracting the printing part is totally different. Wet printing and I guess digital printing is an art form of its own. You either do it yourself or let the specialist do it, by your rules and specifications.
It was the wet printing, indeed the whole D&P process, that I am talking about. If that was OK for many of the greatest photographers, then why is PP different?

I suspect that many of us press the shutter without having a clear idea what the final result is going to be. Then, with a fair bit of cropping and cloning and whatever we come up with something we think is presentable.

HCB had his stuff printed "whole", no cropping. He saw the final image in his mind's eye. He only needed a craftsman to print his work, not an artist.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Should we post-process? at 19/09/2009 - 19:02

George Lazarette
Post a pic in the gallery here, then link.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Image into post at 19/09/2009 - 18:48

George Lazarette
To my mind, it seems that to those who sub-contracted the printing (and it was many of the very best people, not only HCB), the art, the creative element, came before the pressing of the shutter.

There were also those for whom the developing was a large part of the creative process, but perhaps they were, in the main, pictorialists whose only aim was to capture physical beauty. Adams, Weston, et al.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Should we post-process? at 19/09/2009 - 18:47

George Lazarette
RR wrote:
If you wish creative control to be taken from your hands then why not hire a photographer to capture the image for you ? Or visit a stock agency & download one ?
Unfortunately, HCB is dead, or you could ask him that question yourself.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Should we post-process? at 19/09/2009 - 18:41

George Lazarette
An interesting first post, KFXP. Might I ask what you paid for the item?

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on SMC Pentax AF Adapter 1.7x TC from EBAY at 19/09/2009 - 17:49

George Lazarette
Should we post-process?

OK, that was the attention-grabbing headline. The full question is: should a good photographer post-process his own images, or should he leave it to a professional?

The question arises because I was consulting my photographic library (both books!) in response to a thread about winter reading. And in one I read that most good photographers (in the film age, long ago) sub-contracted their printing to a professional printer. I knew HCB didn't print his own, but I thought most photographers did.

And if film photographers didn't print their work, why should digi-togs PP theirs? Now I may, in this as in many things, be behind the curve, but I am not aware that professional PPers exist to any significant degree. Do they? Should they? Is it the future?

And is there something intrinsically different about digital post-processing as compared to developing a print? Is the image more about what happens after the shutter has been depressed? And if so, is it still photography?

And, moving from the philosophical to the practical, if PPers exist, where are they to be found? I have a picture of a bird that needs professional attention. Like HCB, I prefer to just press the shutter, then go for a beer. Or perhaps a pastis in his case.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Should we post-process? at 19/09/2009 - 17:35

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo