Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
Wrote the above as you were posting yours Stefan.

Re. your second post - what you suggest would retain the sharp detail. However, I'd still have a problem with the bokeh. Even if I don't apply any sharpening to the picture the oof area is affected detrimentally by re-sizing.

It's a pity I can't post the original file to actually show what I mean - but if I upload it on my Flickr account it will be automatically re-sized. I think I need a Pro account to upload large files, right?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Re-sizing (again) images and keeping detail and bokeh character at 15/11/2009 - 10:17

Dr. Mhuni
Jeez, I think I'm even deeper in the Circle of Confusion than I was before I read the link.

Maths was never my strong subject!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Re-sizing (again) images and keeping detail and bokeh character at 15/11/2009 - 10:07

Dr. Mhuni
I'm confused, Stefan. Yes the image in the Forum thread is smaller - but I've compared the original and re-sized versions on my screen at the same size and reduction has clearly changed the character of the shot.

Thanks for the link. Will take a look at that now.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Re-sizing (again) images and keeping detail and bokeh character at 15/11/2009 - 09:43

Dr. Mhuni
Very interesting to see what you have done Barry. And I see my initial instinct was completely wrong! Funnily enough, it works less well now - but I think this maybe confirms the idea about reading a pic from left to right. The reason why the original works better is because the figure is on the left, so the viewer places (slightly) greater emphasis on it. Or is this all in my head?! Actually, looking again, I think the second also works less well because the train is going out to the left.

BTW Barry, could you tell us how you achieved this - would be a very useful tool to have in the PP armory!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Lonely wait at 15/11/2009 - 09:24

Dr. Mhuni
Just looked at this again and realised that people are going to wonder what I'm going on about re. the noisy bottom and rendered children. As this version looks quite different to the original 4,800 pixel one. Hadn't spotted this yesterday - was in a rush to post this and my lens threads before going to pick up my daughter from a party, and I thought it appeared like this just because it was showing a smaller sized image. But looking again the re-sizing has really sharpened up the kids and the noise has gone.

If anyone knows how to re-size while keeping bokeh character and sharpness, please let me know in the thread I've started here link.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Assembly at 15/11/2009 - 09:02

Dr. Mhuni
I posted an image on the forum yesterday (here: link), without paying enough attention to how the re-sizing had impacted on the image. Looking again this morning I noticed how the children had been sharpened quite detrimentally. One of the things I like about the original was the way the oof children are rendered (not sure if this is bokeh - when does bokeh become bokeh?!) - in the re-sized version they just look slightly oof.

I had re-sized this the normal way I do - halving the size then sharpening. And this time I had been more restrained in sharpening than normal, but it still had this effect. So today I've tried to resize it in order to achieve a smaller file which resembles the original.

First, I tried really slight sharpening in two stages (from 4,800 to 2,400 & Unsharp Mask of 30/0.8/0, then to 1,200 and the same UM). The result was slightly better than above, but only slightly - ie. the kids were sharpened undesirably. So then I tried just re-sizing it to 1200 pixels with no sharpening. The result was still not right but in a different way. The kids were more blurred (which in this case is good), but not as much as in the original (bad) and their appearance just wasn't the same as in the larger version. Meanwhile, the Principal appeared less sharp (bad) - and as result the impression is of overall softness.

How the hell can I resize this image so that it appears like the original? Surely this must be achievable - I mean photos which combine sharp details with blurred backgrounds are a photographer's stock-in-trade.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Re-sizing (again) images and keeping detail and bokeh character at 15/11/2009 - 09:01

Dr. Mhuni
thoughton wrote:
Yeah, i saw these on your Flickr stream and to be honest I didn't agree with the comments on the candle shot. It's a good idea, but it needs better focus (my personal opinion, of course )

Nice blues in the gas fire shot but the burnt out highlights are bit extreme for my taste.

Hope you don't mind honest opinions, don't mean to be too harsh on you when you've just come over from the dark side!
I'm with Tim - with a bit of work, you could end up with some nice shots. It's the area illuminated by the flames which makes these images (or potentially so). I'd have less black at the top of both.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Just a two test shots at 14/11/2009 - 11:09

Dr. Mhuni
Given the current RRP - that would be a snip. Good luck!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Bigging up the DA17-70 at 14/11/2009 - 10:52

Dr. Mhuni
I read in a K7 review recently some mildly disparaging remarks about Pentax consumer zooms being fairly ordinary (not bad, but not that great either). It sparked my curiosity about how they compared to competitors' lenses (not so much the third party lenses, whose performance I know something of). Now it was always my impression that Pentax did pretty well with their zooms compared to Canikonly - though the price/performance ratio must have deteriorated of late. However, I'm not sure how I've formed this opinion (blind prejudice, perhaps:lol as I am totally ignorant of other camera mfrs' lenses. Anyway, I'd be interested to read the thoughts of those with better informed points of view.

BTW this isn't my attempt to start a thread that will burst into acrimony before finally being deleted - we had enough excitement last w/e.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax zooms and the competitions' at 14/11/2009 - 10:35

Dr. Mhuni
I'm liking this lens more and more and thought it was about time there was a thread in which its praises could be sung (I know I'm not the only Forum Member to rate it). Maybe it's because it's relatively new (and a lot more expensive) but it just doesn't seem to have attracted the plaudits that the DA16-45 has.

Optically it's only down side is the barrel distortion, which as Richard Day pointed out in another thread, leads to you losing more than just 1mm on the 16-45 after you've corrected. Images are detailed. Colour rendition's great. The bokeh's good. Wide performance is more than decent. And contrary to early reports I read, I've found the long performance to be excellent. See eg. link & link. Both these shots were taken wide open at 70mm and at high ISOs (800 + 400 - accidentally in the case of the first), and are minimally cropped.

It's also much better built than the 16-45 - a pleasingly solid hunk of glass.

And I'm sure mine is improving with age. The results I'm getting now seem to be better than when I first started using it earlier this year. Can this be possible? Could the climatic conditions here in Colombo have affected the alignment of optics slightly? I did quick tests on it when I got it, and it was fine - but maybe I should check again, to see if it really has improved.

The other alternative is that my ability to get the most out of it has increased. Hey, that would be nice!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Bigging up the DA17-70 at 14/11/2009 - 10:21

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo