Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
I have to say I agree with you Amin. And your point about whether someone aiming to get surreptitious images of kids would more likely use a discreet compact than a DSLR is well made.

Restrictions on photography - relating to both terrorism and paedophilia - in the UK seem ludicrously over the top. I'm lucky to be living somewhere where these aren't clouding what invariably is the perfectly innocent use of cameras to record treasured moments. At kids parties (and school functions) here, parents routinely bring and use cameras - DSLRs and compacts - which is how it should be. I guess this isn't the case in the UK any more.

And Tony, you make an excellent point in observing that a. the occurrence of paedophilia is probably no greater than it was 20 or 50 years ago; and b. that most instances occur within the family, or close family friends, and recent hysteria and the policy response has done nothing to reduce its prevalence.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Assembly at 16/11/2009 - 13:19

Dr. Mhuni
Thanks, Hefty.

johnriley wrote:
I have never had mould in a lens in the past several decades, and have never exposed any lenses to the sun. Expanding and contracting the elements and their support with heat from the sun doesn't seem like a good plan to me.

If you could get the UV light without the heat maybe, but you can't. Even UV lights designed to cure polymers give off huge amounts of heat. Possibly a couple of 3 second bursts with a Plasma Light would be OK.
John, I wouldn't be considering it either if I wasn't now living somewhere with such an awful climate. In just three months we've had mould on clothes, bags and leather items. I'm very glad I bought my Peli case when I was in the UK over the summer. TBH I think that, with the dehumidifier, this is sufficient to protect my equipment. However, for extra peace of mind I was investigating additional options.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on what causes the Fungus infection? at 16/11/2009 - 12:34

Dr. Mhuni
Many thanks for the feedback guys, and in particular for your detailed explanation of an appropriate set-up Banjo. That sounds like just the ticket - and if I had suitable nous I'd do what you say. Unfortunately, when it comes to DIY I've got two left hands (actually more like one:lol.

So that brings us on to Calcium Chloride - is this obtainable from a chemist, K10D? And what form does it take?

At the moment I've got something like this link, in my Peli case. No sign of any problems yet.

Though judging by what you say Hefty, perhaps it would be good to be exposing the lenses to the sun every so often. The reason why I haven't done this, is because I seem to recall reading somewhere that exposure to direct sunlight was bad for lenses.

If I am to expose them - I assume it will be best in mild early morning/late afternoon sun. Should I remove the cap in order to expose the elements to the sun, or is this not necessary?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on what causes the Fungus infection? at 16/11/2009 - 11:45

Dr. Mhuni
Cheers Nathan.

Tony - Blimey, you're making me feel guilty - I've often put up pictures of my own daughter (and sometimes her cousins). Do we really have to be so cautious? I mean, I can understand why one wouldn't post a photo if the child in it is scantily clad, but should we as parents really be so concerned about everyday pics of our offspring appearing in a public forum? (I'm not saying this is your view - just raising the question).

I understand the point about parental consent - but, assuming the innocent nature of any photos posted, doesn't this also raise issues about any image of a person being posted without consent. Should children be treated any differently than adults, that is? The current policy for adults being - if I'm not mistaken - that consent is required if the image is used for commercial purposes.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Assembly at 16/11/2009 - 10:38

Dr. Mhuni
I understand your point, Nathan. But given the nature of this photograph - the children are in a large group setting, oof, quite distant in the frame - I wouldn't have thought anyone could make a serious objection to it.

Perhaps you're right in suggesting I should have thought about the issues you raise before posting - I confess I didn't. But probably the reason why I didn't was the same reason why I would still have gone ahead and posted: this isn't IMHO in any way an exploitative or provocative picture.

I understand you're probably making a legal point as much as anything and advising caution, but I'd be interested to hear your's and others' views on this.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Assembly at 16/11/2009 - 10:07

Dr. Mhuni
Forgot to say - thanks everyone for all the feedback!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Assembly at 16/11/2009 - 09:40

Dr. Mhuni
Blimey, I go away for lunch and all of a sudden the comments are coming in thick and fast (well by the previous standards of this post at least:lol.

BTW, this was written before Amin's post (had just pressed Preview Update and saw yours appear, Amin) - you make some very good points but if I respond to all the posts I'll be at it all day. Actually thinking about it maybe this is just me being evasive, because I'm not sure I can address your concerns very well! Anyway, I need to crack on in case (like London buses) the next time I press preview another post will appear! So here's wot I wrote earlier:

Tim's highlighted both of the things about this photo that I really like - the cross pattern (almost like a flag); and the fact that the kids are paying absolutely no attention to the teacher addressing them, other than the girl in red (nor are the teachers)! And I love the many different things the kids are getting up to instead of listening to the teacher - this is a bit like all the incidental detail you get in a cartoon away from the main action. All this is of course more evident when viewed large - I really like the shot on full screen. And in the original I do like the way the kids are rendered - quite smoothly oof but with enough detail to work out what they're up to (but you'll have to take my word on that as the image I worked on was a sharpened jpeg, so I can't do what JR suggested in my other thread to this image). I understand it isn't immediately apparent what exactly is happening but with the title I thought there are enough clues for the viewer to work that out.

Re. chopping feet - I couldn't avoid this without losing the composition. I was pretty close to the teacher. And, even if the composition wouldn't have been wrecked, I actually don't think inclusion of the feet would have improved it. I wouldn't say the teacher was the main subject of the photo, but instead the interaction between the teacher and kids, and to optimise this I think I would do the same again (but crop a tad higher). There would have been too much teacher with the feet - though a longer lens from further away might have made a difference, but this wasn't an option.

I take your point about the face Mike. I do have a shot with him looking to one side, but he's looking out of the frame and doing something funny with his legs.

mikew wrote:

Gee I think I can beat 150 views no comment - not on this forum but on another where I delete them if they are met with blank indifference. As you say getting a negative response is better than no response.
I was only claiming the record for this forum!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Assembly at 16/11/2009 - 09:38

Dr. Mhuni
Thank goodness, an opinion!

Interesting what you have to say, Mike - and I assume this is representative of forum members given the absence of feedback (but not views). Though I'm not sure why someone has taken so long to say so. I mean there's no shortage of ropey photos posted here - attracting both negative and positive feedback. Perhaps I'm going to have to be nastier in my own comments in order to encourage others to be more forthcoming when I post a dud.

Having said that. I actually don't think this is one (yet:lol. And in the hope of drawing further commentary (from you or others) I'll address your points:

I think the focal point or points are fairly obvious. The teacher first (and not his bottom - my eyes go the head and torso first), followed by the interaction between him and the kids. And of course the kids and their postures etc. are an integral part of the image which I would expect the viewer to dwell on. As for cutting off the feet - I thought general opinion was that chopping limbs is bad at joints, which I haven't (though perhaps could have gone a touch higher here). But the lack of feet doesn't bother me here. The blue posts - these were really not something that jumped out at me before your comment. Having been sensitised to them now I find it a bit hard to assess - but you may have a point (though this is easily dealt with).

Anyway, critical or otherwise it is good to read someone elses' assessment (other than Tim's Flickr post). And thanks for saving me the ignominy of a photo post totally devoid of any response!

By the way, can I now claim the 'indifference record' of 143 views without a response - though it could have been up to 149 (as when I looked at your response the number of views stood at 150). Beat that Pentax Users!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Assembly at 16/11/2009 - 08:05

Dr. Mhuni
hefty1 wrote:

In fact lenses like the same sorts of conditions humans do, which makes sensible storage quite easy.
Just confirms my opinion about how un-sensible the weather is here in Colombo (temp. consistently 27-30c; humidity 65-85%). I have my kit stored away in a weathertight Peli case with a large dehumidifier inside. I know it's dark which isn't good, but there's no way I'm exposing them to this climate for any length of time. Have already had two coats wrecked due to mould in the three months I've been here. And am mildly paranoid about fungus attacking my lenses. Had a friend who lost £thousands of Nikon kit in Ghana just a few months after his arrival there.

If anyone has any tips on lens storage in high humidity conditions - these would be much appreciated. I had read in a very old (1980s) article by some jungle-based photographer that what I'm doing & occasionally exposing them to sunlight is a good idea. But I'm really not sure that exposure to sun is at all sensible.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on what causes the Fungus infection? at 16/11/2009 - 04:53

Dr. Mhuni
RR wrote:
Well 55 views & no comments. I'd much, much, rather have honest criticism than indifference.
Peanuts, Bob - my 'Assembly' post has notched up 143 views and not a peep (barring my own corrective) from anyone so far. Possibly an 'indifference' record? (BTW thanks Tim for your comments AND posting them on Flickr thereby not undermining my record!). Am beginning to wonder if sensitivity about taking pictures of children in the UK extends to making comments on photos featuring them?!

Apologies, Mike, for the distraction. You know my thoughts on this image. Like the idea but not the execution. Looking at it again, I agree that getting the ivy in focus (or DoF) to the tip is pretty critical.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on From today's graveyard jaunt at 16/11/2009 - 04:37

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo