Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
Neat shots - but the second is definitely better. (Not sure why you opted for the first... erm, first). I'd straighten it a little, though. It is amazing how sharp the man is in both, given the long exposure.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Work night shot at 23/11/2009 - 19:58

Dr. Mhuni
Daniel Bridge wrote:


How about Canikolympanosonycans?

This could go on forever...

Dan
What about Cakonly and Cakonlyians?!

Oh... and congratulations Chris. If only you were moving back to London (or, better still, Colombo - competition's not too stiff here, especially for Pentax).

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Some news from Watford! at 23/11/2009 - 19:51

Dr. Mhuni
Right, none of my conventional efforts has really come off, and I'm not going to get anything by Wednesday, so I'm going to have to post one of my more, erm... experimental shots:

Comment Image


Crime scene

Taken Sunday 23rd with the K20D, FA35 f2, ISO6400, f22, 0.8 sec handheld

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fortnightly Competition #29: CARS at 23/11/2009 - 18:47

Dr. Mhuni
Thanks Emily, pnjmcc, for muddying the water! I think I'm probably going to go for a compromise solution - cropping some of the grass off. Will try this later.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Where to crop at 23/11/2009 - 04:48

Dr. Mhuni
Not for me, I'm afraid. I think the diagonal lines probably work better - and the shell is crisper. But you have perhaps gone too far in trying for DoF, and lost one of the things I really liked about the first one - the bokeh. Also, I prefer the scale of the first - the smaller snail in the frame and (I think this is the case) taking the shot from slightly further away from the leaves. Also, looking at the two side by side, I think that the dark corners add some nice soft contrast - so perhaps in a diagonal shot I might be looking to have some of this in one corner perhaps? Or an area where the leaves were slightly shaded and darker in a corner? The blurred snail doesn't help in your latest shot either.

What I think this probably goes to how is how difficult it can be to re-stage a photo in order to act on comments. And also how, while comments might be valid, implementing them doesn't necessarily result in a better shot! Often I think they're helpful more to get you thinking about your photos and this may result in more success with a shot somewhere down the line.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Snail on a leaf - Re shot. at 23/11/2009 - 04:46

Dr. Mhuni
Thanks for the feedback. I figured people would prefer the second. Stefan's right, though - I wasn't happy with where the posters end up in the frame. Had kept the grass in the first for some context, but you're right it doesn't work at all in the second. Re. desaturation - I've already desaturated it quite a bit (you can perhaps tell from the rather faint blue of the poster in the top left) - but those posters are extremely red.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Where to crop at 22/11/2009 - 08:18

Dr. Mhuni
I did a square crop on this photo because I liked the vegetation poking out in the top right, because I liked the gap in the gate at the top, and because I liked where this placed the posters in the frame. However, I think there's too much featureless gate at the top. The question is where do I crop - assuming that is there is enough interest in the shot (I think there is but by all means say otherwise, if you think so)?

Comment Image


I did try this, but I'm still undecided (and yes I can see now I've accidentally oversharpened this in re-sizing - more noticeable in the large size):

Comment Image

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Where to crop at 20/11/2009 - 11:36

Dr. Mhuni
mikew wrote:

I don't think anything less than an Australian front row rugby player would obscure that door so it has to be part of the shot.

Mike
Yes, but if there are no front rows passing, someone else might at least obscure some of it!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Where's Wally? at 20/11/2009 - 07:22

Dr. Mhuni
I'd go for the K20D over the K7, then you'd have a lot more flexibility with your budget. You would lose faster focusing, but the image quality is just as good.

Re. wide - I personally wouldn't look beyond a DA12-24 (or the Samsung one). Although it's not fast at f4, I've always been amazed at how well it performs in low light. They're very expensive at the new price - though you might pick up a Samsung for around £500. (If I was getting a D90 the Tokina 12-24 - basically the same lens, re-badged - would be one of my first purchases).

For zoom - the DA55-300 is an excellent lens for the money, though I'm not sure that this is the type of lens you're after.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Advice please: K7 + lenses at 20/11/2009 - 02:10

Dr. Mhuni
The only place I can spot is - though I'm not sure how you'd have done this, as it's a very large area, and I'm not sure where you'd have cloned from - the door. The bottom panel seems to be reflecting something that's not in front of it. The top panel I find confusing - though you surely couldn't have cloned it. Are those posters behind the glass or reflecting in it (and if so where from?) - and is that a wheel hub? The other place it could be is towards the bottom of the model - some of the lines don't join up there, though that might be the thing itself.

Re. the shot. I think impotentspider's right about the potential of the location and it being worth going back. In this one, for me there's a bit too much pavement - I'd want to crop (or preferably frame it) higher (but then you chop the guy's legs off). You'll have to encourage pedestrians to walk closer to the shop window. I'd be trying to get one to obscure as much of the door as possible - which is pretty utilitarian and horrible!

Oh, forgot to say, I disagree about the reflections. I think they're an important part of the image. I like the figures standing and sitting in particular. If I did go back I'd be looking to have the same, and even exploring the possibilities of using reflected figures as a counterpoint to the model instead of someone walking past (if it's a place where people naturally congregate this might even be easier - and you could get rid of the pavement).

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Where's Wally? at 20/11/2009 - 01:44

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo