Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
I understand your point David. But it begs the question what criteria are being used to judge? As this is a photography competition, for me these should be aesthetic first - ie. what makes the best photograph on the theme of suffering, not the subject that is suffering the most.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Again? (rant) at 16/02/2010 - 13:19

Dr. Mhuni
Okay say he is - though I'm sure they'd be just as happy to earn income from shots by Don McCullin, Robert Capa, Bill Brand etc. etc. But is little Magnum really in a position to brainwash a gullible public? I think not.

As I said, surely a much more logical explanation for HCB having the reputation he has is that the man was hugely talented. Not that it's the product of a devious conspiracy by Magnum to sell books/images.

To my eye, his mastery of composition and light is self evident in his best work - this has nothing to do with hype.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Analysing famous pictures at 16/02/2010 - 13:05

Dr. Mhuni
Does the 'Magnum machine' have that kind of clout? What do you have in mind some kind of artistic conspiracy theory?!

There are also many other talented Magnum photographers apart from HCB. Why might the 'machine' single out him?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Analysing famous pictures at 16/02/2010 - 12:35

Dr. Mhuni
IMO it was HCB's uncanny ability to be in the right place and time and know exactly when to press the shutter that made him the 'photographic genius' that he was.

Bret - I don't think art is an entirely subjective matter. For eg., most of us would agree that Police Academy V has less artistic merit than Lawrence of Arabia. Not all perhaps. But I wouldn't want the person who didn't controlling programming on the BBC.

Re. the hype about HCB. I'm not sure who exactly might benefit from building an undeserved reputation for a photographer such as HCB? It is surely more logical that he has developed the reputation he has because he was bloody good at what he did.

Personally I came upon him when I took up photography as a serious hobby a couple of years ago. I've actually read very little about him - so I wouldn't say I was exposed to any hype (particularly not in Addis Ababa or Colombo, where I've lived for the past two years). But for me the quality of his photos is self evident when I look at them. Not all of them, of course, but an extraordinarily large number of them.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Analysing famous pictures at 16/02/2010 - 12:16

Dr. Mhuni
I love Marmite. I can see why others don't. I also love HCB but cannot for the life of me work out why other photographers fail to recognise the man's talent. HCB was a bona fide, solid gold photographic genius. Period. And it has nothing to do with being French or owning a Leica.

I got an HCB retrospective ('The man, the image & the world') before Xmas. After reading the OP I went to leaf through it to look at the St. Lazare shot again, and was once more staggered by the number of astonishing images the book contains. He simply had an extraordinary gift to recognise opportunities for memorable images in the real world. And I don't find his images 'arty' in any way - they seem to me to epitomise the very essence of photography as a medium and are not generally contrived images in the way much art photography is. After all, he specialised in street photography above all.

I find looking at this book both inspirational but also slightly depressing. While I probably have equipment that far exceeds his in sophistication I recognise that I will be hard pressed to capture images that come anywhere near the best of HCBs. Though I live in hope.

Regarding the St. Lazare shot. I wouldn't let the cobblers that was uttered in the TV programme put you off it. Art critics/theorists have a tendency to see what they want in an image. I'm sure HCB - either at the time of composing or in retrospect - had no such thing in mind. I've looked at that image on countless occasions and 'broken Europe' has never come close to sugggesting itself to me. It's simply a brilliant example of street photography - and the capture (dare I say it) of a 'decisive moment'.

BTW your connection didn't work - you can see the photo here - link - although the reproduction is much poorer than that in my book.

What makes it great for me? The perfect reflection of the man. The anticipation of what is about to happen (but forever won't as people look at this image). The figure looking on. The glassy quality of the water. The gritty urban context. I could go on, but I'll stop there. And IMO, though highly memorable, this isn't even one of his better photos.

Of course, taste is subjective, HCB may not be everyone's choice of savoury spread. There are many other great photographers. However, for those of you who don't get HCB - check out this book at a bookshop/library, and see if you're still untouched by his images. For those who aren't - alongside the anti-Marmite brigade - as far as I'm concerned it's their loss.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Analysing famous pictures at 16/02/2010 - 04:46

Dr. Mhuni
Perhaps it can be pointed out to Promhandicam what the judge's responsibilities are? A third week without comments might risk setting a trend. Though as a veteran of the comp in the Forum days (though recently inactive), I'm sure Promhandicam is well aware of what's expected.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Again? (rant) at 15/02/2010 - 18:58

Dr. Mhuni
I have to say that I'm glad I didn't enter this week as if I had I'd probably be feeling much the same as you are Nathan. What is particularly disappointing is that the judge has a track record of entering the weekly. Surely he has observed the effort put in by previous judges week in, week out (well most weeks, that is:wink, to assess the images and offer their reasons for singling out particular photos. Having himself received feedback on numerous images he has previously submitted, one would have expected that he do the same, but no such luck.

And, like Hyram, I am still waiting for an internet connection to be established so that we can receive the comments on last week's! I have to confess that the thought of judging a photography competition on a mobile phone left me baffled.

I agree with David about newbies working out what is expected of them prior to entering - however, I'm not sure that judging responsibilities are mentioned anywhere.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Again? (rant) at 15/02/2010 - 18:39

Dr. Mhuni
The mint with a hole


Comment Image


Taken yesterday with the K20D, FA35 + Raynox DCR-150, f3.2, 1/100, ISO 250

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Entries for Fortnightly Competition # 35 - "Design Icon" at 15/02/2010 - 06:06

Dr. Mhuni
I don't mind the flowers - but the dark area at the top isn't pretty, or the rock? in the f/g. In the end, though, even if you like the flowers - isn't this just an image full of bokeh with no real focal point?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Over exposed but... at 13/02/2010 - 10:06

Dr. Mhuni
No problems Phil, especially when you've made such a big difference. That's much better, though possibly a little light now. What did you do, exactly? Clearly I should try something along these lines.

Not sure I understand your point about 'mirroring'.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on A wintry image from Sri Lanka? at 13/02/2010 - 09:44

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo