Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
Pentaxophile wrote:
The MTF graphs look very similar at f4. The problem is, the Tamron 17-50mm has them both beat!
If I was buying a wide-mid zoom now that's the one I'd probably go for. That Photozone test sharpness is borne out by so many photos I've seen from this lens (and peoples' experience). Though it does lack Pentax colours - & 20mm.

But given the OP already has the 17-70 he can probably upgrade his equipment a lot more profitably at other focal lengths.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on K5 / KX / K10 which 2 would you keep and why? at 02/03/2011 - 11:28

Dr. Mhuni
Rataegeoff wrote:
Thanks for the thoughts on the wide to normal zoom. I wonder if anyone has checked the 60-250* vs the kit 50-300 telephoto zooms on either the KX or the K10?

I haven't seen too much about the DA*60-250 on here for a while. Is it really worth the money? Will the K10/KX bodies focus quickly enough compared to those bodies linked to the DAL 50-300?

Of course there are always sad stories about technology not working as it should. I have the 50-135 DA* and for me its been a beauty -others have reported issues. I think if I was going to spend £1100 on a tele zoom I would certainly expect flawless performance and a marked jump in IQ.

I can see that there's lots to balance and it will serve me well to keep out of the camera shop for a few more days!

Decisions, decisions......
As I understand it, the 60-250 is on a par with the 50-135, which would mean it blows the DA55-300 out of the water. I don't have either DA*, but my Sigma 50-150 (very close in IQ to the DA* apparently) clearly outperforms my DA55-300 on my K5. The only thing that stopped me getting a 60-250 is its' size (and a remarkably cheap Sigma).

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on K5 / KX / K10 which 2 would you keep and why? at 02/03/2011 - 10:05

Dr. Mhuni
Tyr wrote:

I find there is a big difference between the 16-50 and 16-45. The 16-50 is sharper by a fair bit, faster, weather sealed and quiet. The long end is not as good as the wide. It is amazingly sharp from 16-24 and drops off slowly from there.
That's strange as from what I've read about the 16-50 people tend to say it is good from about 24mm. Similarly, I've never heard anyone complain about the sharpness of the 16-45. Perhaps sample variation can account for your experience with both, Tyr. I know tests don't tell the whole story (and what I've said is based mostly on users feedback), but the Photozone stats seem to indicate that the 16-45 is the sharper lens throughout the range:

link

link

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on K5 / KX / K10 which 2 would you keep and why? at 02/03/2011 - 10:00

Dr. Mhuni
Rataegeoff wrote:

The DA*16-50 is one lens I haven't checked out thinking that maybe the 17-70 was already a suitable step up from the K10s kit lens.
Personally, I'd say that the DA*16-50 was a bit of a red herring. The DA17-70 is a good lens which apparently performs better wide (though not at 16), is significantly less bulky (and fits 67 not 77mm filters) and has a handy extra 20mm. The 16-50 is supposed to be the better performer longer (though not after 50mm:wink.

I've never used one, and I know that many people love the 16-50. However, someone here - was it Pentax Dan - did a thorough comparison test of the 16-45 & 16-50 a while back, and the 16-45 more than held its own. Given that the 17-70 is an improvement on the 16-45 in every way bar barrel distortion, then I think you already have a more than adequate wide to medium zoom.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on K5 / KX / K10 which 2 would you keep and why? at 02/03/2011 - 04:51

Dr. Mhuni
Boeforce - SRS definitely do give VAT refunds if you're exporting the goods out of the EU. You get your VAT form stamped at the airport and send this to them and they process the refund.

Frogfish - don't bank on getting all your VAT back. Most retailers use some third party administrator to process the refunds which results in your receiving only around 10% of the VAT. Used to be much more than this on bigger purchases, but the amount now is immaterial and you always end up with around 10%.

Happily (though not for you as the Sigma is at Ffordes) SRS do not use the third party admin, but do it themselves and do refund the full amount. Yet another reason to shop at SRS.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Sigma 50-150 and 1.4x converter at 01/03/2011 - 08:26

Dr. Mhuni
I've tried it with a Tamron 1.4 (which works with Pentax SDM - in fact with all my other lenses) and the Pentax 1.7. Neither worked with the 50-150 - not just focusing but aperture info too. And if I'm not mistaken the Sigma TCs don't either.

Nice lens, though - a snip at £399.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Sigma 50-150 and 1.4x converter at 28/02/2011 - 12:49

Dr. Mhuni
Out of interest, what have you got against the Middle East? Probably the least crime-prone area in the whole world.

Even Africa - outside Nigeria and a handful of other places - probably isn't quite as dark as it's cracked up to be. Though you're unlikely to be getting many bids from there, unless it's from people like me. I never had any problems with parcels to Tanzania, Ethiopia and Kenya. Though I never got any camera stuff (other than filters from HK) there - noone would send them.

BTW I hope Sri Lanka's somewhere you will ship to, as I've found the parcel system to be excellent for both sending and receiving.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on How to get MAX prices on auction sites... at 26/02/2011 - 17:38

Dr. Mhuni
Probably my favourite lens - it's uber-sharp and the understated colours it produces are wonderful, both of which are evident in your first shot. Bokeh's not bad either, eh?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on First images from my Pentax A 50mm f/2.8 Macro at 26/02/2011 - 09:28

Dr. Mhuni
I prefer the DA Ltd's!


BTW to the OP - I do think it's worthwhile going for something faster than 2.8 if you can, as that gives you greater versatility (as far as both DoF & available light goes). In answer to your question - there is a noticeable difference between f2.8 & 1.7, never mind 1.4 (which I have no experience of).

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Sigma 50f1.4 vs Pentax 40f2.8 at 24/02/2011 - 15:00

Dr. Mhuni
Been tempted by one of these for yonks but have restrained myself, as my LBA is bad enough without going down with CBA! But underwater photography does open up a new world of opportunities. I've been using an old point and shoot with Dipac water casing (little more than a reinforced ziploc bag in reality) in Greece over the last few summers. Optically it's not ideal, but the unusual perspectives can be great. Here's a few of mine - I imagine with the W90 the image quality would be significantly better:

Comment Image


Comment Image


Comment Image

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Optio W90 at 24/02/2011 - 12:48

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo