All Forum Comments
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Weekly competition #90 - Heavy at 29/03/2009 - 14:47
Can anyone tell me what the advatantages of the 724 over the 700 are?
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Arctic Butterfly at 29/03/2009 - 14:43
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on cleaning a uv filter at 29/03/2009 - 14:42
Like yours a lot too Aiki - good detail on the foreground ice and wonderful contrast with the buildings/sky in the background. What lens did you use for this?
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Weekly competition #90 - Heavy at 27/03/2009 - 05:14
Can anyone tell me if I need an SL700 or an SL725?
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Arctic Butterfly at 27/03/2009 - 05:09
Thanks Hyram, I appreciate the offer.
I won't have much time to go out photographing. And my friends I'm staying with have a newly acquired bridge camera, a Panasonic. So if the withdrawal gets too tough there is some mild remedy at hand.
Prieni
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fortnightly Competition no # 12 : Comments. at 26/03/2009 - 13:04
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Weekly competition #90 - Heavy at 26/03/2009 - 12:37
Now I wonder where Promhandicam got to?
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Missing persons report. at 25/03/2009 - 05:44
On the downside, Martin might need warning about a probable shortage of early entries – that is if he’s not looking at this thread (I avoid looking at comments when judging as per the old informal rule, although I’m not sure that this applies anymore). If the theme is best shot in the fortnight then I guess the entries will be slow to appear, as people will hold off posting a shot they like early in case they surpass it before the deadline! And if Prieni's right about us improving all the time - then the shots we'll be taking in 13 days will be better than those taken today!
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fortnightly Competition no # 12 : Comments. at 19/03/2009 - 12:00
GlynM – Amaryllis
Good detail, colour and exposure on flowers, and a nice plain background. It’s an unusual choice of subject to be going wide on. Given that you were shooting at 10mm, you must have got extremely (and I mean extremely – I just tried it with some flowers at 12mm!) close to capture this. Unfortunately, though, it doesn’t give me much sense of width. It’s a shot that could have been taken with a longer lens from a greater distance.
bforbes – Angel of the north
Now this is a great subject to give the impression of width. The span of the wings is nicely accentuated by the angle – with the discrepancy between the left and right ones (due to perspective) really giving an idea of the scale of the thing. I also like the juxtaposition of the three bold colours of the sky, the sculpture, and the grass. However, I think you could have accentuated both of these elements by cropping a bit tighter on the left – in particular to remove some (and clone away the rest, perhaps) of the trees in the bottom corner. I’ve tried this, and in my opinion you’re left with a much more simple, but striking image without the clutter of the trees (I know they’re small – but they make a surprising amount of difference). Also, I’d clone away the patches that appear on the right wing – the small dark one at the end and the ones closer to the body which look like flare (though perhaps they’re faded areas on the wing surface itself?).
RR – View from a stubbed toe
Even better choice of subject for ‘Something wide’ – a gob! And one open to its maximum extent too. I like the stretch of the chin caused by the angle of the shot and the closeness of the camera. Brilliant detail in the mouth – your dentist would no doubt be appreciative. It’s a nicely inventive shot which does weird things to your face – could be a picture of some new race in Doctor Who, with a face dominated by a huge bearded mouth and an odd pointy top to their heads! However, for me, this gets at what would have made it an even better photo – some detail of the face beyond your nose. If you could have got some of your eyes/forehead/hair in, that would have enhanced the photo as a picture of a pained human rather than an extra terrestrial. Not sure if this could have been achieved by a slightly different angle, or whether even with an all-compassing fisheye this is asking too much at the same time as keeping the chin/mouth in the frame.
Malo1961 – Delfzijl monument detail
This is a great, kind of disorienting, picture. When I first looked at it, I had the impression that it was of something much larger – I envisaged the cobbled bit in the middle going down to the sea, and being wide enough for a vehicle. But inspecting it again, it must be much smaller – a footpath? All the different lines moving across the picture can confuse the eye. But they’re great – the way the barrel distortion has accentuated the curves of the monument (?), the cobbles sweeping down almost river-like from right to left, and the rounded brown rocks/cement in the right foreground. There’s a nice sense of space too, both width (helped by the lines moving across the picture) and depth (with the rocks in the foreground). And the juxtaposition of textures and colours are great too (though I might have de-saturated the picture a smidgeon – IMHO that enhances it just a bit). All in all, a lovely photo.
jondc – Old can decaying
Another great choice of subject for this round. I like the composition. Great low perspective – you must have got dirty taking it. The can appearing towards the back of the frame gives excellent sense of depth. Meanwhile, the track and hedge crossing the right of the frame are well positioned. The sky is blown out, of course – but given that you need some sky for the composition, and its overcast nature at the time when you took it, there’s little you could have done about this. I see you de-saturated the edges – presumably to emphasise what’s in the centre. However, there isn’t really the colour in the centre either to make it really stand out. Don’t know if the edge de-saturation has helped or hindered here, but I do feel the photo needs a bit more colour for oomph.
Hyram – Small fishing boat
No shortage of colour in this one! Lovely contrasting blues of sky, paint & water. There’s a good sense of depth too, with the prow of the boat stretching in from the right. And the textures in the photo are great too – the weathered wood and flaking paint on the boat, the rusted anchor(?), and the pier in the foreground (though it would have been good if this could have been in focus). The shadows of the ropes going down the side of the boat are also great. Just two things spoil it slightly for me – the bank of the river(?) behind the boat and the beam with the light/aerial on towards the back of the boat. Not sure what you could have done to address this – dropping the aperture would have achieved more background blur (which might have helped), but you would have lost important depth of field on the boat/pier; and compositionally it doesn’t look like you had much scope. Although, maybe getting down a bit lower would have helped – and also accentuated the way the lines of the pier and boat converge, which I like.
Mikew – Surprisingly sunny Barmouth
Lovely light on the sand/water and nice sweep of the chain going from front to back which takes advantage of the wide angle. Good depth of focus (and sharpness – as you observe). However, for me the image is rather narrow and constrained. Also, every time I look at it I have the urge to straighten it a little – for me it just seems its alignment should be adjusted slightly to make a more harmonious picture. As it is, everything is sloping down to the right.
Beakynet – Fisheye
There’s a lot to like in this photo. The fisheye effect works really well with the subject, resulting in some interesting shapes that draw us into the picture and gives a real sense of being there and looking up at the monument(?). Meanwhile, the combination of exposures has resulted in a nicely balanced range of colours and shades. My only issue is sharpness. It’s possible that the lack of it perhaps suits the subject. As it is, though, I keep wondering what it would have looked like if it was really sharp.
Prieni – Wide area communication
Again, there’s a lot to like in this one too. Technically – as ever Ralph – it’s spot on. Great lighting and exposure, wonderful clarity and colour, nice combination of textures. It’s a strikingly well put-together image. Apart from one curious thing – for me, at least. It should be the other way up! As it is, my first instinct on seeing the photo is that the phone should be falling. If you rotate it fully, the image works better – not only for gravity’s sake, either. You also get the suggestion that the red thing that the phone is resting on are shaped like lips, the way the phone curves parallel with the shadow is accentuated, and – in relation to this fortnight’s theme – there is a bit more of a sense of width because the phone is in the foreground. By the way – what lens was this shot with?
Rob – Market scene
There’s lots of movement in this shot, which is great. The two arcades coming towards the camera and off to the right, the two striding pedestrians heading down each arcade who look like they’ll probably narrowly miss each other somewhere near the table with the romper suits, the other pedestrians dotted throughout going at an apparently more leisurely pace (pity you had to cut off the one entering frame right). I would have liked to have seen more of the rather attractive glass roof, which I think would have helped the balance of the picture too. But I can see why you haven’t been able to do this – those pesky converging verticals at wide angles. I find this is one of the chief compromises I am always having to make at wider angles – to either frame a shot with everything I want in place, or to have those lines nice and horizontal. It also might have been nice if you could have increased the shutter speed to freeze the striding pedestrians by upping the ISO – but you probably didn’t have time for this, and, in any case, it’s possible you might have lost sense of movement at the same time as the blur.
Now to judgment. You lot have made it really tough, as there’s a lot that I like in this fortnight’s crop of photos. But here goes...
First, Malo 1961 – Sorry Martin, but you’re going to have to judge again! I thought your shot was a wonderfully composed combination of shapes, textures and colours, which also nicely exemplified the width of angle (even though it was shot at the narrowest angle of all entries).
Second, Prieni – Brilliant technique resulted in a striking shot.
Third, Hyram – Great combination of colours and textures.
Commended: RR & Beakynet
Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Fornightly Competition no.11: Something wide at 18/03/2009 - 19:37

