Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
I like the shot but those hands just don't look quite right to me. They look nothing like the last pair of bloodstained hands I saw in a window.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Something totally different.... at 07/09/2009 - 12:57

Dr. Mhuni
A few points to address from the above.

If Pentax are going for a niche, then how small can they afford that niche to be? R&D, and manufacturing, costs for new bodies and lenses are no doubt large and would require a reasonably substantial base of Pentax customers in order to remain a going concern.

Meanwhile, the pricing of the bodies doesn't indicate this strategy. If Pentax were going for a high-end niche then surely they wouldn't be pricing the bodies so competitively? Rather the body pricing seems to indicate that - like other manufacturers - they have identified that the profit is in the lenses. Only problem being that the price of Pentax glass is such that any newbie investigating the options would surely think twice despite the value represented by the bodies.

However, there is one important caveat. This only really seems to apply to the UK and (to a lesser extent?) continental Europe. Check out the prices of Pentax lenses on Amazon US and you'll find that they aren't that much more expensive (in US$) than they were a year ago (when I was investigating the possibility of buying from the US). At the current exchange rate, most of the lenses are around the price in the UK before the recent hike. Also, prices from Ebay sellers in the Far East don't seem to have increased much. So perhaps Pentax have just decided to pursue a different strategy in those parts of the world where they don't sell in large quantities? If so, that's bad news for us!

Re. Sigma increases - perhaps these weren't consistent across their full range, but of the lenses I am aware of the increases haven't been too significant. For example, the 10-20 went up from about £330 to £390; the 17-70 from £220 to 245; the 105 macro from £305 to 375.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax pricing strategy seriously wrong? at 07/09/2009 - 02:04

Dr. Mhuni
I'm afraid I don't think that Pentax 12-24 is representative, John. It must be stock bought at the old price. I think that SRS or Park Cameras (both of which are dealers offering competitive prices on Pentax products) prices much more accurately reflect the current state of play. SRS were able to retail old stock of the 12-24 and other lenses at the old price until they ran out in June.

By the way, the Sigma 10-20 f4-5.6 can be got for £389 at SRS.

bforbes wrote:
If you look at the value of the Yen against Stirling link over the last 12 months, you can appreciate where some of the increase comes from. Compared to this time last year a 20% price rise would just maintain a status quo for Pentax. At the low point in Jan 09 it would have required a 37% rise. I don’t believe any company could absorb Price reductions of that size
Sure the £ depeciation has to have an effect. However, other Japanese manufacturers including tokina, Sigma & Tamron (they're all Japanese, right?) haven't hiked their prices anywhere near as much.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax pricing strategy seriously wrong? at 06/09/2009 - 14:51

Dr. Mhuni
Just noticed the end of my post was rather confusing, as Don didn't write the last two paras. So it should read thus:

Don wrote:

unless of course the original pricing was the mistake, and they realised that bargain basement pricing degrades the percieved value of the product, and won't keep the company solvent in the face of competition with larger production/advertising and distribution channels.... so going niche, premium, upscale, somewhat exclusive and catering to a more well heeled customer is the 'Right" pricing strategy.....

Dr. Mhuni wrote:

Possibly, though this strikes me as a very risky strategy. Pentax might be able to keep existing users, but a sound business plan would identify the necessity of attracting new customers for long term viability. Meanwhile, as I see it some lenses are strikingly poor value at present - even if Pentax were pursuing a premium strategy such as you suggest.

At £1,000 for the 12-24 I'd be expecting a lens with a maximum aperture of f2.8 and better build quality. Tokina seem to agree. I love this lens, but if I were in the market for an ultra wide zoom at the current pricing I'd have to go for the Sigma or Tamron. Similarly, I'd have gone for the Sigma 17-70 instead of the DA17-70. Are Pentax going to sell enough lenses at the current price in order to compensate for lost sales such as this?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mhuni

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax pricing strategy seriously wrong? at 06/09/2009 - 14:22

Dr. Mhuni
It seems to me that the recent hike in Pentax lenses (in the UK at least) is a grave error in strategy. Another thread, in which this issue was raised, has now been blocked due to it getting rather acrimonious (though not on this subject). So I thought this part of the discussion might be continued here.

Here are the relevant posts from the other thread:

Dr. Mhuni wrote:

Reflecting on the original subject, I have come to the conclusion that there are good reasons to switch to Nikon. Oddly, a prime consideration for me would be to get 'Pentax' glass at a reasonable price. If I lost all my gear tomorrow, I'd be sorely tempted to get a Nikon D90 or D300 and Tokina lenses - notably the 12-24, 16-50 & 50-135 - at half the price of the DA equivalents. I am hooked on Pentax. And what got me hooked in the first place was that for the money - at least up until the recent price hikes - it's been a no-brainer as to which brand offers the best vfm (though Olympus too are very competitively priced for the spec). However, the current prices of Pentax lenses in the UK surely threatens what small market share it has managed to build. To take the DA12-24 as a prime example. No doubt it's a great lens, but does it have the speed (or build) of a lens with a RRP of £1,300?

johnriley wrote:

Quote:
To take the DA12-24 as a prime example. No doubt it's a great lens, but does it have the speed (or build) of a lens with a RRP of £1,300?
We have never, until very recently, worried about the RRP of any lens. The actual price is the "street price" and these have been stable for so long we've all but forgotten about RRPs.

If you wanted to buy a 12-24mm today, you would pay slightly more than £600 for it if you really looked. More expensive than it was, sure, but nowhere near £1300.

Dr. Mhuni wrote:

John,

Of course your point about RRP not being what one would usually pay is correct. However, my point about Tokina vs. Pentax was made with actual prices in mind. While there may be a few old stock 12-24s around at £600, SRS (which usually offer the best prices around) currently have it up for £999. The Tokina, meanwhile, can be had for £475 from Warehouse Express (not necessarily the cheapest outlet - just one I've consulted in a recent AP, though they do have the Pentax for £519 [by contrast Park Cameras, usually a good source for Pentax, have it at £949]).

IMHO the latest price increases on Pentax lenses were quite disproportionate. Speaking to the guys at SRS recently, they seemed to think that the prices would come down at some point to a more reasonable price. But we'll see. And as indicated above, if I were to start afresh, I'd certainly think twice about whether I'd opt for Pentax (notwithstanding how happy I am with my current kit).
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mhuni

George Lazarette wrote:

There is absolutely no doubt in my mind that Pentax lens prices will come back to more reasonable levels. Somebody, somewhere, in Hoya has made a drastic mistake with the new price structure, and market forces will soon put that message across very strongly.

G

Joe S wrote:

johnriley wrote:


[...]

If you wanted to buy a 12-24mm today, you would pay slightly more than £600 for it if you really looked. More expensive than it was, sure, but nowhere near £1300.
"...if you really looked."? But honestly, why stick with Pentax as it has become so hard to find anything at a reasonable price. I don't know the situation in Manchester, but personally, even though I live in a European capital city I cannot find Pentax on the shelves. When I walk around, looking at the shopping windows I often see Canikons (and various lenses) on sale and I kick my legs for staying with Pentax. I have come to the conclusion that value for money is not quite the selling point I thought it was.

So to be quite honest, even though I am quite happy with my gear today I don't think I would have gone the same route today. And that's not because "the grass is always greener...", but for practical reasons.

I agree with George and others that Pentax could do the job as well as Nikon, when it comes to IQ. But then again, Feeb has not yet stocked up on lenses, so I think it is a rather rational thing for her to do - switch now, buy some piece of mind. As the doctor points out, she could start with a Nikon body and the Tokina lenses.

I know, some will say it is a great anti-Pentax conspiracy but the way I see it Pentax IS challenged hugely. Come on guys, don't say you don't see it?! The way Pentax dropped the goodwill for K-7 before it even hit the shelves have to be one of the most amazing home goals ever!

You have to just love the limiteds so much that you ignore the warning lights blinking. I'm happy to say, I'll still stick around, though

Greytop wrote:

Thoughtful and interesting post Joe and I agree with pretty much all you say. I just hope George is right and Hoya/Pentax realise the mistake they have made with pricing.

Don wrote:

unless of course the original pricing was the mistake, and they realised that bargain basement pricing degrades the percieved value of the product, and won't keep the company solvent in the face of competition with larger production/advertising and distribution channels.... so going niche, premium, upscale, somewhat exclusive and catering to a more well heeled customer is the 'Right" pricing strategy.....
Possibly, though this strikes me as a very risky strategy. Pentax might be able to keep existing users, but a sound business plan would identify the necessity of attracting new customers for long term viability. Meanwhile, as I see it some lenses are strikingly poor value at present - even if Pentax were pursuing a premium strategy such as you suggest.

At £1,000 for the 12-24 I'd be expecting a lens with a maximum aperture of f2.8 and better build quality. Tokina seem to agree. I love this lens, but if I were in the market for an ultra wide zoom at the current pricing I'd have to go for the Sigma or Tamron. Similarly, I'd have gone for the Sigma 17-70 instead of the DA17-70. Are Pentax going to sell enough lenses at the current price in order to compensate for lost sales such as this?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax pricing strategy seriously wrong? at 06/09/2009 - 14:10

Dr. Mhuni
Don wrote:
Greytop wrote:
Thoughtful and interesting post Joe and I agree with pretty much all you say. I just hope George is right and Hoya/Pentax realise the mistake they have made with pricing.
unless of course the original pricing was the mistake, and they realised that bargain basement pricing degrades the percieved value of the product, and won't keep the company solvent in the face of competition with larger production/advertising and distribution channels.... so going niche, premium, upscale, somewhat exclusive and catering to a more well heeled customer is the 'Right" pricing strategy.....
Possibly, though this strikes me as a very risky strategy. Pentax might be able to keep existing users, but a sound business plan would identify the necessity of attracting new customers for long term viability. Meanwhile, as I see it some lenses are strikingly poor value at present - even if Pentax were pursuing a premium strategy such as you suggest.

At £1,000 for the 12-24 I'd be expecting a lens with a maximum aperture of f2.8 and better build quality. Tokina seem to agree. I love this lens, but if I were in the market for an ultra wide zoom at the current pricing I'd have to go for the Sigma or Tamron. Similarly, I'd have gone for the Sigma 17-70 instead of the DA17-70. Are Pentax going to sell enough lenses at the current price in order to compensate for lost sales such as this?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Why i am switching from Pentax to Nikon at 06/09/2009 - 13:53

Dr. Mhuni
I'd go along with Marcus - the angle of the cork just doesn't sit right in the frame as is. I'd also perhaps explore portrait options. I'd probably remove the hinge, though it's hard to be too prescriptive without seeing the scene in the flesh.

Is it my screen, or is there some strange effect occurring along the shaft of the upper nail. It's the one part of the pic that's hazy. I've had this occur as a result of flare (I think), but I don't see how flare could have had this effect concentrated along the length of the nail?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on unlucky 13 at 06/09/2009 - 13:36

Dr. Mhuni
Like the skies in 1 & 6. IMHO, I'd say 2-5 are lacking a little contrast, though perhaps this has something to do with the angle of the sun in relation to the camera?

I'm finding 1 a bit confusing - is that how the tower actually is? It looks stretched, but wouldn't be (would it?) in that part of the frame. Is it because you've used perspective correction for converging verticals? Or is this simply an effect of shooting as wide as 10mm (I only go to 12mm in my kit:wink?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on I love my new Tamron at 06/09/2009 - 13:24

Dr. Mhuni
Nice shot Aiki. While I can see why you have kept the upper part in - interesting effect on the water - I reckon Martin's right. If you crop above the highest leaf you do retain some of the water effect.

B&W nice too - though it would be interesting to see it in colour.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on waterlily at 06/09/2009 - 13:05

Dr. Mhuni
johnriley wrote:
Quote:
To take the DA12-24 as a prime example. No doubt it's a great lens, but does it have the speed (or build) of a lens with a RRP of £1,300?
We have never, until very recently, worried about the RRP of any lens. The actual price is the "street price" and these have been stable for so long we've all but forgotten about RRPs.

If you wanted to buy a 12-24mm today, you would pay slightly more than £600 for it if you really looked. More expensive than it was, sure, but nowhere near £1300.
John,

Of course your point about RRP not being what one would usually pay is correct. However, my point about Tokina vs. Pentax was made with actual prices in mind. While there may be a few old stock 12-24s around at £600, SRS (which usually offer the best prices around) currently have it up for £999. The Tokina, meanwhile, can be had for £475 from Warehouse Express (not necessarily the cheapest outlet - just one I've consulted in a recent AP, though they do have the Pentax for £519 [by contrast Park Cameras, usually a good source for Pentax, have it at £949]).

IMHO the latest price increases on Pentax lenses were quite disproportionate. Speaking to the guys at SRS recently, they seemed to think that the prices would come down at some point to a more reasonable price. But we'll see. And as indicated above, if I were to start afresh, I'd certainly think twice about whether I'd opt for Pentax (notwithstanding how happy I am with my current kit).

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Why i am switching from Pentax to Nikon at 06/09/2009 - 09:53

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo