Canada_Rockies

Joined: 17th March 2009

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Canada_Rockies
Depth of field tables are valid only for a particular size of enlargement/print. The ones on lenses are most often defined for an 8x10 print viewed from 10 inches. The "standard" is the circle of confusion at the specified magnification.

Using the APS-C sized sensor we have, an 0.02" circle of confusion on sensor would be magnified 1.5X to achieve the same print size and become 0.03". I find that stopping down one more stop comes pretty close to offsetting that, but having peered through viewfinders checking depth of field by eye since 1961, I use the dof preview lever on my k10d or MZ-s or SF-1, whichever I happen to be using, to visualize my hyperfocal or other depth of field.

Frankly, my definition of acceptable circle of confusion may not be the same as yours. Try out the various ideas in this thread, and come to your own conclusion.

Comment by Canada_Rockies posted on Depth of field-hyperfocal distance at 02/05/2010 - 03:50

Canada_Rockies
Mike-P
There is a look to Pentax lenses. It is the lens rendering that really makes the difference. Even M lenses look good on either film or digital bodies.

Others have spoken of (early 70's) lenses being still compatible. All lenses with K bayonet mount can be used on any Pentax K mount SLR. The caveats are: First: if there is no "A" position on the aperture dial, Av is available only wide open and M must be used to allow the lens to stop down. You also have to enable the aperture ring. Second: Only very late film cameras can use a lens that does not have an aperture ring (except at minimum aperture). Third: A DA lens may not cover the entire frame when used on a film camera, leading to terrible vignetting, but you can crop to the DA frame, and get the same results if you, for example, would like to compare your favourite DSLR to your MZ-S film camera with Fuji Velvia.

For those who really complain about digital noise, this would be an interesting exercise: use the same lens on both cameras, shoot the digital (even my K10D) at ISO 1600, then shoot Fuji's ISO 1600 colour print film with the same lens and image.

However, with a relatively inexpensive piece of metal, the Pentax M42 - K adaptor - all screw mount lenses back to 1957 can be used. With another very hard to find M39 - M42 adaptor installed in the M42 - K adaptor you can use Asahiflex lenses as well. The Asahiflex was a single lens reflex without the prism to allow eye level viewing (Pentaprism + Asahiflex = Asahi Pentax), and was Pentax DSLR's Great Grandfather.

Comment by Canada_Rockies posted on why pentax is better? at 02/05/2010 - 03:32

Canada_Rockies
My current set of lenses has a rather wide gap, but works for me. I gave my daughter the lens that used to fill the gap. I own several others, but these are the ones I use most. The surprise in here is the 50-135 + 1.7X
The results actually startled me. The Flickr set is here link


DA 12-24
DA* 16-50
DA* 50-135
F 1.7X AF (above lens becomes 85-230 f/4.8 with fine tune auto focus and great image quality.
M 100/4 macro (becomes 170/6.8 semi-auto focus)
M 400/5.6 (becomes 680/9.5 when pushed)

Comment by Canada_Rockies posted on 'Perfect' set of lenses? at 02/05/2010 - 03:22

Canada_Rockies
Kris, that was the problem I was having, and what we are discussingin this thread. Others on another forum of which I am a member (PentaxForums.com) suggested that substituting the screen from an *ist D would resolve the problem with wonky metering on my K10D. I tried the LL-60 *ist D grid screen (I use grid screens in all my cameras), and it did resolve the problems with my two M lenses, the 100/4 macro and 400/5.6 telephoto. They now meter as expected across the entire range.

There was some discussion that the problem was not with the metering but with the mechanicals that stop the lens down not being linear with the older lenses and linear with the DA series. I took a series of shots with the 400 using "Sunny 16" exposures, and all were the same. They are here

Flickr 400 exposure test

Comment by Canada_Rockies posted on Problems using aperture ring at 25/02/2010 - 20:18

Canada_Rockies
iceblinker wrote:
I'm not claiming everyone gets a non-linear problem. It may depend on the particular lenses.

I got a non-linear problem with my *ist DS and the original screen and Pentax-M 100mm f2.8 and Pentax-K 135mm f2.5. So I don't believe changing the screen will fix everone's problem.
Pete, I can believe that you found the problem you have. For both my M lenses (400/5.6 and 100/4 macro) all my exposure metering problems quietly went away when I installed the LL-60 screen. I have just received my M42>K adaptor and a (hard used) SMC Takumar 55/1.8. I should be able to try them out over the weekend and see if I have any problems with metering. I shouldn't because the lens will be in stop down metering only, but one never knows.

Comment by Canada_Rockies posted on Problems using aperture ring at 25/02/2010 - 18:24

Canada_Rockies
iceblinker wrote:
The *ist D, *ist DS, K10D and K20D have pentaprism viewfinders, so I can believe they can take the same focusing screens.

The rest have pentamirror viewfinders, so I can believe it if they need a different size of screen.
I never thought of that aspect! Thank you for pointing it out. Perhaps the Pentamirror viewfinders do take a different screen. I do know from the Pentax Forum gang that the older screens make the camera work much better when lenses are set to a specific aperture on the lens.

The screen is slightly darker than the original K10 screen, and is linear in response to the light. My manual lenses meter correctly with the older, darker, screen. Response is correct at all apertures, contrary to the claim above that the response is not linear. It also has not lost its accuracy metering with my DA series lenses, which was something I was worried about.

I have read speculation that the brighter screens are the cause of the metering problem, and I can believe it. I also have more accurate depth of field preview with the older screen. The k10 default screen does not accurately portray the depth of field to me at wider apertures. It seems to hit a depth of field and then hold it all the way to the widest stop. As I use the optical preview, and have done for some 49 years now with Pentax cameras, I am more concerned with accuracy than brightness.

With the LL-60 *ist D screen, my metering and viewfinder have returned to what I expect, whatever the reason may be.

Comment by Canada_Rockies posted on Problems using aperture ring at 25/02/2010 - 16:46

Canada_Rockies
iceblinker wrote:
Why do Katz Eye supply different screens for different models?

See http://www.katzeyeoptics.com/cat--Pentax-DSLRs--cat_pentax.html

"Even though the screens look similar, many will not interchange!"
I have no idea why Katz Eye do that. The screen from the *ist D works and fits identically on my K10, even though Katz Eye say the K10 needs a different screen. The K7 is probably different because of 100% viewfinder coverage, but I don't own a K-7 so I cannot test it out.

Comment by Canada_Rockies posted on Problems using aperture ring at 25/02/2010 - 01:07

Canada_Rockies
iceblinker wrote:
The fact is that many of us do experience a non linear problem. I don't see how a different focusing screen can fix a non linear problem. I had the problem with an *ist DS anyway (non linear), with the original screen.

I suspect that some users don't get the problem, or not so seriously, because there is something different about their particular lenses.

I thought the K100D and K200D take a different size screen, or is that not so?
No, the same screen fits all.

Comment by Canada_Rockies posted on Problems using aperture ring at 24/02/2010 - 21:24

Canada_Rockies
iceblinker wrote:
The *ist DS screen doesn't fit all other models, and anyway can't solve the non-linear problem that some of us get with some lenses.
Cameras up to and including the K20 can use the *ist D screens. I have no problems with non linear responses on either of my lenses. I did have a mild problem at the smallest apertures (22,32,45) on my 400, but had it cleaned, lubed and adjusted and now it exposes exactly the same whatever stop I select.

Comment by Canada_Rockies posted on Problems using aperture ring at 24/02/2010 - 19:33

Canada_Rockies
Are you sure you are metering at the aperture you have set? I have two M lenses that I use with my K10d, and I have two ways of metering. The quickest is to set the aperture desired and press the green button. the camera will set the shutter speed following the program default mode. I have my program mode set to MTF, so I get the standard program settings with manual lenses that the camera does not know the MTF aperture settings for.

The second, and I prefer it when I have the time to use it, is to use the optical depth of field preview. This puts an exposure meter into the viewfinder while it is held over stopping down the lens.

The last thing that will get you is that with the standard focusing screen the exposures are off the wall. They can be over at one setting under at another and spot on at a third. With the LL-60 screen I bought on eBay, my exposures are perfect with all lenses. The screen is out of the *ist series of DSLRs. If you are going to be using manual apertures to any great extent, this is the way to go. I use my M 400/5.6 and M 100/4 macro a lot.

Comment by Canada_Rockies posted on Problems using aperture ring at 24/02/2010 - 19:03

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo