aminstar

Joined: 30th December 2008

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

aminstar
whelmed wrote:
Sorry to be academic, can't help myself, but the term that should be batted around regarding this is called Moral Relativism. An interesting read for about 60 seconds if you're keen. The crime-scene photographs seem to fall under normative relativism.

Anyhoo, back to thesis writing.
How about the practise of Sati?
Can the term be applied here also as "Moral Relativism"?

Surely there are certain things that are evil, no matter what culture it is practised in.

And I am sorry I do not agree with Ruth Benedict's view regarding ethnocentricism, that morals do not exist — only customs do.

Comment by aminstar posted on I met a policeman one morning. at 18/05/2010 - 14:59

aminstar
I agree, what is immoral in one society might just be the norm in another one. But its also interesting how when something is seen generally immoral in a society (arabic culture as an example springs to mind) they still would carry on doing things without any restrictions or even not going through major trouble of hiding it from the general public knowledge, only because they are rich.

If it happens to be a foreigner doing something as simple as kissing in the public view they are likely to be imprisoned.

Prime example here is this guy who spent over a million riyals in a Dubai club or gathering of some sort. I think it comes to over a quarter of a million british pounds if my calculations are correct. It really makes a disturbing viewing, at least for me. link

Comment by aminstar posted on I met a policeman one morning. at 18/05/2010 - 14:34

aminstar
George Lazarette wrote:
Interesting story, Amin.

However, I think the photo didn't lie; it merely didn't tell the whole story. And knowing the whole story doesn't make the photo less powerful, or less horrible.

Terrible things happen in war. That's why it should always be the very last resort. And this photo reinforces that message.

G
Well, I was just quoting the words of the photographer himself who took the photo.
But I tend to agree with your point that it doesn't tell the whole story. Perhaps the term "misleading" is more appropriately applied here.

I for one spent years thinking something totally different since I saw that photograph but the moment I read the full story the tables turned. Many would probably have done the same as the general under the same circumstances.

Comment by aminstar posted on I met a policeman one morning. at 18/05/2010 - 13:25

aminstar
George Lazarette wrote:
Sometimes old-fashioned is better than new-fangled.

I think that war photographers walk a very thin line. The two famous Vietnam photos (the one of the burning child, and the other of the man being shot in the head) were by any standards a gross invasion of privacy. But by bringing home the horrors of that war to the public that financed it, they probably were justified.

G
This is a tricky one George. The one particularly of the man being shot which was photographed by Eddie Adams really should have been left out from that example as being justifiable. And also its a clear example of how a photograph can lie. And I will let Eddie Adam's own words say it as he put it in the General Nguyen Ngoc Loan's (The man shooting) eulogy.

Quote:
I won a Pulitzer Prize in 1969 for a photograph of one man shooting another … The general killed the Viet Cong; I killed the general with my camera. Still photographs are the most powerful weapon in the world. People believe them, but photographs do lie, even without manipulation. They are only half-truths. What the photograph didn't say was, "What would you do if you were the general at that time and place on that hot day, and you caught the so-called bad guy after he blew away one, two or three American soldiers?" General Loan was what you would call a real warrior, admired by his troops. I'm not saying what he did was right, but you have to put yourself in his position.

…This picture really messed up his life. He never blamed me. He told me if I hadn't taken the picture, someone else would have, but I've felt bad for him and his family for a long time. I had kept in contact with him; the last time we spoke was about six months ago, when he was very ill.

I sent flowers when I heard that he had died and wrote, "I'm sorry. There are tears in my eyes."

--Eddie Adams
More about the whole story behind that famous photograph which earned Eddie Adams the Pulitzer Prize in 1969 here

Comment by aminstar posted on I met a policeman one morning. at 18/05/2010 - 08:43

aminstar
Mike-P wrote:

Have you ever read a Canon forum?

I joined one a while back when looking at different options .. they have no sense of humour whatsoever .. in the end I banned myself.
I agree entirely , sense of humour is really something that abounds here in this forum and it makes a jolly great place , and friendly also.

Mike
Mike-P wrote:

H in the end I banned myself.
Which one was that?

Comment by aminstar posted on Time to say goodbye at 17/05/2010 - 16:05

aminstar
johnriley wrote:
That was not the reason either Amin, as you are well aware.
John, I am not saying that he was banned due to what he was posting at least here in the forum, its obvious that something more must have occurred that got him banned. All I am saying is agreeing with thoughton that he was definitely annoyed and kept on posting comments reflecting his annoyance and those comments were critical but not abusive.

I did not pass any judgement on whether he was rightly or wrongly banned. Surely you have a duty and a very difficult one I admit to keep control around here and keep tabs on things so that it doesn't get out of hand.

NOTE: sorry John forgot to add that I definitely am not aware of the reason why he was banned. You are wrongly assuming that I know

Comment by aminstar posted on Jessops at 17/05/2010 - 14:55

aminstar
thoughton wrote:
It seemed pretty obvious he was going to get banned after all the furious posts he has been making in various threads over the last day or two! I think he was quite annoyed
Yes, he seemed annoyed particularly because his posts kept being deleted, and it was mentioned earlier by a forum member that although his posts seemed to be pretty critical but they didn't seem abusive. We do know when abusive or childish posts are used around here and in those instances their ban has been quite well received generally by most members, and quite rightly deserved.

Comment by aminstar posted on Jessops at 17/05/2010 - 14:14

aminstar
cardiff_gareth wrote:
will I now be banned for saying that :
Very possibly yes

Comment by aminstar posted on Time to say goodbye at 17/05/2010 - 11:57

aminstar
sam-joseph wrote:
Crikey Carl, look at the major drama your post has caused!
Usually a goodbye post does give initiation to a major drama in the forum.
The whys and whats etc are reactions that tend to follow up. You just have to briefly glance over threads like that and notice the number of pages it then keeps running, until of course the moderators decide to step in.

But I must say though that mostly they are kept within civilized verbal tones, with exceptions of some odd comments here and there, but otherwise all within the limits of decent expressive comments.

I agree also that the topic is highly explosive so perhaps its time to have a "Explosive topic" section in this forum for these type of threads

Comment by aminstar posted on Time to say goodbye at 17/05/2010 - 11:29

aminstar
Mongoose wrote:
on at least one forum I've been part of over the years, just about everyone who has posted in this thread would have been banned by now
You mean including good old George too?
I personally think most of the members if not all of them who have posted in this thread have behaved quite well. Didn't notice anything out of extraordinary deserving a ban. But then I might have missed some posts as I read that comments have been deleted.

Comment by aminstar posted on Jessops at 17/05/2010 - 08:53

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo