Prime lens focussing problems

Miniman
Posted 08/02/2009 - 17:05 Link
Hi, I have bought a 50 mm f1.7 Pentax manual prime for the shallow depth of field. I am problems focussing with any consistency, in fact I get better results through the bottom of a milk bottle. I have the same problem with another manual prime (Chinon 50 mm ). I have done all the tests, Newspaper on wall, on and off tripod, all apertures, everything. At f22 the results are awful. During these tests I have also used the 18-55 kit lens manually and the results are excellent, which shows I can focus. I am using a Pentax K10D which is superb with all the autofocus lenses I have tried, manually or otherwise. If anybody can help tell me where I am going wrong I would be extremely grateful. By the way, in my 30 years of pre-digital I only ever had manual lens.
iceblinker
Posted 08/02/2009 - 17:16 Link
1. Do you EVER get sharp results from these prime lenses? If never, then both lenses could be faulty.

2. Are you trying the same apertures that you use with your other lenses?

If yes to both questions, I can't think what the problem could be.

If trying larger apertures with the primes, focusing will be more critical and tricky and will need a good eye or some trial and error. A Katz Eye focusing screen does make it easier.

Remember that these fast prime lenses are naturally a bit soft wide open. You'll need to stop down to about f2.8 to get very good sharpness.
~Pete
mikew
Posted 08/02/2009 - 17:24 Link
Are these primes M42 fit or bayonet?

Mike
pschlute
Posted 08/02/2009 - 17:24 Link
Hi

The smaller and darker viewfinder of a DSLR can make manual focussing harder than what you are used to with a 35mm camera.

A couple of points first, f22 wont give you the sharpest image because you will be suffering from diffraction. f5.6-f8 is generally where lenses are sharpest. But to pin down focus issues you should test the lens on a tripod using both manual and auto-confirmation to see if there is a problem with the lens. Use widest aperture for this test.

If you can focus manually fine with other lenses then your lens must be faulty.

Just a thought: what is the widest aperture of the autofocus lenses that you can manually focus with ?

It may be that at f1.7 you are just not accurate enough, but at f3.5 the DOF hides this fact.

A split prism screen is the way to go, it worked for me.
Edited by pschlute: 08/02/2009 - 17:28
Miniman
Posted 08/02/2009 - 17:32 Link
I do get some sharp images, but it only seems to be in any one session. I mean 1st session okay, change for another lens, replace for 2nd session and the results awful..Soft is not the word, we are talking well out of focus. If I set up the lens to f22 and focus on an object 25 feet away, everything between 8 feet to infinity shoulc be in focus (according to the barrel markings). Not so, nothing in focus, but using the kit lens okay. Surely both my primes cannot be faulty for 60% of the time.
Edited by Miniman: 08/02/2009 - 17:38
Mannesty
Posted 08/02/2009 - 17:40 Link
You haven't answered mikew's question. Are these M42 screw thread primes, or bayonet?
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
pschlute
Posted 08/02/2009 - 17:41 Link
Ok , so we are talking about seriously mushy , not just missing focus by a smidgin.

If it was 100% off I would say bin the lenses, but the fact that it works sometimes and not others is very odd.

Are you using shake reduction? and are you correctly telling the camera the correct focal length when you mount the lens ??
Edited by pschlute: 08/02/2009 - 17:42
Bob and his Pentax
Posted 08/02/2009 - 17:42 Link
Hi,

When focusing manualy are you using the green hexagon as a focus confirm or just when it looks OK through the view finder?

If the latter then it may be that you have not got the diopter setting for the eyepiece set correctly leading you to believe that it is in focus when its not.

Alternatively to check your manual focus technique set up camera on tripod a measured distance from target (eg 2m from newspaper taped to wall) and use the focus scale on lens to set a distance and take the picture with manual focus on camera (do ensure that axis of camera lens is exactly at right angles to the wall too)- I would try a stop or two off of max aperture to experiment then go to full aperture to see how much DOF reduces.

good luck
Bob
Good luck

Bob

Pentax user since 1978, Digital since 1997.
Kit includes: K-7, K20D, K10D, *istDS, full set DA* lens, etc
Miniman
Posted 08/02/2009 - 17:42 Link
I have done comparisons at all apertures with 2 manual + 2 autofocus lens manually. Only the manual primes give me problems. Both primes are bayonet mount. I have used o right angle magnifier on the view finder, I have checked the diopter setting. I am now going to set the lens/newspaper distance according to the barrel markings and try Bob's idea.
Edited by Miniman: 08/02/2009 - 17:48
iceblinker
Posted 08/02/2009 - 17:46 Link
There's more to it than depth-of-field. f22 results in softness due to refraction. It may be that the primes happen to be affected more by refraction than your other lenses.

You'll get the best results with these fast lenses at f4 to f8.

The fact that you get SOME sharp images from them proves that they are not turkeys. I reckon it's just a matter of understanding their qualities and taking as much care as possible with focusing.

Ensure the glass is clean as well. Check with a bright white light.

The Pentax 50mm f1.7 should be at least as sharp as your 18-55mm at 50mm at f5.6.
~Pete
Mannesty
Posted 08/02/2009 - 17:49 Link
You still haven't answered mikew's question. Are these M42 screw thread primes, or bayonet?
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
johnriley
Posted 08/02/2009 - 17:51 Link
Quote:
f22 results in softness due to refraction
Diffraction - the effect of the light trying to pass through a tiny aperture acuses speading of the light at the edges.
Best regards, John
pschlute
Posted 08/02/2009 - 18:31 Link
Miniman wrote:
I have used o right angle magnifier on the view finder.....
I think I see the problem
iceblinker
Posted 08/02/2009 - 19:01 Link
Both at f5.6 with flash, 100% crops, best of several focus attempts on K20D, JPEGs (Natural with medium sharpening), no post processing:

Pentax-A 50mm f1.7:
[IMG]http://i493.photobucket.com/albums/rr298/lime501/Tests/K20D0662.jpg[/IMG]

Pentax-DA 18-55mm II at 50mm:
[IMG]http://i493.photobucket.com/albums/rr298/lime501/Tests/K20D0677.jpg[/IMG]

Just a quick rough test - that proves nothing except that it's possible to get the old MF prime in focus!

Thanks for the "diffraction" correction, John.
~Pete
Edited by iceblinker: 08/02/2009 - 19:04
womble
Posted 08/02/2009 - 19:10 Link
Miniman wrote:
I have done comparisons at all apertures with 2 manual + 2 autofocus lens manually. Only the manual primes give me problems. Both primes are bayonet mount. I have used o right angle magnifier on the view finder, I have checked the diopter setting. I am now going to set the lens/newspaper distance according to the barrel markings and try Bob's idea.
Mannesty wrote:
You still haven't answered mikew's question. Are these M42 screw thread primes, or bayonet?
Bold my edit.

Best wishes, Kris.
Kris Lockyear
It is an illusion that photos are made with the camera… they are made with the eye, heart and head. Henri Cartier-Bresson
Lots of film bodies, a couple of digital ones, too many lenses (mainly older glass) and a Horseman LE 5x4.

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo