K20 sensor clean on start up

jackitec
Posted 13/08/2009 - 20:47 Link
If you use the same lens and don't change it very often I wouldn't use it at start up, I change lenses quite often so I use it but it will cause a certain amount of ware on the camera and only time will tell how much, all mechanical parts ware out eventually normally 5 years.
George Lazarette
Posted 13/08/2009 - 21:08 Link
If Pentax thought the wear was significant, I doubt that they would have provided an "on at start-up" option.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
jackitec
Posted 13/08/2009 - 21:51 Link
The sooner they wear out the more cameras they will sell, (I corrected my spelling) when I worked in IBM most computers were designed to last around 5 years and today's cameras are just computers with a lens attached if they didn't wear out there would be no repeat sales and no more Pentax, that's why all camera companies keep bringing out new models because they know that their cameras will wear out and go out of date and lack all the the new refinements that new models have, they are just trying to stay in business, all electronic companies have the technology planed well in advance, they bring out little bits of advancement to keep the numbers ticking over, If one company brought out all the future upgrades now that they have planed most companies would go out of business,IBM had technology 20 years in advance of most computer companies and could not release it, but I shouldn't be telling you that but I don't work for them now so it should be OK,
regards,
Jack.
Oggy
Posted 13/08/2009 - 22:04 Link
OK Ladies and Gents - think of it this way. Rumours are that the the mean number of operations between failure of the camera is 100000. Now if every time you took a picture you took another, is the camera going to last as long.

Maybe since operating it will eventually cause it to fail, they should not have put a shutter release button on it.
Comment Image
jackitec
Posted 13/08/2009 - 22:23 Link
If they didn't put a shutter button on it it wouldn't wear out and they wouldn't sell any more Pentax Cameras so don't use the button if you want it to last
Jack.
patrickt
Posted 14/08/2009 - 01:05 Link
I've never used the shimmy on startup feature. I live in Oaxaca, Mexico, and we're famous for dust and soot. So far, neither has been a problem with my K10D. If I get dust spots, then I shimmy, use my blower, and I'm good to go. I have nothing against using it on startup but I have no reason to do it.
mikew
Posted 17/08/2009 - 15:02 Link
Oggy - I have been away so I missed the question about starting a car 3 times in a row. I do that when off road, it's not always wise to leave the engine running so I might go 10 yards, stop/start, another 10 yards stop/start. It's only the battery I'd worry about and since I fitted a huge tractor battery I don't worry too much anyway.

Each to his won in the case. I change lenses a lot so for me it's a good plan. If they had a shake rattle and roll button then I'd be happy and turn off at startup.

Mike
---------------------------------------------------

You can see some of my shots at my Flickr account.
Oggy
Posted 17/08/2009 - 18:12 Link
mikew wrote:
Oggy - I have been away so I missed the question about starting a car 3 times in a row. I do that when off road, it's not always wise to leave the engine running so I might go 10 yards, stop/start, another 10 yards stop/start. It's only the battery I'd worry about and since I fitted a huge tractor battery I don't worry too much anyway...
Mike
Really?

No worries about connecting a high current source to a highly inductive load and the resulting plasma discharge etching the faces of the contacts?

No worries about the imperfect mechanical engagement of a suddenly started motor with a stationary gear? Etc.

Everyone is indeed entitled to their opinions, but as an engineer, I prefer the facts.
Comment Image
mikew
Posted 17/08/2009 - 18:29 Link
I'm not quite sure what you're actually on about but no I'm not worried as I'm using the equipment within its design constraints and duty cycle. I'm not sure a diesel has any HT side and it's a very simple design which can trace its ancestry back to the 50s I think.

Mike
---------------------------------------------------

You can see some of my shots at my Flickr account.
PeteL
Posted 17/08/2009 - 18:42 Link
I used the Shake on startup with my old K10 and that did over 50,000 clicks and never a problem. However i have never once used the dust removal on the K7 (2604 shots) as i have not yet had any dust that has stayed on for more than a few frames so don`t feel the need to instigate it at startup (Yet!)
Regards - Pete
Oggy
Posted 17/08/2009 - 21:47 Link
mikew wrote:
I'm not quite sure what you're actually on about
No apparently not, but please do not let that stop you.

Quote:
I'm not sure a diesel has any HT side and it's a very simple design which can trace its ancestry back to the 50s I think
Possibly not, but taking a wild guess it has a starter motor which was what my first comment referred to.

My point is that the more times you use it, the less time it lasts, so why use it if it is not needed.
Comment Image
philstaff
Posted 17/08/2009 - 22:02 Link
Have both the K10 and GX 20 set at this function without any problem. It would seem odd that both companys should build this function into the camera if it could cause problems and both cameras have been on the market for a few years now. If this was the case that it could cause a problem or there had been a number of problems caused by this function then I think we would have heard more by now.
Ian
George Lazarette
Posted 17/08/2009 - 22:05 Link
Oggy wrote:

My point is that the more times you use it, the less time it lasts, so why use it if it is not needed.
My answer to that is that if a piece of dirt lands on your sensor, then (with sensor-shaking ON) it will be dislodged as soon as you next turn the camera on, which means it is less likely to become firmly attached and to need intervention in the form of compressed air or a cleaning swab.

But I take your point about wear. In principle, your argument is entirely valid. In practice, I like to think the shakey-shakey business will last as long as the camera.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Edited by George Lazarette: 17/08/2009 - 22:06
mikew
Posted 17/08/2009 - 22:17 Link
Oggy wrote:
mikew wrote:
I'm not quite sure what you're actually on about
No apparently not, but please do not let that stop you.
I feel that's a little rude but hey.


Oggy wrote:
Quote:
I'm not sure a diesel has any HT side and it's a very simple design which can trace its ancestry back to the 50s I think
Possibly not, but taking a wild guess it has a starter motor which was what my first comment referred to.
Which you failed to make clear.

Oggy wrote:
My point is that the more times you use it, the less time it lasts, so why use it if it is not needed.
Which is a fair point but I'd simply reiterate I'm using the equipment within its design specifications and duty cycle. All these things wear out that's accepted. Given the starter motor is designed to be used under water and may have to be cleaned of mud periodically I don't think a few extra starts is going to make any real difference to its life expectancy which is usually in excess of 20 years given some TLC.

The same I agree cannot be said of firing a shutter which we are led to believe has a life cycle of 100,000 activations and no indication that using the sensor clean has any impact on that lifetime. So I feel I am operating the camera within its design specifications and duty cycle.

But really we're agreeing and I just don't like the way you're dismissing my motoring point so I'm sure we remain best of friends.

Mike
---------------------------------------------------

You can see some of my shots at my Flickr account.
Oggy
Posted 18/08/2009 - 22:26 Link
Sorry Mike still not quite there. The thing with fatigue failure (and this is not just the sensor itself - the whole camera is shaken as per Newton's laws) is that it is cumulative. The more often you use it, the sooner it fails.

The concept of being within design criteria therefore having no impact is almost unheard of in the real world. It would mean something never wore out.
Comment Image

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo