Aviation photography

KZ
Posted 20/01/2011 - 10:41 Link
Hi,

http://www.flickr.com/photos/kz2011/5316679396/

This photo was taken with a K200D (which is not the fastest camera of the world) and with Pentax 200/2,8 SDM lens, which is also not too fast but terribly sharp. If you use continuous AF and continuous HI drive mode you will have sharp pictures (among quite a few soft ones) even with a slow camera/lens. And if the photo is sharp enough, you can crop it accordingly, so the distance is not the greatest problem. (This picture is heavily cropped.)
Though they are not cheap, but that’s why I suggest to buy a not so long, but sharp prime lens (200/2,8 or 300/4) insted of going for a longer Sigma zoom. IMHO.
Edited by KZ: 20/01/2011 - 10:59
Oggy
Posted 20/01/2011 - 12:52 Link
Not my findings. The year before last I went to Shoreham and a few other shows with the DA*300 and the Sigma 150-500. If I could fill the frame with the 300 then it did produce a better picture than the Sigma, but if the subject was smaller or further away by a significant amount then the Sigma came into it's own. For example, the Lancaster is very large and will easily fill the 300 frame as she passes, but a more interesting picture can be taken as she turns at the end of a pass. This is the most obvious chance to get a bit of "topside".

There is also the consideration that the Sigma has the versatility of a zoom, so if something interesting appears very close, you don't end up with a picture of the pilot's nostrils.

The third advantage of the Sigma is that it focuses faster than Pentax lenses (mine does anyway).
KZ
Posted 20/01/2011 - 18:38 Link
Oggy wrote:
Not my findings. The year before last I went to Shoreham and a few other shows with the DA*300 and the Sigma 150-500. If I could fill the frame with the 300 then it did produce a better picture than the Sigma, but if the subject was smaller or further away by a significant amount then the Sigma came into it's own. For example, the Lancaster is very large and will easily fill the 300 frame as she passes, but a more interesting picture can be taken as she turns at the end of a pass. This is the most obvious chance to get a bit of "topside".

There is also the consideration that the Sigma has the versatility of a zoom, so if something interesting appears very close, you don't end up with a picture of the pilot's nostrils.

The third advantage of the Sigma is that it focuses faster than Pentax lenses (mine does anyway).
Have you tried to compare a cropped DA*300 picture with a similar one taken with the Sigma at 500mm?
Oggy
Posted 20/01/2011 - 19:23 Link
Yes. That was the basis of my post above.
KZ
Posted 21/01/2011 - 19:25 Link
Well, then it is a matter of taste. But I agree, Sigma focuses faster than any Pentax sdm lenses.
Oggy
Posted 21/01/2011 - 22:14 Link
Taste has nothing to do with it. It's simple physics. If the aircraft fills the frame on the 300 it wins hands down - at the price, this is to be expected.

If it does not and you have to crop then the image will be degraded.

The extra 200mm gives the Sigma an advantage which will at some point overwhelm the IQ advantage of the 300.
KZ
Posted 22/01/2011 - 09:46 Link
Yes, the question is where is "at some point". My finding was that I was able to shoot far more "good" pictures with the 200/2,8 heavily cropped than with the longer Sigma. Probably another reason that at 400-500mm it was not easy for me to keep the AF point on a fast moving object that filled the frame, while the 200mm gave a far better chance to keep the AF precisely on it.
Practices are different, that is to say, I was not able to shoot pictures like put on the flickr with the Sigma, but was able with the Pentax 200/2,8 (of course cropped).
But I accept maybe you have different experience.

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo