3 different cameras sharpness and image quality test ???
Posted 13/04/2007 - 18:00
Link
Assuming these are straight from the camera (at its default settings) and not adjusted other than for the crop...
I would say A1 is the 30D. B1 is the K10D and the last is the 5D
WHY?
the first image looks like canons saturated colours and the third looks like the full frame sensor, ie wider angle of view
I would say A1 is the 30D. B1 is the K10D and the last is the 5D
WHY?
the first image looks like canons saturated colours and the third looks like the full frame sensor, ie wider angle of view
Posted 13/04/2007 - 18:08
Link
Interesting answer Impo you may be right or wrong
I will post the answer when we have a few more opinions.
Kind of a competition to see how many get it right pity i have no prizes
OH well no doubt i'll get ribbed for it and many will say a totally pointless exersise but it keeps the forum light hearted and something different I suppose.
Makes a change anyway
Pete
I will post the answer when we have a few more opinions.
Kind of a competition to see how many get it right pity i have no prizes
OH well no doubt i'll get ribbed for it and many will say a totally pointless exersise but it keeps the forum light hearted and something different I suppose.
Makes a change anyway
Pete
Posted 13/04/2007 - 19:28
Link
B is the odd one out... ???
I think A and C are Canon from looking at the colours recorded.
B is the Pentax, from what I've seen it tends to be bright.
Don't like C, but it may be the light/time of day in the picture.
I think A and C are Canon from looking at the colours recorded.
B is the Pentax, from what I've seen it tends to be bright.
Don't like C, but it may be the light/time of day in the picture.
Posted 13/04/2007 - 19:30
Link
Interesting answer also
I will let you know later the answer
Pete
I will let you know later the answer
Pete
Posted 13/04/2007 - 19:33
Link
a1 = K10D
b1 = 30D
c1 = 5D
Applied some logic, whats the prize anyway Pete
P.S. Are they your snaps ?
EDIT
b1 = 30D
c1 = 5D
Applied some logic, whats the prize anyway Pete
P.S. Are they your snaps ?
EDIT
Quote:
pity i have no prizes
Damn, need to stop speed reading, the brains too old to keep up with eyes
pity i have no prizes
Cheers
Brian.
LBA is good for you, a Lens a day helps you work, rest and play.
Brian.
LBA is good for you, a Lens a day helps you work, rest and play.
Posted 13/04/2007 - 19:46
Link
congratulations Brian
You have the correct answer
You have a good eye mate or a good guessing mind
YOUR PRIZE Good eyesight who knows A GOOD QUALITY IMAGE WHEN HE SEES ONE
But it shows on web based images which most of use and probably base our opinions there really is not a lot between all 3.
My opinion for what its worth thought the first image a1 was the best and that is not because i am a pentax user.
PS no I did not take the image
Pete
You have the correct answer
You have a good eye mate or a good guessing mind
YOUR PRIZE Good eyesight who knows A GOOD QUALITY IMAGE WHEN HE SEES ONE
But it shows on web based images which most of use and probably base our opinions there really is not a lot between all 3.
My opinion for what its worth thought the first image a1 was the best and that is not because i am a pentax user.
PS no I did not take the image
Pete
Posted 13/04/2007 - 20:46
Link
I have to confess
My answer was nothing to do with taste, the answer is in the image sizes
If I have to give an answer based on looks I would have went for the same as Impotentspider for the same reasons stated.
Any way I reckon the comporison is pretty useless, the shots appear to have been taken at very different times of the day (maybe even different days), note the shadows and sky for starters.
My answer was nothing to do with taste, the answer is in the image sizes
If I have to give an answer based on looks I would have went for the same as Impotentspider for the same reasons stated.
Any way I reckon the comporison is pretty useless, the shots appear to have been taken at very different times of the day (maybe even different days), note the shadows and sky for starters.
Cheers
Brian.
LBA is good for you, a Lens a day helps you work, rest and play.
Brian.
LBA is good for you, a Lens a day helps you work, rest and play.
Posted 15/04/2007 - 09:38
Link
Quote:
Any way I reckon the comporison is pretty useless, the shots appear to have been taken at very different times of the day (maybe even different days), note the shadows and sky for starters.
Agreed. Judging by the vegetation, they were taken over a period of weeks or months rather than days.
Any way I reckon the comporison is pretty useless, the shots appear to have been taken at very different times of the day (maybe even different days), note the shadows and sky for starters.
Posted 15/04/2007 - 09:54
Link
I think the pentax shot was taken using bright mode. This just goes to show it’s so difficult to tell the difference in cameras when viewing images on the net.
Pretty useless I agree but interesting. One thing I must say is how different images do look on different monitors.
This does beg the question that unless you go to Jessops or wherever and try several cameras and ask them to print the shots A3 or bigger from different cameras which they obviously wont do, how is a new consumer able to know what’s what in terms of final image quality before he decides on which camera.
I realise there are many other factors that decisions are made on but ultimately I believe its image quality that is the key for most newbie’s anyway, I may be wrong. My point being that if one has to rely mainly on internet or magazine based reviews then this method is not exactly unbiased as we all know.
All I can say it’s a mine field and go with what feels right in the end. A camera is only as good as the photographer or is it the other way around
Pretty useless I agree but interesting. One thing I must say is how different images do look on different monitors.
This does beg the question that unless you go to Jessops or wherever and try several cameras and ask them to print the shots A3 or bigger from different cameras which they obviously wont do, how is a new consumer able to know what’s what in terms of final image quality before he decides on which camera.
I realise there are many other factors that decisions are made on but ultimately I believe its image quality that is the key for most newbie’s anyway, I may be wrong. My point being that if one has to rely mainly on internet or magazine based reviews then this method is not exactly unbiased as we all know.
All I can say it’s a mine field and go with what feels right in the end. A camera is only as good as the photographer or is it the other way around
Wedding & Portrait photographer
Posted 15/04/2007 - 10:13
Link
For the choice for Pentax came out of a number of reasons.
1) I had previous good experience with them
2) The handling and overall "feel" of the camera
3) I had very bad experience with Canon (dead USM motors)
4) absolutely no experience with Nikon
Allthough the camera could have been a little larger (I have the DS) the handling is to me in a complete different league then the Canon and Nikon offerings.
A nice note on handling, a colleague has a Konica-Minolta DSLR and after 2 minutes playing with my DS he was wondering why on earth Konica-Minolta made the handling so strange.
The only thing people have to get used to if they handle my DS is the fact that I have moved the AF operation to the OK button on the back side instead of with the shutter release button.
Image quality is very important offcourse, but when shooting RAW and getting the hang of Silkypix more and more I really love my DS. I am a little tempted to get a K10D but SWMBO allways try to get me to leave the camera store when I am looking at the offerings...
1) I had previous good experience with them
2) The handling and overall "feel" of the camera
3) I had very bad experience with Canon (dead USM motors)
4) absolutely no experience with Nikon
Allthough the camera could have been a little larger (I have the DS) the handling is to me in a complete different league then the Canon and Nikon offerings.
A nice note on handling, a colleague has a Konica-Minolta DSLR and after 2 minutes playing with my DS he was wondering why on earth Konica-Minolta made the handling so strange.
The only thing people have to get used to if they handle my DS is the fact that I have moved the AF operation to the OK button on the back side instead of with the shutter release button.
Image quality is very important offcourse, but when shooting RAW and getting the hang of Silkypix more and more I really love my DS. I am a little tempted to get a K10D but SWMBO allways try to get me to leave the camera store when I am looking at the offerings...
Camera:K20D|Ist*DS|Spotmatic II|MZ-10
Pentax Lenses: DA16-45|DA50-200|50A 1.7
Tamron Lenses: 28-200
Takumar Lenses: SMC 55 1.8
Sigma Lenses: EX DG 50-500 'Bigma'|EX 50mm Macro
Flashes: Metz 58 AF-1|Samsung SEF-36PZF|Pentax AF-220T
Pentax Lenses: DA16-45|DA50-200|50A 1.7
Tamron Lenses: 28-200
Takumar Lenses: SMC 55 1.8
Sigma Lenses: EX DG 50-500 'Bigma'|EX 50mm Macro
Flashes: Metz 58 AF-1|Samsung SEF-36PZF|Pentax AF-220T
Posted 15/04/2007 - 11:10
Link
Quote:
I think the pentax shot was taken using bright mode. This just goes to show it’s so difficult to tell the difference in cameras when viewing images on the net.
It doesn't really show anything of the kind, nor indeed anything at all.I think the pentax shot was taken using bright mode. This just goes to show it’s so difficult to tell the difference in cameras when viewing images on the net.
If you wanted to actually compare the sharpness of the three camera/lens combinations you picked, all you need to do is take the pictures under identical conditions, and then enlarge selected portions to a size viewable on a screen. Then you can make a meaningful visual comparison, even if you don't actually measure resolution in lines per inch.
But all you've done is take three shots on three cameras in wildly differing conditions, and in fact they show nothing at all.
Sorry Pete, but if you're going to start a thread with the word "test" in the title, I don't think it's unreasonable to expect that you'll test something. But these shots don't test, or even compare anything.
Complete waste of time, in my view. Sorry, but there it is.
Posted 15/04/2007 - 12:44
Link
Quote:
Point taken Chris
Or "lessons have been learned"
Point taken Chris
Keep up the good work
Graham
I'll think of something someday.
Graham
I'll think of something someday.
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


740 posts
19 years
West Mids UK
Images are labeled a1 b1 c1 for reference
IMAGE a1
IMAGE b1
IMAGE c1