3:2, 4:3. 1:1, or 16:9?

bwlchmawr
Posted 11/06/2014 - 08:23 Link
On the wall of my bedroom is a 16" square colour enlargement of a lake in Cumbria which I took twenty odd years ago with a borrowed Rollieflex. I remember taking just that camera and a couple of rolls of 120 film to try and see if looking at the world through square eyes would improve my photography. It probably didn't but the exercise was fascinating and frustrating in equal measures.

Using mainly 35mm cameras for years, makes you "see" pictures in a certain way; you get used to it. DSLRs are the same, of course, with a standard 3:2 crop. I know, we all crop images on the computer to suit the composition, as we did in the darkroom, sometimes producing square or "more oblong" shots, if that makes sense.

Since having a compact camera I've become more aware of the different ways of framing an image in the field and with the quick menu button on the MX-1 and fast rear dial (about the only thing which is fast about the camera) it's so easy to experiment. On our trip to Majorca last week I found myself flicking between the various formats, not often, but when obvious framing options presented themselves. I usually stuck with the standard compact 3:4 ratio which is a very old film format and well suited to portraiture but found that the "Y" axis was usually too tall for landscapes. It's a lesser version of the problem I had when I tried a long coveted Sigma 10-20 that there' simply too much foreground for most shots. Back home I'm finding the need to crop the bottom or/and sometimes part of the sky from many shots.

With advent of wide-screen TVs and lap top computer screens 16:9 now seems a more natural way to frame a landscape and no longer feels too wide. But I'm still more at home with the 3:2 view from my K100 or K10. Whether it's just habit or the fact the natural world is mostly made to fit that format, I don't know.

I wonder what other people think.
4:3
Comment Image

16:9
Comment Image

1:1
Comment Image

3:2
Comment Image


The above shots are for illustrative purposes only: they were all cropped after the fact.
Best wishes,

Andrew

"These places mean something and it's the job of a photographer to figure-out what the hell it is."
Robert Adams
"The camera doesn't make a bit of difference.  All of them can record what you are seeing.  But, you have to SEE."
Ernst Hass
My website: http://www.ephotozine.com/user/bwlchmawr-199050
http://s927.photobucket.com/home/ADC3440/index
https://www.flickr.com/photos/78898196@N05
johnriley
Posted 11/06/2014 - 08:29 Link
It depends what the image demands - square compositions are stable and balanced for example. These days, as you say, 16:9 is the norm and other formats may start to look cramped. 3:2 was always a bit long for portraits in vertical format, so I always cropped those.

However, none of our pictures actually need to be one of these fixed ratios. We can crop to suit the image in software such as Photoshop and it can be any format we like.

Changing the format in camera may well alter the way we view a scene though, as will using the waist level position of a TLR like the Rolleiflex. Sometimes I set the 1:1 ratio in camera purely to force me to think Rollei for a specific set of images. Quite a few of my EPZ images are square format, and that uses the full area available quite well.
Best regards, John
DrOrloff
Posted 11/06/2014 - 08:35 Link
I like 16:9 and use it for many of my images. However, it does not seem to be a standard print ratio. It is worth bearing the intended destination of an image in mind when processing and cropping.
fritzthedog
Posted 11/06/2014 - 08:50 Link
One the absolute biggest advantages of 'the digital age' is that to me there are no longer any size ratios to worry about.

I don't really 'see' the size ratio of the image as I take it - I 'see' the way it will look after I have applied whatever crop feels right. When I first started cropping digital images - I religiously stuck to the 'standard' ratios that are usually supplied with any cropping tool. These days 90% of the time - I manually crop to whatever I like best.

I accept that for images I intend getting printed professionally - more consideration may be required but it is rare for me to do this.

The Sigma 10-20 is by far my favorite landscape lens and yes you do need to crop many shots but I do not consider this an issue at all. Unless it is something I intend for the shot (such as a very low level landscape)- generally I don't even consider the immediate foreground to be in shot when using this lens as it will be cropped straight away.

It would be interesting to see what everybody else does.

Carl
No matter how many lenses I have owned - I have always needed just one more
kh1234567890
Posted 11/06/2014 - 09:15 Link
16:9 is an ugly compromise kludge. 16:10 was nearer to the golden ratio and looked better. Sadly 16:10 monitors are on their way out because of manufacturers greed.
alfpics
Posted 11/06/2014 - 09:23 Link
Interesting topic Andrew.
For my eye with your images above, the 16:9 and 1:1 crops work for me!

As above from Doc, we need to bear in mind the intended end use when framing/ cropping etc. I often don't re-crop to 16:9, but do a resize to 1080 for a full HD slideshow that leaves dark edges at left and right.

I have a Charlie Waite landscape book - full of square format prints which all work as well (crafted by a master!)

With other shots the end destination will determine the final ration and will often be 'none of the above' if, say, buying an off the shelf frame and mount (with a 10"x8" window for example). And then it really is a matter of whether or not the image suits that crop!
Andy
Edited by alfpics: 11/06/2014 - 09:24
aliengrove
Posted 11/06/2014 - 09:55 Link
I used to just crop to what I thought looked best, but now use standard ratios almost exclusively. I use 16:9 a lot, mainly due to constraints with where I shoot a lot of my images, but also because I like it. However, I also think that people have become conditioned to the format because of modern monitors and TV's. I've only sold two prints that weren't 16:9, one a totally random crop and one that was 2:1, which I also use quite often. 4:3 is quite close to square, and I find it sometimes looks a bit unbalanced. I prefer 1:1.

I'd like to experiment more with 1:1, though it's become a bit trendy with Instagram etc. One of the reasons I want a Flucard is to use my K3 and a tablet as a sort of "Live-view" for my Yashica, to see what images look like in 1:1 before shooting off expensive film.

Of the images you have posted here, Andrew, the 1:1 version is the one I like most, but different scenes probably suit different formats.
Blythman
Posted 11/06/2014 - 09:56 Link
I tend to do mix up 3x2, 10x8, and 1x1 as standard crops. But not averse to letterboxes or whatever when it suits.

For prints, it does help to stick to my standard sizes, because I have mounts which I've pre-cut, ready for them to drop in
Alan


PPG
Flickr
Edited by Blythman: 11/06/2014 - 09:58
doingthebobs
Posted 11/06/2014 - 10:04 Link
For your image above, the 16x9 works best for me and the 1x1 the least attractive. In fact I might try going even wider like this:Comment Image


It all depends on the picture we want to make. I often find 10'x8' gives a ratio that I like but 1x1 is sometimes just right! I think wide views can be great but they don't always suit the picture. The flexibility we have with digital is great but we always could crop with the enlarger or craft knife and rule.

I will often remove excess white paper from prints to get the picture how I want. Print to the largest side, then crop the print with a knife.
Bob
wvbarnes
Posted 11/06/2014 - 10:11 Link
3:2 for me and cropping later. Editing my wife's bridge camera photos after our holiday seemed odd as they were 4:3 of similar shots which seemed very square with excessive foreground. Easily fixed of course.

As to 16:9 its a horrible cramped screen format for a computer unless you want to watch a movie.

Thus, like many on here, I have to complement my PC a Dell Ultrasharp 24 inch IPS monitor at 1920 x 1200 deep.
Smeggypants
Posted 11/06/2014 - 10:50 Link
I can't see the point in adhering to some arbitrary set of aspect ratios.

I just crop to whatever looks the best to suit the scene.

There's no need to adhere to a set of aspects these days so why shackle yourself top them? Makes no sense. :
[i]Bodies: 1x K-5IIs, 2x K-5, Sony TX-5, Nokia 808
Lenses: Pentax DA 10-17mm ED(IF) Fish Eye, Pentax DA 14mm f/2.8, Sigma 17-70mm f/2.8, Pentax-A 28mm f/2.8, Sigma 30mm F1.4 EX DC, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.2, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-FA 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.7, Pentax DA* 50-135mm f/2.8, Sigma 135-400mm APO DG, and more ..
Flash: AF-540FGZ, Vivitar 283
dangie
Posted 11/06/2014 - 11:18 Link
On my Panasonic LX7 compact which has a choice of aspect ratio's I keep it at 4:3 as this uses more of the sensor than the other ratio's. As I do my own mounting I then crop to whatever ratio looks best.
6th Year Apprentice Pensioner
bwlchmawr
Posted 11/06/2014 - 17:54 Link
Thanks everyone for your considered contributions. I wondered how people dealt with the format issue at the point of exposure.

Ultimately, of course, as Smeggy and John suggest, we can do as we like in Photoshop, unconstrained these days by 6x4 or 7x5 prints or 35mm slides.

Interesting.
Best wishes,

Andrew

"These places mean something and it's the job of a photographer to figure-out what the hell it is."
Robert Adams
"The camera doesn't make a bit of difference.  All of them can record what you are seeing.  But, you have to SEE."
Ernst Hass
My website: http://www.ephotozine.com/user/bwlchmawr-199050
http://s927.photobucket.com/home/ADC3440/index
https://www.flickr.com/photos/78898196@N05
alfpics
Posted 11/06/2014 - 18:33 Link
bwlchmawr wrote:
Thanks everyone for your considered contributions. I wondered how people dealt with the format issue at the point of exposure.
In answer to that, I don't tend to think about that; just try to get it looking right in the viewfinder. Its afterwards I sometimes wish I had thought about it at the point of exposure!
Andy
Smeggypants
Posted 11/06/2014 - 22:33 Link
bwlchmawr wrote:
Thanks everyone for your considered contributions. I wondered how people dealt with the format issue at the point of exposure.

Ultimately, of course, as Smeggy and John suggest, we can do as we like in Photoshop, unconstrained these days by 6x4 or 7x5 prints or 35mm slides.

Interesting.
I tend to shoot a bit wider to give scope for adjustment when I get home.
[i]Bodies: 1x K-5IIs, 2x K-5, Sony TX-5, Nokia 808
Lenses: Pentax DA 10-17mm ED(IF) Fish Eye, Pentax DA 14mm f/2.8, Sigma 17-70mm f/2.8, Pentax-A 28mm f/2.8, Sigma 30mm F1.4 EX DC, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.2, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-FA 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.7, Pentax DA* 50-135mm f/2.8, Sigma 135-400mm APO DG, and more ..
Flash: AF-540FGZ, Vivitar 283

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo