RichardDay

Joined: 19th May 2008

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

RichardDay
iceblinker wrote:
That large P70 shot is good enough to make me think about getting one for myself, or a P80.

What other sub 130-gram* camera competes in terms of image quality and handling?

(I've decided on that weight limit because otherwise I'd just carry on using my old 120-gram* Optio S5i when travelling light. I already have heavier and larger cameras when I'm prepared to carry more).

* Including battery.
I can't think of one to be totally honest. It is a very small and neat package.

P70 v P80 differences - link

If I get a good CX1 (which I hope I will ), or I jump for something better again , my P70 may be available . Only 654 shots since new (14th March 09) and is covered by Pentax/SRS 2yr warranty (which is transferable to forum members).

Comment by RichardDay posted on My new P&S ? at 16/01/2010 - 17:32

RichardDay
Anvh wrote:
Richard, we are getting confused here. I'm not the one with the problem but Technoblurb is.
He has found out that if he used aRGB instead of sRGB in raw that the colour is correct, when coverting from Pef to DNG. For the rest I'm with you on that part that I don't see a difference either but that does not explain why it does for Technoblurb, I can't get my head around why it should either and was hoping you know more but you're also at lost...

As for PP.
I don't save in tiff for photoshop, I use the DNG instead so I don't bother about colour profiles only when first opening a RAW file, but that's a camera profile and later only when I save the file to jpg I convert to a colour profile.
Most of the time that's sRGB for web use and for printing I use a custom printing profile that the print-shop has giving me for their printers or I print at home straight from Photoshop and let that handle the colours with custom printer profiles.
That way I go around the whole dilemma of colour profiles although I know the printer can print colours that my monitor can't display and vice versa but you always keep that problem.
Working with a smaller colour space that both devices can project is an option but also a compromise in my view, but you do get so good as matching colours.
It seems we are talking the same language.

I think the issue is that many people become very confused between camera & printer/paper/ink "profiles" and colour "space", which is not the same thing at all.

Users should just stick to sRGB unless the really do understand colour space configuration and workflow.

Comment by RichardDay posted on K7 Raw files and Photoshop CS3 at 16/01/2010 - 17:08

RichardDay
hefty1 wrote:
RichardDay wrote:
Short story is I caved in and bought a CX1 in black!
As another Ricoh compact user (GR-Digital) may I be the first to welcome you to the club!

I like the fact mine feels like a camera rather than a mobile phone with the phone features switched off. Very intuitive, quick operation, lovely IQ and built like a tank. Very underrated cameras and well worth a look.
Thanks Hefty

I agree about the solidity and feel, but I hope that I can find a better example than the one I took away with me (above)!

Serves me right for not checking it out in the store, I always do it when I buy my Pentax gear, I have no idea why I had a relapse!!

Fingers crossed for a better result on Monday!

BTW - The P70 is actually a very good little camera, if it had sensor or optical AS and a bit faster "shot to shot", I would probably not be looking elsewhere!

Comment by RichardDay posted on My new P&S ? at 16/01/2010 - 16:47

RichardDay

May be longer than the weekend, the black CX1 I bought appears to have bad IQ so I am returning it on Monday, stupidly I didn't check it out in the store (idiot! :roll. The store demo was much better.

Here is a typical comparison shot v. my P70 taken today, both taken at their base ISO's and at 28mm wide (the P70 appears to go a bit wider).

EXIF is intact so you can see that there is no question of shake etc. (click on images for 1600 x 1200 size for a clearer image). Shots are untouched apart from being resized.

P70

Comment Image


CX1

Comment Image

Comment by RichardDay posted on My new P&S ? at 16/01/2010 - 16:42

RichardDay
Well, I did go to Clifton Cameras today with my Optio P70 and compared it to the Ricoh CX1, CX2 and R10, Fuji F70EXR and I had a quick look at a couple of Panasonics (TZ6 & TZ7).

Short story is I caved in and bought a CX1 in black! - I nearly went for the champagne rose finish, it actually looks a little bit like titanium, but chickened out after a few seconds!

Why the CX1? -
Handling and response is super fast, feels almost like a DSLR!
Build quality looks and feels the best.
Menu system is totally intuitive.
The 3" 920k screen is lovely (like a K-7 ).
Customisation is really excellent.
Overall IQ at the lower ISO's appears to be the best of the bunch, I suspect because of a very decent lens.

The others failed to impress in various ways, but they all felt slightly "toy like", a bit "gadgety" and unresponsive compared to the CX1. You need to handle them to see why. The Panasonics are impressive spec wise, but they just don't "feel" as "right" as the Ricoh, even the little R10 feels nice, but it is a completely different annimal to the CX1, it's really just another P&S. I wasn't at all "at home" with the Fuji. In fact the Optio P70 stands up quite well amonst them, if it wasn't for the slow "post shot" (but effective) software SR, it would be my second choice, especially for the money.

Okay, if you want HD movies, then the Ricoh's don't deliver, you probably have to go for the Panasonic's (but even the P70 has 1280 x 720, but at 15fps), but my main requirement was for a very responsive pocketable still camera with quick "shot to shot" (not the same as continuous) capability that had sufficient customisation not to frustrate the heck out of me and deliver pretty decent IQ at low to moderate ISO's. High ISO capability in a small P&S doesn't equate, so the CX1 easily met my needs. Okay, Raw would be nice, but I missed out on the GX100 offers that were around just before Christmas at around £200.

The weather was abysmal (so what else to do except go to a dealer and play with some gear!), so I didn't take any decent outdoor shots. I did my evaluation based upon rear screen reviews at reasonable magnification and general handling. The Fuji was the best at high ISO's but you could see the detail smearing very easily, even at ISO200 and you can't turn the NR off or down. I suspect that the Ricoh could match, or even better it if you used a decent software based NR program, in fact the P70 is pretty good at ISO400.

I still have my P70 and will wait for some better weather to do some IQ comparisons, Sunday is supposed to bring better light, so will do some then, I shall also do some low light, indoor and macro shots in the meantime.

Comment by RichardDay posted on My new P&S ? at 15/01/2010 - 18:25

RichardDay
IMO - He is 99+% correct, and I don't often say that about him!

I don't bother with aRGB, but I DO bother converting to 16 bit TIFF if I don't print directly from Raw files in Silkypix Pro (as it supports printer profiling), i.e. when I need to do significant PP'ing in Photoshop, as editing in 8 bit format leads to posterisation and artifact problems. I only ever convert to JPEG as a final step after PP adjustments before submitting for web or large format printing (which I cannot do) unless the photolab can use TIFF, which is not often.

Comment by RichardDay posted on K7 Raw files and Photoshop CS3 at 15/01/2010 - 13:34

RichardDay
Well I'm at a complete loss as to what you are finding.

I converted a PEF to DNG with the latest DNG converter and made sRGB and aRGB to both JPEG and TIFF conversions with ACR and viewed them in Photoshop CS2 (I don't have CS3) and they look identical on screen and print.

I repeated the same process using Silkypix Pro and converted both the PEF and DNG files to sRGB and aRGB and again found no visible differences.

My monitor is a HP LP2065 which is a 1600 x 1200 SIPS type and accurately calibrated using an Eye One. My printer, paper and ink are also specifically profiled as well. I have a completely colour managed workflow.

I can only surmise that you have an error in your colour management setup somewhere, as I cannot duplicate what you are finding.

I'm sorry that I cannot duplicate your issue and can be of no further help.

Comment by RichardDay posted on K7 Raw files and Photoshop CS3 at 15/01/2010 - 11:38

RichardDay
Anvh wrote:
Thank you Richard and already knew that

Still it does not explain why a PEF to DNG conversion leads to colour shift if you use sRGB for the jpg preview and is correct when you use aRGB.
I can see where you go to with colour profiles and that can be it but still I don't see why a RAW convert should read the embedded jpg preview...
It's becoming complicated.

The program in question of viewing is Photoshop CS3 and that does open the RAW file and not the jpg preview, so it's just RAW.
It may be due to your CS3 setup, under Color Settings you need to set your Color Management Policies in the RGB box to "Preserve Embedded Profiles"

But please read Ken Rockwells comments and don't use aRGB. You'll be better off for it!

Comment by RichardDay posted on K7 Raw files and Photoshop CS3 at 14/01/2010 - 17:56

RichardDay
Another item.
The CX2 (longer lens version of CX1) received a best compact camera of 2009 award, beating the Panasonic TX7 and Canon S90.

See http://www.trustedreviews.com/laptops/review/2009/11/25/TrustedReviews-Awards-20...

Comment by RichardDay posted on My new P&S ? at 14/01/2010 - 17:44

RichardDay
For what it's worth, Photography Blog's reviews:

F70EXR - F70EXR

CX-1 - CX-1

CX-2 - CX-2

Pentax Optio P70 - Optio P70

From DPR user reviews

F70EXR - F70EXR user comments

CX-1 - CX-1 user comments

CX-2 - CX-2 user comment

Optio P70 - Optio P70 user comments

Comment by RichardDay posted on My new P&S ? at 14/01/2010 - 17:11

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo