richandfleur

Joined: 3rd December 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

richandfleur
joostdh wrote:
Pentax has a very clear and solid proposition: they make great cameras for photography. If you want video then you will nog be served well by them. We all know this. If you want to do commercial video projects then look elsewhere.
What if you want them to be as good as they were?

Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax K-1 Reviews at 13/07/2016 - 08:49

richandfleur
McGregNi wrote:
Somehow I wonder whether Pentax would ever think that a customer who's been with the brand for 30 years would ever want more sophisticated video features ?!?
It's interesting to consider that video from DSLR's started around 2008/2009 and Pentax was right in there with the k-7. k-x and k-5 cameras, all featuring sensor stabilisation during video. Pentax was well in the video game, and has been in it right from the early years of DSLR video. Video is not new to Pentax, it's been with us for as long as video has been an option on DSLR's.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax K-1 Reviews at 13/07/2016 - 03:20

richandfleur
Does sound good indeed.

Comment by richandfleur posted on crazy KS2 deal on Amazon FR at 13/07/2016 - 03:02

richandfleur
Pretty stunning first attempt for Pentax

Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax K-1 Reviews at 07/07/2016 - 09:59

richandfleur
petrochemist wrote:


You say these are just firmware issues but perhaps the processing power is simply not available to carry them out with video...
Perhaps they should ask the Pentax Engineers from 2009/2010 how they did it with the K-x, K-7 and K-5 models?

I can't know the specifics of why they haven't improved, be that engineering, resourcing, internal budgeting or other.
What I do know though is every other camera manufacturer can make this work now.

As others are moving to 4k, Pentax will be moving to catch up to higher quality 1080p. Focus peaking and achieving sensor stabilisation during video, plus a higher bitrate mode would suit me just fine. They may have sorted the audio levels display already, I haven't used a K-3 with the mic input so can't say.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax K-1 Reviews at 07/07/2016 - 09:44

richandfleur
D0n wrote:
pentax is known for releasing odd, eccentric one off models anyways.
It would not kill the company and might even help to simply release a "V" or "Cinema" version of k70 and k1 just to shut me up.
I'd genuinely be purchasing a K-70 if it addressed some of the points I mentioned above.

I think it's really important to reaffirm that I (an others) aren't after significant changes in terms of video. The base/core is there, and the look from our lenses is great, it just needs a bit of work to polish it off to a level that will really make it shine. Despite the talk, the K-70 unfortunately brings very little new developments to the video table, (AF in video mode with some lenses, and a mic input which isn't new to Pentax, but is to this lower model range).

The K-70 really caught my attention, as it looks like the natural successor to my K-30 and incorporates lots of features I'm interested in, such as the K-3 pixel shift tech and a newer high res sensor (that some are suggesting might have some improved low light capabilities). Video wise though, it's the same 2012/2014 offering, with no sensor shift stabilisation, focus peaking or improved bit rate, and given it's mid 2016 now, that's rather disappointing and reaffirms that Pentax really lags the competition in this area.

As was mentioned by others above, all cameras are pretty good these days and frankly they are all excellent in stills. Video looks to be the final frontier for Pentax to venture into, but small tweaks would go an awful long way to satisfy both existing and new customers.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax K-1 Reviews at 07/07/2016 - 06:30

richandfleur
nocturnal wrote:
davidwozhere wrote:
Buy one of those and you get slammed for import duty
Just wait until UK has left Europe. Import duty on every beautiful lens from Italy and elsewhere!!!!!!
Yep that's what NZ has. The local agent seems completely useless and Pentax gear is only sold in a select few shops throughout the country. Anything over a certain threshold attracts tax when it's imported.

Comment by richandfleur posted on k1 ebay at 07/07/2016 - 01:19

richandfleur
dcweather wrote:
Most cameras are good these days.
Fully agree. It's genuinely difficult to find a bad camera these days, especially in stills where the technology is well developed. There's very little in it in stills, and the comparisons seem quite nit picking over resolution abilities etc. The pixel shift is genuine improvement, which really shines for the likes of static far off landscape and studio product shots.

Video wise though all the companies have progressed in the last 2 years or so except for Pentax. Pentax last really looked at the video software offering around 2012, where the K-01 and K-30 picked up 1080p at 24fps and full manual control, and also lost mechanical sensor stabilisation. Nowadays even Fuji and Olympus (who outright stated video wasn't their thing at all) have made dramatic improvements. Sony and Olympus and Panasonic now do sensor stabilisation during video mode and talk to lenses that have stabilisation inbuilt, to determine who can do which parts the best. This is tech Pentax was using 5+ years ahead of the game, but walked away from under Ricoh.

There really is work to do to bring the Pentax offering up to where it should be in 2014/2015, and that's before looking at where it should be in say 2016/2017. Reviews will continue to highlight this until they address it. As mentioned above though, I don't think they have to do too much to be really useful, over and above the base they've got for casual use now. I had high hopes for the K-70 in this regard, but they've only added AF during video, which is yet to be evaluated during a review.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax K-1 Reviews at 06/07/2016 - 23:57

richandfleur
Why do you pick a Pentax DSLR over a point and shoot or cell phone?

The answers to that question are typically why I want to pick a Pentax for video. Outside of the stills only features, such as pixel shift/ HDR modes, the Pentax offers a rugged body with weather sealing, great image quality, focus peaking, sensor shift stabilisation and interchangeable lenses. Why limit the maximum use of that to stills only?

Saying that you need to have a super expensive TV production camera (such as the random link to the LDK 3000+) is akin to saying you can't possibly shoot anything properly on anything less than a Pentax 645Z. Keep it real, without the desperate link to extremes. Handicams are great for certain situations, especially where you are running the camera for a very long period of time (say a presentation/school play etc) but you could say the same about a cell phone or point and shoot instead of a DSLR. There are times when you want the look, depth of field, low light ability etc of a DSLR for stills, and for video. A handicam is no more a video alternative for DSLR video than a point and shoot is for DSLR stills.

The other aspect is the continual push of 'video will hurt stills' or 'video will cost more' etc. For sure one would optimise the hardware in a different manner if the primary objective was video, but a lot can be done with what's already there. Pentax bodies have had video for years, since the K-x I think it was, back in 2009. Video is nothing new to Pentax, so those who don't want it at all are really living in the past. It's here now, has been for many years and will be moving forward also.

Given it doesn't require any additional hardware, we're only talking software, which typically doesn't add significant costs to the final product. I don't know Pentax's business strategies around this, with regards to costs recovery of firmware development, but the bottom line is you're not being asked to pay more for any hardware associated with video. The new K-70 for example has on sensor PDAF points, which one could argue are a predominately a video feature (with benefits to stills in live view presumably) which now drives continuous AF in video mode. This improvement has been included in a new package which is extremely competitively priced at $647 USD. Bottom line is video developments (of the type Pentax users are asking for) do not have to cost significantly more, and the K-70 is an example of this.

So, what are people asking for? (I think it's important to look at this, so we don't end up with examples like the LDK 3000+ above.)
1) Mechanical Stabilisation.
This was working on the K-x, K-5 and K-7, but was dropped around the K-01/K-30 models when they switched to a different processor type. Ricoh also use this on cameras such as the WG-M1, featuring Electronic image stabilization (Movie SR). They've treated this as a generic bit of code for stabilisation, across all hardware types, but it just plain doesn't work very well. At best it's actually pretty good, but it's bad to really bad most of the time. At worst it plain ruins your footage, warping it terribly, and in a non recoverable way.

2) Bit rates / Codecs.
Basically these are looking pretty poor by todays standard. It's essentially on a par with stills really. Imagine you had the power of your Pentax camera but were limited to only taking photos in the low to medium JPEG settings. This would tend to show a lot of compression / blocking when the scene is complex, and that's essentially what we're seeing with the current Pentax video options. They need to offer a higher bitrate setting (akin to say Protune on the GoPro, or X-AVC S on the Sony's). Pentax has been pleased that their approach gives small file sizes, but I'd prefer an option to priories image quality.

3) Focus Peaking
Pentax has focus peaking, but it turns off during video recording. The file should be written to the storage media before peaking is subsequently applied for display purposes. The same could be said for digital zoom as well.

4) Audio Levels visualisation.
This may have been addressed already, but without an indication you don't know if you are clipping your audio or not.
Pentax offers options for setting the audio levels at different points, but you can't know what you need without a mic out or preferably audio level visualisations.

5) Clean HDMI output.
I'm not so fussed on this one, but to allow the use of external recorders, there should be an option to remove any camera info overlays on the hdmi output. This then allows for a much higher quality capture and encoding than is being provided internally, for those who want to go to this length.


As you can see, the likes of 4k resolution etc are not included. Pentax needs to walk before it can run.

Comment by richandfleur posted on Pentax K-1 Reviews at 06/07/2016 - 22:41

richandfleur
Great that you found a solution

Comment by richandfleur posted on K3 II Interval Composite Mode Stops at 06/07/2016 - 21:21

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo