philmerrin

Joined: 24th October 2006

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

philmerrin
The lens itself is not scratched, I've taken the pic in a way to emphasise how that coating has come off. It definitely appears that someone has been over zealous with the cleaning. My guess is some type of solvent has been used. I have tried a dab of petrol (knowing that that won't affect glass) but all it did was clean the lens and not soften the remainder of the coating as I had hoped. With some of the coating off, I would prefer to make things uniform by removing the rest. One thing is certain I can't put it back. Any ideas anyone?

Comment by philmerrin posted on coating coming off lens at 21/03/2007 - 22:44

philmerrin
[quote="johnriley"]I've never experienced this problem with any lens, old or new. Are you sure that the coating has come away and that it's not just a discolouration of part of the front element?

Hello John, You or anyone who cares to, take a look at this image and you'll see what I'm on about.

http://philmerrin.gallery.netspace.net.au/albums/album01/IMGP4923_cr.jpg

Comment by philmerrin posted on coating coming off lens at 17/03/2007 - 04:10

philmerrin
To make the glass more uniform perhaps! Its my intention to be using this lens for indoor pics and I can't see I'll have too many problems with solar flare. Despite not having seen any aberrations to the few images I've taken doesn't mean that will always be the case.

So what would remove the remaining coating safely? I guess someone was careless enough when giving the glass a 'super' clean to have found it. I wonder, what it is?

Comment by philmerrin posted on coating coming off lens at 16/03/2007 - 22:50

philmerrin
I was given a manual wide angle cosina lens which takes surprisingly nice images. On closer inspection I noticed that part of the coating on the front lens had come off or been removed. This is about 25% off of one side. It doesn't seem to affect any of the pics I've taken thus far. I wonder does anybody know of a substance I can use to remove the rest of it without compromising the glass itself?

Thanks.

Comment by philmerrin posted on coating coming off lens at 15/03/2007 - 21:27

philmerrin
Quote:
I have seen a Sigma 18-200 when I have done a search through google and a Sigma 18-125. Can you please advice as to their relative merits. Thanks for your patience.

Howard
Yeah I bought a used Sigma 18-125 and like it a fair bit. I made comparison shots between the lower end of the 18-125 and the Pentax 18-55 kit lens. IMO there was little to choose quality wise, so I sold the kit lens which contrary to the view of many Pentax users I didn't really think much of.

Now I do agree with reports by other buyers of the 18-125 regarding inconsistent auto focusing in low light. Its a bit like pot luck if you rely on it. Sometimes I notice it focuses correctly at first try but if you lift your finger off the shutter button then half press again this A/F may try focus again and get it wrong leaving you with out of focus subjects.

What I do is look through the viewfinder and check the subject really is in focus before I take. What puzzles me is the focus light on my K100D is also fooled.

So IMO if you're shooting professionally or fast and don't have much time to double check focusing then this is probably not the lens for you. But for my needs and the handiness of not changing lenses continually I find its a good thing to have as a general always on the camera lens despite its drawbacks.

I'm getting the impression from reading various reviews that the Sigma 18-200 is a better lens for Auto focusing but the FOV @ 200mm is more like 180mm say compared to equivalent Pentax zooms.

Comment by philmerrin posted on Clean sensor at 27/01/2007 - 05:23

philmerrin
Quote:
http://www.currys.co.uk/product.php?sku=717373&camp_id=froogle

Does this surprise anyone : I haven't used the pentax version but if the only differences are the absence of an SMC coating and the different barrel design I may way go for it...
Who says it doesn't have the SMC coating? All debate I've seen on various forums concurs both the Samsung and Pentax 50-200 are one and the same item both emanating from the same factory in Vietnam. The only difference being they're finished off cosmetically to reflect the particular company they're 'intended' for.

Yer best bet is to buy the cheapest you can find between these two brands unless of course you're a brand snob sort of person.

Comment by philmerrin posted on Pentax 50-200DA zoom - £122 Tecno at 25/01/2007 - 13:55

philmerrin
Thanks John and Gartmore. With regards to the shattered filter, I'd tend to agree the cheap glass would break very easily and with a drop like you had the shattering glass is potentially a greater hazard to the lens than if you didnt have one. While I don't argue for filters to be used 24/7. I do feel that neutral UV will do a reasonable job on my 80-200 particularly as I intend using it for outdoor work and the amount of sun we get here. I also understand that skylight 1A and 1B should also cut down UV haze, I wonder why the promaster 1A skylight (pink tint) didn't cut it, perhaps its just a cheap thing.

Comment by philmerrin posted on 2xConverter at 24/10/2006 - 09:55

philmerrin
I think the degradation of lens glass by neutral UV filters may be being over-stated. I recently purchased a used Pentax-F 80-200 zoom from the US. It was advertised as having a small piece chipped off the filter ring. The lens also had a promaster skylight 1A filter attached. Now I don't like filters, even to protect the lens, I understood the logic of why you wouldn't choose to put cheap glass in front of the 'state of the art"? Well with the zoom in the condition it was I stuck some black insulating tape over the hole as I realised that anylight entering the lens from anywhere but the 360 aperture at the front of the lens front must be stopped. I then zoomed to 200mm and took some test shots of a letter box with house number 150 yards up the street. I then removed the tape and filter and re-took the same shot with the same settings and the house number was considerably clearer when viewed at 100%.

I ordered a standard Hoya UV haze filter and re-took the same shots and to my surprise the result was quite different and the house number was actually clearer with the filter on, not by much but it was. I took a further pair of shots for a second opinion the outcome was the same. I'm now convinced that if you're taking pics in sunny weather (and we get plenty of that in Queensland) then a decent UV Haze filter is a good thing for those conditions at least.

Comment by philmerrin posted on 2xConverter at 24/10/2006 - 05:06

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo