All Forum Comments
Comment by OldTaffy posted on Yet another Pentax' media exposure at 31/10/2017 - 14:10
Cheers!
Martin
Comment by OldTaffy posted on Another pointless thread at 24/10/2017 - 23:48
Ah, micro breweries, the saviours of good beer.
.... We have many more in Yorkshire that produce wonderfully ales and stouts of excellent quality. ...
Comment by OldTaffy posted on Another pointless thread at 24/10/2017 - 23:09
What surprised me was that the dxo tests found the Pentax 21mm Limited to be slightly inferior in sharpness, and some other respects, to the Sigma zoom.
Comment by OldTaffy posted on Dissatisfied with my mid-range zoom at 24/10/2017 - 15:52
Mike-P: yes the images are still fuzzy at the edges, testing from f4 to f8. Worst at wide-angle (19mm) but still noticeable at the long end (50mm - see my example below).
Algernon: I have wondered if I should have rejected it, as the blur seems a bit worse at the right hand end of most images than at the left hand end. Maybe the glass is slightly off-centre. As for your Youtube reviewer, he heaps much praise on its build quality and good constant f2.8 max aperture, but he does admit to some softness and CA in the corners.
davidstorm: I think you are right. It is a good all-round lens and maybe I am expecting too much from an "affordable" zoom. I am a bit obsessional about sharpness. What surprised me was that the dxo tests found the Pentax 21mm Limited to be slightly inferior in sharpness, and some other respects, to the Sigma zoom. Surely one would expect a prime, and especially a Limited grade, to out-perform a zoom which of necessity will have some compromises.
AbeNormal: I have tried adjusting front/back focus, but found the factory setting to be as good as any.
Below is a composite of a recent photo, in which I show 250x250 pixel clips from the left-hand end, the centre, and the right-hand end of a photo (Whitby West Pier) that I have just uploaded to flickr;
link
This photo was taken at the long end of the zoom range (50mm) and even here the lack of sharpness is evident, especially at the right-hand end. Taken at f5.6, 1/1000, ISO400. I don't have any suitable wide-angle images to use in this way at present, but edge sharpness is worse when one is in 17 to 30mm range.

Maybe I'm just being hyper-critical in 'pixel peeping' at 250 px clips from an image that is 5472 pixels long?
Thanks again for your thoughtful comments.
Martin
Comment by OldTaffy posted on Dissatisfied with my mid-range zoom at 23/10/2017 - 11:17
This lens seemed to be well regarded, but I have been disappointed with its edge sharpness. Some unsharpness in the corners was mentioned in the reviews, but I find mine much worse than the somewhat maligned DAL 18-55 at the edges. The Sigma lens is certainly good in the mid-field - almost as good as the prime DA 35mm f2.8 Ltd which I bought from a PU member a while ago. It is also nice to have a constant f2.8 aperture, but I am always annoyed to find the edges fuzzy when viewed at 100% in PSE, more or less through the whole zoom range.
Maybe someone who won't spend well over three hundred quid on a lens shouldn't be pixel-peeping, but I began looking at some wide-angle primes to complement the superb DA 35mm macro. To my disappointment, I see that the dxomark tests of the Pentax HD DA 21mm f3.2 Ltd are actually slightly worse than their scores for the Sigma 17-50 that I am grumbling about!
What to do? I am sure that many of you use lenses in this focal length range, and maybe you are content with them, but if anyone can suggest a good wide-angle prime, in the 18-25 mm range, that performs better but doesn't cost a month's pension, let's hear from you!
I wait in hope....
Martin
Comment by OldTaffy posted on Dissatisfied with my mid-range zoom at 22/10/2017 - 16:58
Does anyone have experience of using LED lighting? I am not sure if one gets a continuous colour spectrum (as in sunlight) or is it an interrupted spectrum as in some fluorescent lamps?
Comment by OldTaffy posted on Best SRL and Lens to photograph oil paintings? at 16/09/2017 - 16:49
OK, so where's the problem?
At the end of the day the choice is ours. No-one forces us to use their free services.
Martin
Comment by OldTaffy posted on Oath/Flickr at 14/09/2017 - 14:53
Does this have any good or worrying significance?
There is an entry for Oath on Wikipedia: link
It seems that it is a branch of a major American media conglomerate: Verizon Digital Network, which now owns Yahoo (who own Flickr) as well as AOL, Huffington Post. Do you think that it is unimportant that Flickr is now under new ownership, or could it lead to intrusive abuse of our details?
Martin
Comment by OldTaffy posted on Oath/Flickr at 11/09/2017 - 18:24
Comment by OldTaffy posted on Another pointless thread at 09/09/2017 - 23:00

