mikew

Joined: 22nd October 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

mikew
Isn't the 15mm also rather bigger?

Comment by mikew posted on UWA Primes - 14mm or 15mm? at 07/04/2010 - 19:46

mikew
Depends what you want - I have a Vivitar 70-200 manual focus lens with A setting. f3.8 and it's OK nothing special but I think it would be better than the Cosina. I bought it to see if I would be blown away by it and I wasn't. As I have the much lighter Pentax 50-100 it's a cheap lens I can part with if you're interested.

I see you're in Worcestershire just like me. We can meet and you can try it if you like.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on cosina 100-400 at 07/04/2010 - 14:07

mikew
Thanks Kris.

Comment by mikew posted on Is it supper time yet? at 07/04/2010 - 07:17

mikew
No Stefan you're not. I will use the 30 in preference to the 35 if I feel the extra 5mm are significant.

For your only prime I think 40 is too long.

17-50 against 28-75, you can always crop but you can't expand

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on looking for my first prime!! at 06/04/2010 - 22:18

mikew
Thanks guys - I find it very illuminating to have others explain why they took the shot, what appealed and why they feel it worked. It's all well and good me thinking 'Can't see what the fuss is about' but if it's spelt out then I can see how the 'mechanics' combine to make the shot effective.

As a general comment I wish people would give the motivation for the choices they make when taking a photograph as it lets me see more when I am out and about. I sometimes think 'how would such and such approach this'.

There is one photographer in another forum who sees so much in the humdrum, I would love to just walk with her for an hour or two and try to understand how she thinks. What she does isn't always top notch but she is so productive and creative as are many members here. And I live to learn.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Is it supper time yet? at 06/04/2010 - 22:15

mikew
Okeydokey.

Comment by mikew posted on I want to do this ... which lens please? at 06/04/2010 - 22:03

mikew
The photograph was not made by the lens but by the skill of the photographer in drawing the three women out, realising the on board flash would create the vignetting and I am not sure but the close perspective creates the apparent distortion.

I may well be wrong, I often am, but get me three willing women in a row and I suspect I could get something similar with a kit lens, my Tamron 17-50, and my Sigma 10-20 for sure. What I would struggle to do is to get them to play up to the situation the way this very skilled photographer has. I bet She (I think) could have got just as good a photograph with my 21 ltd on a K10. She would simply work the situation slightly differently.

For me that photograph is all about the women and they way we are drawn into their group the close proximity and almost everything else is an irrelevance.

My fear is that you think you are being constrained by your equipment while in fact it's perhaps opportunity that you lack.

Then again how can I talk as I have bought a good few lenses in my time!

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on I want to do this ... which lens please? at 06/04/2010 - 20:16

mikew
Tamron 17-50 f2.8 I think it's about £350.

Many will disagree but I found it to be an excellent all round lens that I don't use any more because I am seduced by primes.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on looking for my first prime!! at 06/04/2010 - 20:06

mikew
OK I can't hold back any more - I can't see the appeal of this at all. The tree is too central, the colours look off (unless it's my monitor), the sheep seem typically pointless sheep and are in line with the rather meandering composition. The sky doesn't look too great although it has retained a full range of tones which in itself is an achievement.

The strong bits seem to me to be the two diagonals made by the grass and straw on the ground. I guess there is some appeal in the almost triangle the sheep make.

Now I have said why I don't like it can someone be rational and explain why they do like it

I'm hoping Kris won't take offence as I think he knows I am always keen to learn and will happily concede that I am wrong.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Is it supper time yet? at 06/04/2010 - 19:51

mikew
Are you sure it's the distortion you like and not the exaggerated perspective? I don't really understand your desire to buy a lens for this one very limited purpose - but hey what do I know?

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on I want to do this ... which lens please? at 06/04/2010 - 19:45

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo