mikew

Joined: 22nd October 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

mikew
'Unused' is a bit harsh - surely well cared for

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Weekly Competition # 76: Still life in black and white.Comments. at 19/12/2008 - 17:32

mikew
Damned if I know what a fine art image is but your photos seem powerful enough. Hard to tell about real quality at that size.

I'd suggest you try a critique site like link and see if they offer more advice.

I think if you want to make money you'll be quickly disillusioned!

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Fine Art Photo at 19/12/2008 - 16:05

mikew
Father Ted I read this and it helped a bit

link

Your mileage may vary as they say

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Dull photos / Dim User at 19/12/2008 - 12:46

mikew
Thanks John and Hefty - and I apologise for getting confused about which lenses Hefty has. I blame this damned cold which is a killer and robbing me of what little wit I have left.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Fortnightly Competition #5 - Christmas COMMENTS at 18/12/2008 - 12:22

mikew
I must admit the expression 'expensive balls' made me think of David Beckham

While we're here is the difference between the 16-45 and the FA43 very noticeable in real world photography?

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Fortnightly Competition #5 - Christmas COMMENTS at 18/12/2008 - 11:18

mikew
Now that one I really like. I think it would have been better but for the shadow on the man's face (it is Putin right?) and if perhaps the tree and picture were a bit more separate. The grey of the face and the green of the tree work so well together.

The overall idea and image is great just some small details don't quite work.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Abstract, Minimal & Others Variations at 18/12/2008 - 08:12

mikew
I hope that no-one minds me starting this topic.

Oh dear how does one do Bah Humbug in a photograph?

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Fortnightly Competition #5 - Christmas COMMENTS at 18/12/2008 - 08:09

mikew
Quote:
he asked me to take a group photo with it for him, 10x face detection every face dead sharp, i couldn't argue with him,
Are you suggesting that a face at 5m and one at 2m can both be in focus?

That would be a clever trick.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on should pentax dslrs have face detection added at 11/12/2008 - 10:22

mikew
No tripod! Not such an unsteady hand then! I have come to realise I simply can't hold a camera as still as I once could.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Fortnightly Competition #4 at 10/12/2008 - 20:07

mikew
As always marking is a tough job and totally subjective! I have tried to explain my reaction to each shot and I hope I’ve not been cheeky when making suggestions. Be assured no slight or offence was meant even if my clumsy use of English might make it seem so!

What I did notice is how I kept on being impressed by the technical quality of the photographs they really are very impressive. Also the effort taken to create these images within the 14 days shows commitment.

Now don’t ask questions of me with any hope of a reply as I am off away for a few days as of Thursday although I may be around first thing!

Hyram’s abstract tree. I like abstracts and this is certainly abstract but retains its woodiness as well. The colours are lovely, the focus seems to be on target. For me it lacks that killer simplicity of structure that seems to give abstracts their power but it is a good set of patterns and shapes. I think I might have tried a crop to tidy up the bottom left corner and perhaps lose the branch stump bottom right.

Tony-O’s head. Excellent technical work, well exposed, sharp well controlled colours. Two things struck me straight away. Should there be some extra dead space in front of the face? I think it’s usually more satisfactory to have a face like this looking into space rather than being so close to an edge. Also there is the light on top of the ear – it catches my eye and distracts me from the main subject. Maybe rotating the face towards the camera a little would have dealt with both these as the ear might not have caught the light and the face would have more space to look into we would see less of the back of the head.

Hefty’s Harley. Very well exposed and delicate colours – is there a slight colour cast? It seems a little blue to me. I think I need to have more of the carving in focus and have the carving more detached from the fruit behind. I think the chosen point of focus is right given the narrow DOF but that pear looks inviting, maybe it could have been further back?

Dan’s branch. Good colours and focus and that tripod ensured it was sharp. The square format was brave, maybe too brave for me as I see the lines flowing across the image and I think they would flow with more purpose if a bit was cropped from the top and rather more from the bottom. But that of course is a personal decision and the image we have does posses definite structure and composition. The more I look the more I feel there are too many worm holes.

Darkmunk’s tree. What a great shot – what a memory to recall this tree is there and the effort in going to take this shot when the weather looked right is well rewarded! I think everything about this shot works. The sky is terrific, the tree’s shape is shown so well, the curvature of the horizon just reinforces the shape of the tree. The shades of grey are so well controlled throughout. A very, very good shot!

Belinda’s mask. I like to think I can see why you had the shadow cast onto the background as it does add to the composition but the slightly odd edge effects detract for me at least. Excellent focus, sharpness and exposure control. We can see texture in the black although it looks like the white of the background suffered a bit to get this.

Cliff’s sign. I too get caught by shots of the incongruous like this but they need something extra to make them click as it were. I’m not sure this quite has it although the technicals are very good indeed. The sky on the right distracts the eye and although the colours are lovely I wonder how it looks in mono?

Dr Mhuni’s chair. Well this photograph certainly has wood all over it! The colours of the wood glow and my eye gets slightly confused by the perspective which creates some tension. There’s an awful lot in focus but I wonder if more even lighting would have improved the shot avoiding one dark edge to the chair? Being really fussy I might have cloned out the little mark on the floor and also perhaps the lighter block bottom left and also in the top hole.

Prieni’s Joint. A very well observed detail that does offer a real contrast in patterns. The focus, sharpness and exposure are all great but I think probably it would work better if the contrast within the grain was in some way greater. I’m not sure how you’d achieve this without losing some of the delicate touch but I feel it lacks a bit of punch.

SelectCase frost. A very good first entry, well exposed and focussed offering a good compromise between sharp frost and the front face of the wood. Did you fiddle with the white balance? I hadn’t realised how adjusting the white balance can make such a big difference in post processing and if you haven’t done this I wonder what effect it would have. The lighter areas of the background tend to take the eye off the frost a bit. Did you try a tight crop where there was nothing to the left and right of the post?

Bernadette’s sugar jar. Lovely pastel colours, so gentle and nothing has been lost in shadow or burnt out. I think it’s a pity that the jar ‘touches’ the green cup and that there’s a small shadow on the yellow cup. It’s really very well done as the more I look the more I realise what a delicate touch each part of the composition has. I assume it’s simply lit using natural light which is very well done. Why ISO 400? You must have been on a tripod so I’d have used ISO 100 although the image doesn’t seem to have suffered.

Martin’s box. Very accurate colours I expect but a bit flat for my taste without something else to provide some lift. There are some very nice textures in there and the way the reflected light has been handled is very good indeed. The crop at the top looks a bit forced and overall the top area seems a bit dark and ponderous.

Rob’s bird table. Beautifully crisp and bright if only the pesky blue tit had raised his head he might have added a lot to the composition. Maybe the brown background that seems to creep up the table distracts a little from the main subject but the colours are all very good and work together.

Howard’s spoon. I think you lost the bottom tip in a fold of the cloth and the top looks a tiny bit out of focus. I’d be interested to know what the lighting was, I’d guess natural as there are no very harsh shadows. Could the background have been made a dead black? Would that have added anything? Another shot with quite a high ISO when a tripod must have been used. I’d have gone for a smaller aperture and longer exposure but that’s me I guess.


I have to say picking the winner wasn’t hard as it just hit the spot but choosing the other places was very difficult indeed as they were all technically good and had various artistic merits which made choosing very hard indeed. So for good or ill:

Winner Darkmunk’s tree which in my view is spectacular, a really very striking and effective photograph.

Second Bernadette’s sugar bowl. It’s not a perfect composition but it just sits so well and the colours are so calming.

Third Prieni for the imagination to see this shot which must be quite a small detail and easily missed.

Congratulations to the winner but also to everyone who took the time to enter – I wish a few more would join us as I find the time constraint a real buzz and I’m sure they would too.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Fortnightly Competition #4 at 10/12/2008 - 19:19

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo