mikew

Joined: 22nd October 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

mikew
Well I was relying on you

Comment by mikew posted on Carl Zeiss Jena Pancolar 1.8/50mm at 01/10/2009 - 17:55

mikew
Someone will tell you. I thought they were very middle of the road. For 60 quid you should surely get an M 50 1.7 from MrCad if no-one else.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Carl Zeiss Jena Pancolar 1.8/50mm at 01/10/2009 - 17:34

mikew
If I had the money I'd have it

Comment by mikew posted on pentax K20d at 01/10/2009 - 17:30

mikew
Well here's my thoughts and you won't like them! Let me walk through my thinking.

As someone else remarked with more subtlety than I can bring to the party - just what is the subject?

You don't seem to have exposed correctly for anything there and I'm not surprised as I think it's almost impossible. The building is too dark and the sky too bright. There's a horrible colour cast in the sky as well although how it got there I can't imagine. So if I was shooting in these conditions I would be worried about how I can deal with this exposure problem.

The tree is contributing nothing - it has to go. That means you had to shoot from an angle that either drew it in properly or minimised its impact. I don't think that there's anything you can do about it now as the sky isn't interesting enough to warrant cloning the tree away.

Suppose you say the building is the main subject then we have to see it. In that case any sky will be blown out as white so now you have to deal with that problem by eliminating it from the shot as best you can. But the holes in roof will always show bright sky so now you have to lose the roof.

Now you are down to the main bulk of the building and the ivy. This you could expose well and see all the detail. I can't see enough of it in your shot to tell if there's anything much there but my experience is that this sort of building is a bit ho hum. I was and am very frustrated by a ruined church which really should provide an interesting photograph but like this building it's covered in ivy and in a difficult location. In two attempts I have not managed one good shot.

I think the best approach to this will be to seek out some detail within it. The detail in this case might be quite large but the whole buillding looks pretty dull to me so that if you did get a compelling photograph from it then it would be a real achievement.

So my conclusion is that the building as it is lit there it will almost certainly not give you a good and interesting photograph. As another forum member is fond of telling us - it's the light that counts. If the light is no good then walk on by!

Also I don't think any amount of post processing would 'rescue' this shot and here I'm with the hair shirt guys, it has to be right in the camera!

There - said you wouldn't like it! But is was intended to be of positive assistance not a wrecking spree. I simply don't think anyone could have taken a good shot given the conditions.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on alone at 01/10/2009 - 17:27

mikew
I'm sure that I'll be corrected but I didn't think these lenses were very well thought of in their day which must be 30 years ago. What sort of money?

Comment by mikew posted on Carl Zeiss Jena Pancolar 1.8/50mm at 01/10/2009 - 17:08

mikew
My Pentax battery came with an end cap.

Comment by mikew posted on Small issue over a battery at 01/10/2009 - 06:49

mikew
With this clarification I admit I misunderstood the point of the original post buy hey we've had 5 pages of fun

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Do we rely too much on Technology at 30/09/2009 - 22:41

mikew
HG said

Quote:
You grew up on film and moved to digital and took the time to use the technology. In doing so you've learnt new ways to improve/manipulate/alter images impressively so with what I've seen of your work.
and I thought it might be interesting to analyse how much manipulation was required for my entry to the fortnightly competition following on from this valid point. I once again assert nothing here is personal but in the spirit of discussion.

Comment Image


I used most of the benefits in camera. I used Av mode to get the DOF I wanted and let the camera sort out the shutter speed. I reviewed the histogram and it was OK so no Ev adjustment. In this case I did focus manually and have the AF confirm it was OK - the only reason for this was that what I wanted in sharp focus was not central and I am not quite as trusting as to the position of the red rectangle matching the AF point as I was.

What I don't understand is at a number of levels:

How would using manual helped me? I would have had to muck about getting the exposure right whereas the camera indicated what it thought was best and the histogram confirmed this.

In PS I reviewed the shot and I could quickly see that the histogram needed to be spread more which was the work of a moment with levels. No amount of mucking about in camera would achieve that - or am I wrong?

Then I could see that a little more brightness was required and at the same time I softened the contrast. Now how do I do that in camera using manual mode?

Truly, barely any manipulation and far easier than in film.

I'll be delighted if I'm told how I can do this in camera as I am a lazy so and so.

I'm not bragging or anything just taking a real life example which I believe illustrates the futility of ignoring the automation available to us. Maybe I am missing the point that was intended that using manual forces you to work out what is required and that I cheated a tiny bit as I already knew I should control the aperture and that as I was using a tripod the shutter speed was immaterial.

I do hope this post is taken in the spirit intended as a discussion point not an attack nor the big I am.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Do we rely too much on Technology at 30/09/2009 - 21:44

mikew
Away we go!

Comment by mikew posted on Fortnightly competition #26 - Comments on half and half at 30/09/2009 - 19:55

mikew
OK inspired by this guys photographs here the topic is half and half.

Now Jay takes it in a particular way and he is seriously abstract in every way (read some of his comments) but show me your take on 'half and half'.

Don't be too led by his photos as I know abstract isn't everyone's choice so it doesn't need to be abstract. It could fruit cut in half whatever. But I think it needs to be half AND half so one half isn't enough although I don't think it necessarily needs to be two halves of the same thing.

Does that make sense? I hope non English first language members can follow the idea OK you usually seem to.

Looking for quality stuff here which I know you guys and ladies can deliver!

Any questions? I'll read the comments up to the first entry and then PM me if needs be.

I nearly forgot the simple rules.

Must be taken on or after 1st October 2009 and closes 6pm 14th October 2009.

Must be taken using Pentax camera or Samsung DSLR. Ideally with the EXIF info and the maximum for the longest edge is 800 px as I recall.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Fortnightly competition #26 - Half and half at 30/09/2009 - 19:55

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo