mikew

Joined: 22nd October 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

mikew
All in my opinion and no sugar coating ...

The snail shell needs to be sharper and I don't think the dark areas help the image much. I would use a tripod for shots like these as it allows low ISO and adds to sharpness.

The wood is distracting and is the focus in the right place?

I wouldn't worry about rule of thirds. If looks right it is right and coincidentally you'll find the rule of thirds sometimes kicks in.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Still trying to master good composition at 17/11/2009 - 07:17

mikew
I find it overly harsh and too repetitive with no focal point nor any element that draws the eye in any particular way. I think that maybe some adjustment of the crop might help but not one that works for me.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Cimitiere de Montmartre at 16/11/2009 - 21:08

mikew
I agree it looks soft and I find the face looming top right unpleasant. Would a crop ta=hat eliminates or reduces the face be better with less space 'behind' the subject?

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Face in the Crowd at 16/11/2009 - 17:14

mikew
I was thinking may be we should respect the sensibilities of the lady members who might find this a bit offensive.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on To Breast or Not Too Breast in Fashion? at 16/11/2009 - 17:07

mikew
I'm no prude and not unduly PC but is the way this thread has developed really relevant and in the best possible taste?

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on To Breast or Not Too Breast in Fashion? at 16/11/2009 - 16:55

mikew
As for the tip being in focus it was the desire to have Charlotte sharp that took me that way. I'll never get the same light again so a reshoot is probably not feasible.

Comment by mikew posted on From today's graveyard jaunt at 16/11/2009 - 10:41

mikew
I agree about where the eyes go.

Cutting off limbs - you could be right although with missing feet you do wonder what was so awful that they were left out

Gee I think I can beat 150 views no comment - not on this forum but on another where I delete them if they are met with blank indifference. As you say getting a negative response is better than no response.

I think the problem is that there's nothing wrong per se so it's hard to offer anything constructive. I find a lot of my shots drop into that category. Also I think people are hesitant to be the first. After Bob commented on my headstone some more followed. I have no problem commenting and equally have no problem with being wrong and having it explained to me why I'm wrong which makes life easier!

Asking for the impossible if you could see the guy's face then it would work a whole lot better. But that is physically impossible.

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Assembly at 16/11/2009 - 08:15

mikew
Much better but I think I would have used an Exposure layer in PS and adjusted it manually as you can then also adjust the gamma.

Comment by mikew posted on Victoria no 2 at 16/11/2009 - 07:29

mikew
Well for me this lacks a focal point noisy bottom or no. I'm not sure what I'm meant to be looking at (no officer I am not looking at any children here, no, not me it's his bottom I'm looking at). As always there's huge interest in looking at a gang of kids as every face is different, every expression different but that wasn't your intention.

You've cut off the principal's feet which everyone seems to think is a jolly bad thing and probably is. The blue posts have reacted unfavourably to something and glow a bit.

So I've broken your duck but not very helpfully!

Mike

Comment by mikew posted on Assembly at 16/11/2009 - 07:26

mikew
I think based on the comments here and looking again if I were to do this again I would probably shot so the length of the ivy was in focus and I think that would still deploy the minimal DOF at 1.4 (which I confess was almost a 'because I can' application) and avoid the issues raised. Thanks for all the comments which are appreciated.

Comment by mikew posted on From today's graveyard jaunt at 16/11/2009 - 07:11

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo