McGregNi

Joined: 31st March 2012

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

McGregNi
I usually find my images look a little softer here on the forum than in a photo viewer on the computer screen. So I tend to make sure my web-sized versions are nice and sharp, but coming from RAW that means active sharpening and detailing at different stages of the workflow.

Philip, the little flowers in the last one do look a bit overdone somehow .... is that sharpening artifacts maybe? To me the others seem OK technically. I think you had a challenge here with rather bland lighting and very uniform greenery, but you've made the most of it with the angles and there is good depth to them all

Comment by McGregNi posted on A stroll to the lake with the MX-1 at 19/05/2015 - 18:57

McGregNi
A varied overview, not the least in the range of techniques and lenses employed! My favourite is the telephone and lamp on the tables because the processing works very well there. Those old leather bound books are looking like a stock trademark for you now John

The first one with the in-camera HDR has worked very naturally ... in fact you could get away with a little more HDR, but perhaps a slight highlight tweak down and shadow lift in the arched passage would help ?

The fish-eye type one can only ever be an 'effect' .... but it has the advantage of showing the entire space, which is impressive and worthwhile in itself.

A good set of this lovely old place, and how very nice to be able to photograph there without all the old biddies shuffling around !

Comment by McGregNi posted on Arley Hall with ADAPS at 19/05/2015 - 18:50

McGregNi
Here's my take on it ..... I've assumed its basically a daylight shot underexposed, so I've gone for a lighter look and worked to bring out detail while controlling noise in the brightened foreground.

First up into Sagelight 4 for tonal stuff, shadow raising and low-tone contrast boosting, brightness and highlight control, a little polariser and vibrance.

16bit TIFF exported out into PS CS2 for selective (via layers) noise reduction and detail enhancing with Topaz DeNoise. A little colour balance adjustment and a little detailing with Topaz Detail 5 (again on a layer selectively for the ground only). I corrected for barrell distortion and straightened, cropped as required following this.



Comment Image

Comment by McGregNi posted on That old sunset problem - RAW challenge at 19/05/2015 - 17:20

McGregNi
johnriley wrote:
.... Nigel, do we need the foreground? With any image I always ask myself what I'm making an image of and anything that isn't part of, IMHO, shouldn't be there. Hence I culled the foreground.
ahh, silly me .... there I was assuming your fingers had slipped

OK .... DNG downloaded, thanks Mark ..... will fire up Sagelight 4.4 later and see what it can do! Will try and post a result tonight .

Comment by McGregNi posted on That old sunset problem - RAW challenge at 19/05/2015 - 13:40

McGregNi
John, I think you may have accidentally pressed the 'chop image off at bottom' button ...... easy to do if you lean the wrong way

Comment by McGregNi posted on That old sunset problem - RAW challenge at 19/05/2015 - 11:58

McGregNi
I'm not used to judging things against any pre-conceived standard, rather seeing photos individually and judging then against their own terms. Here, there are 2 key elements to the image ... The foreground backlit reeds and the sky. It's a tough job balancing the contrast , and you've managed that well ... The blend in the highlight areas is good. Perhaps it needs shadow raising at the bottom?

So in the context of its style ... 2 key contrasting elements ...... Unfortunately the extra element over to the right really counts as a distraction. So I think this is really the aspect that weakens it. Do you have it shot at different angles without those trees?

Comment by McGregNi posted on What's bad about this? C & C Please. at 19/05/2015 - 09:42

McGregNi
Thanks! I'm quite happy dividing opinions Derek , perhaps its the perspective and angle? Someone elsewhere actually said he would like to wallpaper the house with that photo!

Comment by McGregNi posted on Spring : Continued at 19/05/2015 - 08:21

McGregNi
A lovely pair Kris! I always like it when our exposures reveal that beautiful backlit transparency, even more so than the naked eye, and it's put to beautiful effect here.

Comment by McGregNi posted on Yet another flower at 18/05/2015 - 17:05

McGregNi
I agree on all the above, great advice there .

How much of the frame is taken up with the lamp? If it is very small, surrounded by lots of black space, then you are probably taking too long an exposure anyway, and will just end up with a blown-out white spot. Can you zoom in and fill a good bit of the frame with the lamp, and switch to spot meter mode .... This should give a good exposure for the light source (this would work fine in Av mode for example), and you shouldn't have a massively long exposure time. Once you've metered for the lamp, note the settings and then fix them in manual, then zoom back out for your whole image.

The behaviour you describe does sound normal for the K7 when shooting long exposures, like 10 secs plus. I think you are interrupting the image recording each time. Just leave it to complete the process (it can seem forever!). It's a necessary evil in order to control the noise generated from the long exposure and very little image data in such a dark picture.

I didn't think it was possible to switch off dark frame subtraction ... ? I thought the custom settings for NR related only to software image processing by the Prime II processor for JPEGs ...?

Comment by McGregNi posted on Can't get a manual exposure at 18/05/2015 - 10:36

McGregNi
Good event coverage, plenty of action .... You've caught the water splashing really well which gives the added drama. No 6 is my favourite (no background distractions).

Comment by McGregNi posted on Chatsworth International Horse Trials at 18/05/2015 - 08:31

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo