PLUS

johnriley

Joined: 19th March 2002

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

johnriley
Carrying on from a point in another thread, a discussion of sharpening.

As little as needed avoids haloes and other artifacts, and Unsharp Mask is my tool of choice. I have used this from Photoshop 7 through to CS5, which I currently use.

Unsharp Mask, Threshold 3, Radius and amount depending upon size of final image and image factors. In terms of amount, web images are usually 1000 pixels on the longest side, which fits in with EPZ requirements. It is convenient to make just this one size wherever possible. Radius is around 1.1 to 1.4 pixels and amount about 50% for a K20D or K-5 and ambout 75% for a Q. Different types of sensor behave differently and cameras themselves have different characteristics of JPEG sharpening. For DSLRs +1 sharpening in camera is already set by me.

For A3 prints, a larger radius of pixels as there are so many more pixels in any dimension of the image, so usually 2.2 or therabouts. Sharpening for print needs to be slightly higher, so 100% to 125% is the norm. For other sizes, we can make something in between these two sets of values.

Hopefully my web images look sharp but not over sharp, and likewise my prints.

The technique of converting to LAB mode and just sharpening the luminance (black and white) channel is useful for architectural subjects as the colour information is not affected at all, so we end up with an underlying very sharp image with no artefacts in the colour channels. We convert back to RGB before saving for print.

In recent times, using LAB colour as an intermediate step has not seemed so necessary so I can only presume that the algorithms have been improved in each upgrade of Photoshop.

Comments and questions most welcome.

Comment by johnriley posted on Sharpening in Photoshop at 16/12/2012 - 22:59

johnriley
Quote:
What I would be interested in, though, is how your sharpening differs for different sizes of images.
Rather than hijack this thread I'll start a new thread on the subject later on tonight.

Comment by johnriley posted on Lightroom 4 AND Photoshop? at 16/12/2012 - 20:50

johnriley
AuraTodd wrote:
How do I do it from Photobucket please?
See the third thread down in the Your Photos section.

Comment by johnriley posted on How to post images new! at 16/12/2012 - 19:47

johnriley
darkskies wrote:
Yes, but John, all that has been done beforehand for each image. Why would you want to do that on output?

All the publishing process does is convert your already processed images to jpegs, with a sharpening for output to screen if you so desire, and then send it all to Flickr.

It in no way replaces the fine adjustments that you have described that have been done previously in Develop.
That's assuming that converting to JPEG needs no further input from the photographer, but, depending on image size required, the amount of sharpening, for example, will vary, as will the parameters for that sharpening.

I think you're describing things from the point of view of an entirely different workflow. I've got six articles here on PU that describe a very simple workflow and which summarise what I might do. See the articles section and you'll know straight away if we're talking about different approaches.

Comment by johnriley posted on Lightroom 4 AND Photoshop? at 16/12/2012 - 19:34

johnriley
Quote:
Why would you want to adjust levels?
All part of the process of preparing and fine tuning an image for presenting to the world. Levels is a powerful way of adjusting brightness and contrast, as is Curves.

Sharpening can also be fine tuned for a particular image, not necessarily globally.

It depends how much control we want over the final result.

Comment by johnriley posted on Lightroom 4 AND Photoshop? at 16/12/2012 - 16:39

johnriley
Quote:
Lightroom will create all the jpegs in the background and send them to Flickr
That's assuming Lightroom creates a JPEG to the spec we want. Are there adjustable parameters for specifying levels and sharpening?

Comment by johnriley posted on Lightroom 4 AND Photoshop? at 16/12/2012 - 15:46

johnriley
I'm afraid that we can't promote any charities on Pentax User so this can't be promoted on here either. Like many things, in principle a good idea but there are huge practical problems.

Comment by johnriley posted on Pentax calendar at 16/12/2012 - 15:07

johnriley
SRS are offering 10 ex-demo K-01 cameras for £219 on eBay, the regular price on their website is somewhat higher.

The outgoing Q body is also available at what loooks like a clearance price of £99, again from SRS and eBay. Excellent news, if you don't have one here's your chance!

Always nice to have the heads up on bargains! I'll put this is Leads to Deals.

Comment by johnriley posted on Pentax Full Frame at 16/12/2012 - 13:35

johnriley
Ah, these were yours? You didn't say that the first time around. This isn't really a classified ad because you're not offering the items her, but we'll let it pass.

As a rule, this section is for people to buy and sell Pentax-related items here rather than link to adverts/auctions elsewhere.

Comment by johnriley posted on K10d and K5 for sale at 16/12/2012 - 13:08

johnriley
Also, turn off highlight and/or shadow correction as this too limits the ISO range.

Comment by johnriley posted on K01 Auto Iso - Minimum Iso at 15/12/2012 - 18:59

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo