PLUS

johnriley

Joined: 19th March 2002

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

johnriley
Can't argue with your logic, and indeed wouldn't want to.

I'm just wondering how the choices have been affected by new approaches to photography.

At one time, let's say 1950s to mid 1960s, the choice was a fairly universal 35mm-50/55/58mm-135mm. It was Pentax at the forefront of new technology from 1964 that gradually stretched this to replace 35mm with 28mm, then 24mm, and for the "swinging sixties" crowd even the new fisheye that did not need mirror lock-up.

In the 1970s the 28mm-50mm-135mm-200mm set up would be fairly normal, with some preferring the shorter 100mm. There was plenty of choice from Pentax, with the "odd" lengths of 120mm and 150mm being included.

The 1980s saw the beginning of the zoom revolution, and this has now become the norm. Pentax continue to produce excellent and sometimes exceptional primes, and continue the precedent already established of not being afraid to use unconventional focal lengths.

I would not discourage any new lenses if they feel there's a demand for them.

Ultimately though it does very much depend on the individual - and a wide lens choice does mean that there is something to suit all requirements.

Comment by johnriley posted on What primes would we like to see? at 11/09/2010 - 17:47

johnriley
80-400mm or even 100-400mm would be very nice.

Comment by johnriley posted on What primes would we like to see? at 11/09/2010 - 15:54

johnriley
Still plastic construction, but yes, a metal mount.

Comment by johnriley posted on DA-L 35mm f2.4 announced at 11/09/2010 - 15:51

johnriley
Quote:
"So a full plastic 35/2.4 is available at Nikkor 35/1.8 price?"
The SRS price for the Nikon is £165, and we can expect that will be a plastic lens as well.

The Pentax we have no final street price, no tests and so we don't know what is special about it, if anything. Except that it fits our cameras and the Nikon doesn't....

Perhaps it would be a good idea to make a judgement when we know something?

Comment by johnriley posted on DA-L 35mm f2.4 announced at 11/09/2010 - 15:18

johnriley
Quote:
I do not dispute the 35mm capabilities but what would you use given the task?
To be fair, not being privy to what the task was that can be rather hard to answer. I would not be surprised if the shots were medium format, or even large format, but there's nothing to indicate that they were.

Nowadays for serious huge professional images, maybe even a DSLR. I've seen some images at Focus on Imaging even from the Sigma SD14 that have been as large as those in the video.

Ultimately it depends on the use, the size required and the viewing distance.

Comment by johnriley posted on Medium Format 645D at 11/09/2010 - 15:12

johnriley
Quote:
However, there exists a user group that uses 200mm+ as a Std lens on the street, purely for isolation. I see this as the norm in day to day use
This is a very detached and distant form of street photography, but perfectly valid if that's what is wanted. At some point, as the lenses get longer still, maybe even intrusive in some eyes.

Certainly it's the very opposite of the "get into the crowd and interact" concept.

It all depends on the photographer's style.

Comment by johnriley posted on What primes would we like to see? at 11/09/2010 - 14:40

johnriley
Quote:
Let me get this straight... you wouldn't be excited by a 200mm equivalent f1.4 ?
Not in the slightest. I wouldn't buy a 200mm-equivalent lens as I don't have a need for one, regardless of the speed.

Quote:
35mm is a classic focal length & many a street photographers mainstay
True, going back to the 1950s. By the 1960s photographers were already moving wider, even as far as 24mm in some cases. Tastes change and I'm not sure we can revisit Cartier-Bresson in the same way as once we might.

Comment by johnriley posted on What primes would we like to see? at 11/09/2010 - 14:30

johnriley
So basically it has nothing to do with the 645D - the idea is tenuous at best - professionals have been producing images like that from 35mm since the 1960s.

Comment by johnriley posted on Medium Format 645D at 11/09/2010 - 14:24

johnriley
There's an 85mm f2.2 with 2 elements if that helps! In fact, someone in the back pages of AP has been trying to sell one for a while, for around £350 I think.

Comment by johnriley posted on DA-L 35mm f2.4 announced at 11/09/2010 - 14:22

johnriley
What has this got to do with the Pentax 645D? :

Comment by johnriley posted on Medium Format 645D at 11/09/2010 - 14:02

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo