jeallen01

Joined: 12th February 2009

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

jeallen01
actech12 wrote:

And here is the crux of the matter, straight and level. Should adjoining manoeuvres separated by level flight over a road be allowed? Civil aircraft regularly overfly houses and roads with a descending manoeuvre at low altitude close to stalling but it is deemed ok.
Dave
A very good question, and not one that I have seen mentioned (as yet) anywhere else, especially as rapid sequences of aerobatic manoeuvres are obviously physically and mentally stressful for the pilot - whereas normal civil aircraft landings (and take-offs, of course) are generally planned and performed in relative "slow time" whn compared with aerobatic sequences and with few violent changes in direction or height - and so pilot disorientation could occur.

What a combination of possible contributory factors - chances are that there was no single main contributory cause of the aircraft hitting the A27 EXCEPT for the decision to locate part of the display area to the North of that road. Whether it would happened if that had not been done, we will never know.

Comment by jeallen01 posted on 22nd-23rd Aug - Shoreham Airshow anyone? at 23/08/2015 - 20:01

jeallen01
ilovesaabs wrote:
Weren't there a few mentions about the wind conditions by the PA? Not long before the Hunter arrived if I remember correctly.
There was a crosswind appeared to be coming from the South/South East, which was making it difficult for some smaller lighter aircraft to land against it to the South, but I doubt that would have affected the much heavier/faster Hunter very much unless he was also landing.

OTOH, flying downwind to the North would have meant that the wings would have generated less lift than had he been flying upwind. In addition I did see (think it is on PPRuNe) that the high (30C+, I think) air temperature might have reduced the air density and thus further reduced the lift that the wings generated.

Someone on that forum also commented about the relative shortness and narrowness of the tarmac runway, as compared with those at many other airfields, as that may have mislead the pilot into thinking he was flying higher and faster than he actually was - this was mentioned over the PA sometime before the accident, so it should have been well-understood nevertheless.

Comment by jeallen01 posted on 22nd-23rd Aug - Shoreham Airshow anyone? at 23/08/2015 - 19:40

jeallen01
actech12 wrote:


By this I mean is it possible that the loop (can't remember its name, but the 'climb/roll inverted/pull under back down the crowd line' manoeuvre) was meant to be performed slightly later over the fields along the river Adur, which was just another hole in the cheese?

Dave
Dave

I think I gathered that the manoeuvre is called a "cloverleaf" - and it is possible that the organisers and the pilot did plan for that, but that would still have meant that the display area included the A27.

The latter seems to me to be somewhat confirmed because, as we queued to get in, there was a lot of aerobatic activity over to the North of the road in the area you mention. Presumably the assumption was that when aircraft crossed the road in either direction then they would be flying pretty much straight and level - that assumption tragically turned out to be incorrect.

PS: the Duxford/M11, Waddington and Fairford issues are all talked about on PPRuNe.

Comment by jeallen01 posted on 22nd-23rd Aug - Shoreham Airshow anyone? at 23/08/2015 - 19:30

jeallen01
jeallen01 wrote:
Getting the lens back this afternoon! The board has been replaced to fix (hopefully!) the back-focus problem - so at least some of the spares ARE still available!
Was asked to take the K-3 with me but also took the K-5 (and it seems that they have a K-30 for test purposes) - and the repaired lens worked on both bodies with little need for in-body adjustment (although the 100mm end is not so good as the longer focal lengths). There is however a big BUT - the images from the K-3 were softer than those from the K-5 when informally tested by Mr Cortez by taking shots of details on a building across the adjacent wide road, and that confirmed that the K-3 does need a service as I thought was the case .

So took the K-5 and this lens to Shoreham (another story, as you probably now know) and the combo worked pretty well - so this lens looks to be pretty much "sorted".

However, whilst at Sigma, I asked Mr Cortez about the spares situation for this and similar older lenses, and here (accurately, I hope) is a brief summary of what he said:
- when lenses are discontinued then there is a defined spares stock for each model and camera mount (Canikon, Sony, Pentax, etc.) combo that is kept in Japan;
- the more popular the camera mount is, and the more of the relevant lenses that are sold, then, inevitably, the spares for those more popular combos are depleted/run out soonest.
- they fully warrantee all lenses that are repaired for 6 months, and to do that they then need to have ALL the relevant spares for that lens available and not just those need to fix an other wise OK lens - and so they generally actually need at least 2 of each spares item to cover the possible failure of the first one fitted. That probably explains why some people have been told that no spares are available.
- in my case, the lens was otherwise OK apart from the backfocus, and so Mr Cortex took a bit of punt and asked if they did have the relevant circuit board, - and he said he was VERY surprised when 2 of them did actually turn up; the reason appearing to be the relative "unpopularity" of the Pentax mount version of the lens (hurrah for that, for a change :lol!

PS: the charge of £59.99 was VERY reasonable in the circumstances

Comment by jeallen01 posted on Sigma 100-300 F4 at 23/08/2015 - 19:18

jeallen01
actech12 wrote:


No apologies necessary, John, I am the same, and somewhat analytical - must be the job! But sometimes I think we try to make things too safe for everyone and forget we also need to 'live' a little as well. If this became an everyday occurrence at airshows then I agree, but a one off is a tragic event. We cannot build every house in a faraday cage just because one was hit by lightning.

Dave
Dave

Since the last post I have been looking at a few threads on the FighterControl forum, which lead me to the PPRuNe site where there is a big discussion by aviation professionals on this tragic accident.

Whilst there is a lot about the aerial manoeuvre and the age of the aircraft, there is also a lot about the riskiness of some venues, and Shoreham is definitely one of them that raised a lot of (as yet) unanswered questions, notably as to why the risk assessments allowed the display area to extend well over the A27, whereas there seems to be quite a consensus (and official guidance!) that display areas should be within the bounds of the airfield or over otherwise unpopulated areas with little or no means of public access.

There is also a lot about acceptance - or not - of "risk" by participants, "bystanders/viewers" and totally uninterested "passers by" or "neighbours" (like some of the people living near Tianjin) - and the fact that the people on the A27 were presumably "just passing by" and had not consciously accepted any of the risks inherent at airshows. That's why when people get hurt by something they were not involved in, and over which they had no control, because they just happened to be in the "wrong place at the wrong time", then there is more public anger and likely repercussions.

See where we're going?
(and I hope I don't have to revise my opinion of Rod Dean, but then again I may have to)

John

Comment by jeallen01 posted on 22nd-23rd Aug - Shoreham Airshow anyone? at 23/08/2015 - 18:50

jeallen01
actech12 wrote:

Hi John,
...One thing Hunters are prone to is stalling if put in too tight a turn (angle of attack increases too much and destroys the lift over the wing). What I thought I saw was an increase in pitch attitude (realisation of being too low to complete the loop so pulling back on the stick more) thus stalling the aircraft and hitting the ground. I stress this is only my opinion, I'm sure there are plenty others and from a closer viewpoint.

Dave
That sounds very plausible, nevertheless.

Comment by jeallen01 posted on 22nd-23rd Aug - Shoreham Airshow anyone? at 23/08/2015 - 17:25

jeallen01
[i]
actech12 wrote:


My thoughts are with those that have lost loved ones or are waiting to find out. The services were exemplary while I was there. The only thing I can think of that could have been improved was the 'evacuation' plan. There are in fact two pedestrian exit points (which were both eventually opened once possible), but there are also two road exits, the main to the north where the accident took place and the service road to the south west corner under a low bridge which restricts access to cars and small vans, which is usually open to the public but for corporate ticket holders only during the airshow. A lot of distressed people could have exited in their cars using this route far earlier and reduced the pressure on the organisers etc., all that would have been needed was one organiser's rep and a PC just to ask them if they had any useful video or photographic evidence on the way out. While this was not a pleasant experience for those directly or indirectly involved, my personal belief is that you cannot legislate and make everything in life 100% risk free otherwise we have no life. I do hope that sense prevails and it is seen for what it is - a very tragic accident. The latest news as I write this is that the pilot is fighting for his life. My thoughts are with him and hopefully he will recover and overcome any guilt he is almost certainly going to feel.

Dave
Dave

Was not sure about the 2nd pedestrian bridge, so didn't mention it - but the organisers could also have opened the Emergency Exit track to the A27 much earlier than they did - the only reason I can think for that not happening is that they kept it clear for Emergency vehicles coming in from the West, but I am pretty sure that they did not have to wait until around 6-7pm before they did open it (the coaches appeared to get out much earlier - around 4pm IIRC.

Sorry if I sound somewhat "dispassionate" about those killed and injured (and, of course, their many relatives and friends) - my wife has already said this to me! - but, having been a safety engineer in the defence and other industries for many years before I retired, I tend to take a rather analytical approach to accident prevention and to identifying the causes of accidents so as to try to prevent them happening again (or even better, before they ever happen at all). Thus I don't think the risks and possible risk reduction and control issues were sufficiently thoroughly thought through before this tragic event.

Comment by jeallen01 posted on 22nd-23rd Aug - Shoreham Airshow anyone? at 23/08/2015 - 17:15

jeallen01
The risks from airshow performances are relatively well known after the many years (over a 100 years so far) they have been taking place, and lessons are learnt every time things like these happen and arrangements are (generally) made to improve them.

This is the same approach that the aircrash investigators take with civil airliners (watch "Aircrash Investigation" on the satellite channels for many examples) and there are actually very many fewer people killed or injured in both fields of aviation than there were in 50's 60's and 70's, even though there are more planes, they have got faster and more people attend such events/fly in civil airliners than did then.

I think one of the real problems with Shoreham is not the flying but with the location and very limited number of routes to enter/leave the site: 1 pedestrian bridge from the East, and 2 road access points but only one of those is open for the general public access, and is the one where the Hunter crashed. That effectively meant HUGE queues to get it (we were queuing on the A27 Westbound approach for over an hour and there were masses of cars behind us, and also meant that with that access completely devastated then virtually everybody on the airfield was trapped for 6-8 hours (there were many vehicles still behind us when we got out).

Therefore, had a similar crash happened a couple of hours before, the aircraft would have ploughed into the middle of dozens of virtually stationary vehicles and hundreds of people.

That was an organisation cockup/oversight or call it what you will.

It is also hugely worrying that if the crash had happened just inside the airfield, but near/on that public access road, then hundreds of people would have been killed/injured and the Emergency Services would only have had very limited and difficult access to the site. As it was, the 200-300m long fireball, and most of the debris, was spread in an open area beyond the trees to the North East of the airfield - and thus not thrown anywhere near the public parking and viewing areas - and the Emergency Services could access the impact site from the A27 itself, and to a very limited extent from inside the airfield site via the restricted access entrance, which has a very low bridge, on the South side.

Maybe next year's show (if there is one) should only be via pre-booked tickets (like Duxford's September BoB Anniversary Show will be) so that the numbers can be realistically controlled (which they were not yesterday)?

Comment by jeallen01 posted on 22nd-23rd Aug - Shoreham Airshow anyone? at 23/08/2015 - 15:38

jeallen01
Gwyn wrote:
[quote:3496ace15f="jeallen01"]Was, and still am at the show - unlikely to get out for a couple more hours.
Had just stood up to photo the Hunter coming in from the North when he just got too low, went below the trees & exploded, leaving a trail of fire & thick smoke for about 200-300m. Took about an hour for the smoke & flames to go/be put out.

I hope you made it home eventually, and are recovering from the shock of it all.
I think we finally got off the site at around 8pm, via the Emergency Exit (across the runway and then down a dirt track) onto the A27 West bound (about 200-300m West of where the Hunter impacted the road & cars), and then home at around 10.30pm (with a brief comfort & snacks stop). Neither of us went to bed until midnight or later because it takes time to wind down after a day like that.

Vaguely similar thing happened at Duxford Flying Legends in 2013 when a Skyraider took the tail off Rod Dean's Mustang at about 300-400ft - but Rod bailed out PDQ and was OK, and the accident happened on the far side of the airfield and the Mustang went down in a field well away from anybody.

Coincidently Rod was the Flying Director at Shoreham yesterday, and (knowing just a little of his history in the aviation business) I doubt he would have sanctioned any manoeuvres that had a remote chance of ending like this one did. So I'm suspecting a combination of pilot error (too low and slow into the loop, and possibly too far North along the flight line - if the latter had not happened then the accident would probably happened on the airfield itself) and mechanical failure (flame out because no jet noise was reported on the way down to the impact?).

Somewhat doubt that the pilot blacked out because he (we hope still) is an ex-RAF instructor with a fast jet history, and the Hunter was not really known for very high G turns.

Comment by jeallen01 posted on 22nd-23rd Aug - Shoreham Airshow anyone? at 23/08/2015 - 12:49

jeallen01
Was, and still am at the show - unlikely to get out for a couple more hours.
Had just stood up to photo the Hunter coming in from the North when he just got too low, went below the trees & exploded, leaving a trail of fire & thick smoke for about 200-300m. Took about an hour for the smoke & flames to go/be put out.

IMHO show probably won't happen tomorrow - too much shock and confusion everywhere.

Comment by jeallen01 posted on 22nd-23rd Aug - Shoreham Airshow anyone? at 22/08/2015 - 18:46

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo