jeallen01

Joined: 12th February 2009

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

jeallen01
RayB wrote:
jeallen01 wrote:
And use a little thread-lock compound (or just the other half's nail-varnish because that works just as well! Perfectly serious! ) on the screws before you tighten them up, to stop the same thing happening again.
On a more serious note - it would seem that you have had experience of this, so is there a manufacturing issue for Sigma to be aware of? That is 2 (maybe 3) that have come to light in a few days...
Actually, NO I don't as I don't have a Bigma (too "BIG" for me ), but the same thing has happened with the screws on my specs, which are of a very similar size! - and that is the easy solution (especially when you are on holiday and have, obviously, left the threadlock stuff behind!! :mrgreen].

OTOH, the same thing could easily happen with ANY small screws on lenses or other items - manufacturers rely on torque-setting tools during assembly but they don't always operate accurately, or "it's Friday" and the operators just get careless.

Then again, it could just be a question of tolerances = over-large holes, and too-small screw diameters, and so the screw is not a snug fit and then works loose overtime. That could account for time/batch-related problems like this, and that could ALSO affect OTHER lenses of different types made at the same time because the same screw-cutting tools were used and the screws in question came from the same batch from the relevant supplier.

All these things happen in the manufacturing industry - I know, I been there on the periphery for most of my working life !!

Comment by jeallen01 posted on SIGMA 170-500mm 1:5-6.3 APO DG Zoom at 28/10/2011 - 21:42

jeallen01
RayB wrote:
Don't know if this is relevant, but I had a similar issue with the same lens.

Have a look at the lens mount - is it loose at all? I found that it had enough movement in it to stop the pins making contact with the camera body. A couple of the screws holding the mount in were indeed a bit loose, but this was soon cured with the aid of a jewellers screwdriver
And use a little thread-lock compound (or just the other half's nail-varnish because that works just as well! Perfectly serious! ) on the screws before you tighten them up, to stop the same thing happening again.

Comment by jeallen01 posted on SIGMA 170-500mm 1:5-6.3 APO DG Zoom at 28/10/2011 - 16:23

jeallen01
[quote:3496ace15f="timothyw"]Keep the DA55-300. Consider it the Littlema replacement for the Bigma when travelling light.[quote]

Agreed - it fulfills an entirely different role when travelling "light", and is much smaller but still pretty sharp (I wouldn't sell mine for that reason!).

OTOH, if you don't use it for that purpose, then sell it to someone else who will make good use of it

Comment by jeallen01 posted on Lenses to keep, lenses to let go at 28/10/2011 - 16:18

jeallen01
Seems that this issue is not common, but is also not unique to Pentax lenses.

For example
http://askville.amazon.com/SimilarQuestions.do?req=Nikon-D80-70-300mm-zoom-lens-...

http://photography-on-the.net/forum/showthread.php?t=103008

Several of the posters point to issues such as light reduction, taking the effective aperture below the working range of the autofocus and also to the effective reduction in depth of field at longer focal lengths.

It should be noted that some circular polarising filters are better that others with the same nominal characteristics in respect of light transmission - maybe the Hoyas are better than some others (as has been shown in some back-to-back tests between manufacturers and types of UV filters)?

I have also seen a number of posts/manufacturers' info pages that say that graduated ND filters don't work well with longer focal length lenses - possibly the same effect happens as a result of light reduction and contrast changes at those focal lengths with circular polarising filters as well (just guessing here

Comment by jeallen01 posted on Focus Issues with 55-300mm and Circular Polariser at 23/10/2011 - 18:08

jeallen01
Mike-P wrote:
jeallen01 wrote:


If you are talking about the EX range as a whole, I cannot but disagree!

Sigma 70-200mm f2.8 and 100-300mm f4.
I know that you do use your lenses a lot, but some of us do try to take care with their expensive kit! Mine are all in far better condition than those,with nothing approaching that sort of damage, and two of the lenses were, as I said, second-hand when I got them - so the previous owners took care of them as well.

OTOH, and something I should have said in my first comment, I will agree with any comments that the EX range don't have the hard, semi-gloss finish of some of the CaNikon (and other) lenses - and that type of finish probably is more durable.

Nevertheless, the EX range is a lot cheaper than its CaNikon equivalents and optically nearly as good as the best of them. As such they are very popular because they deliver the goods - a feeling which you obviously share or you would not be using them!

Comment by jeallen01 posted on WTB - Sigma 1.4X DG APO EX TC at 22/10/2011 - 14:44

jeallen01
[quote:3496ace15f="Mike-P"]
Quote:
First of all the EX finish is possibly the worst I have ever seen on any lens. If you spray paint onto plastic I would have thought it's pretty obvious it won't last long..
If you are talking about the EX range as a whole, I cannot but disagree!

I have had a 10-20 f4-f5.6 for nearly 4yrs and it is my walk-around lens for holidays and lots of other things (my wife likes going to big National Trust country houses and it it brilliant in those on the K-5). I bought a s/h 70-200 EX f2.8 and 1.4x EX TC around the same time and used it at a lot of airshows, and then a s/h f4 100-300 earlier this year.

NONE of these lenses show anything more than very light scuffing, and then mainly to the hoods - not the lenses themselves - and the 10-20 has had a pretty rough time of it (even being dropped, filter ring first, when the strap of my GX10 came unhitched - the only damage was to the filter itself!).

The only signs of use on any of these lenses are actually that the matt black finish is getting a little "dull" as compared with a 2X EX TC that I have had for 3-4 yrs but is hardly ever used, and so stays in the bag or the cupboard

Comment by jeallen01 posted on WTB - Sigma 1.4X DG APO EX TC at 22/10/2011 - 08:54

jeallen01
Non-DG version still going here (in Finland) for 100 Euros + P&P
link

Comment by jeallen01 posted on WTB - Sigma 1.4X DG APO EX TC at 22/10/2011 - 08:31

jeallen01
quote:3496ace15f="Mike-P"]
jeallen01 wrote:

AFAIK, for the 1st owner from new and if the lens is registered with Sigma UK within 30 days of purchase in the UK, then there is a 3yr warrantee - otherwise it is one year or whatever applies in the country from which it was bought (at least within the EU).
Is there an echo in here? [/quote]Yes - but I was composing my reply whilst the other reply was being composed, so neither of us knew that the other was going to provide essentially the same answer! He just beat me to posting - otherwise you would have posted the comment against his!

Comment by jeallen01 posted on 2x lens converter info please at 20/10/2011 - 20:02

jeallen01
Gwyn wrote:
Pentax repaired the camera in question when it had a problem. They have treated the OP fairly and done the right thing.
OP says he is reluctant to send the camera back again, but no doubt if he did Pentax would remove the dust and return it to him. No one is saying they have refused to this so why the need for anger or aggression?

My K-5 has dust in the viewfinder too. I live with it. It is no ones fault. It just happens sometimes.
I would not expect that to happen on a £1000/1000 Euro product, and I would not rest until it was fixed - and quickly the 2nd time around.

However, "each to his own" and I will refrain from commenting further in this thread as there appear to considerable differences in opinion which are unlikely to be reconciled easily or quickly.

Comment by jeallen01 posted on Repaired K5 - Viewfinder Dust at 20/10/2011 - 18:19

jeallen01
Dangermouse wrote:
.

Anyone know how long the Sigma guarantee is?
AFAIK, for the 1st owner from new and if the lens is registered with Sigma UK within 30 days of purchase in the UK, then there is a 3yr warrantee - otherwise it is one year or whatever applies in the country from which it was bought (at least within the EU).

Comment by jeallen01 posted on 2x lens converter info please at 20/10/2011 - 18:09

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo