All Forum Comments
Comment by Hythloday posted on Pentax 17-70mm and the K-m at 06/04/2009 - 19:04
Can anyone confirm whether the Pentax 17-70mm zoom works OK with the K-m camera?
* This lens is compatible with the Pentax K-m, K20D, K200D, K100D Super and K10D (with Ver. 1.30 or later firmware installed). When mounted on other camera bodies, the focus mode is automatically switched to manual.
**SDM-only focusing lens may be used with non-SDM Pentax DSLR bodies in manual focus mode.
http://www.srsmicrosystems.co.uk/644/Pentax-smc-DA-17-70mm-F4-ED-(IF)-SDM-Lens.html
Comment by Hythloday posted on Pentax 17-70mm and the K-m at 06/04/2009 - 18:02
link
This is about a 1/4 crop from the original.
ISO 560
70mm
f/4.0
1/60
Can you confirm if this is what is expected from this lens ?
Thanks
According tot the German magazine Colorfoto, the middle range is the best part of the lens. They also come to the conclusion that the DA17-70 is slightly better than the DA16-45mm. The 70mm range seems to be the weakest part of the lens. My few shots from everyday life taken at aperture 8.0 don't show the softness as in this test:
http://www.digitalcamerareview.com/default.asp?newsID=3676&review=pentax+17-70mm
My copy focuses quite well at 70mm, but a little worse at 17mm, as most zooms do. I focus at 70mm and zoom out the the desired focal length to take the picture.
Some early copies had problems with sharpness at 70mm, but did not focus all right at that focul length either. There seem to be no problems with later copies.
Comment by Hythloday posted on Pentax 17-70mm v Pentax 16-45mm at 06/04/2009 - 15:31
I too was a bit worried having also read those reviews. The Photozone tests seem to indicate a better sample used though. I went ahead and bit the bullet though knowing that if I got a lemon a warranty was in place to sort it out.
Comment by Hythloday posted on Pentax 17-70mm v Pentax 16-45mm at 05/04/2009 - 19:32
as I understand it the 16-45mm is pretty sharp wide open.
"Decidedly indifferent at 16mm, where it needs to be stopped down to F11 for best results, the lens improves markedly at longer focal lengths, and is at its best around 28mm. Image quality improves significantly on stopping down , with F8 and F11 the sweet spot; at smaller apertures diffraction takes its toll, as usual. Fortunately apertures smaller than F22 aren't available."
http://www.dpreview.com/lensreviews/pentax_16-45_4_p15/page3.asp
"Nice lens, which shows worse results, however, at the tele end where it loses in contrast."
http://www.colorfoto.de/Testbericht/Pentax-SMC-DA-4_16-45-mm-ED-AL_4770730.html
It does seem quite sharp wide open although softening a bit at the long end.
http://www.digitalcamerareview.com/default.asp?newsID=3676&review=pentax+17-70mm
I have both the DA16-45mm and the DA17-70mm and I don't recognise what the testers have found. For a long time the last test withheld me from buying the DA17-70mm, thinking ik was a bad lens. Finally I bought my copy last week and I did two photo shoots with this lens. I am pleasantly surprised with the sharpness. The tester must have had a bad copy.
Comment by Hythloday posted on Pentax 17-70mm v Pentax 16-45mm at 05/04/2009 - 19:18
The 16-45mm seems to be a stunning lens with not much sample variation, ie. most copies seem to be excellent.
While the 17-70mm lens seems to have some sample variation, maybe not as much as the 16-50mm but more than the 16-45mm.
Is the 17-70mm as good as or better than the 16-45mm ?
The DA17-70mm focuses silently and rapidly and is solidly built. The front element of the DA16-45mm is a bit wobbly.
Comment by Hythloday posted on Pentax 17-70mm v Pentax 16-45mm at 01/04/2009 - 16:24
see this and laugh .... or cry ...depending on your pt of view
http://www.argos.co.uk/static/Product/partNumber/0581921/Trail/searchtext%3EPENTAX.htm
http://www.argos.co.uk/static/Product/partNumber/0582683/c_1/1%7Ccategory_root%7CPhotography%7C10198049/c_2/2%7Ccat_10198049%7CCamera+lenses%7C10198094.htm
Matches design of D Xenon camera.
A real bargain, isn't it?
Comment by Hythloday posted on Argos DA50-200 wrong price at 21/12/2008 - 11:09
yeah well mine keeps changing its mind from dust to no dust, and i have cleaned sensor very well and cant see nothing at all, even tested with white paper at f22 at iso 100 and cant pick nothing out,
Has anyone else got one of these and do you have the same problem?
This is quite normal. Every time I put my camera and this lens into its bag I use the zoom lock.
Comment by Hythloday posted on Pentax SMC 18-250mm SMCP-DA F3.5-6.3 Lens at 07/12/2008 - 19:26


Looks like someone grabbed the last one just before the price rise.
In Holland the average price of the DA17-70mm is 470 pounds, the cheapest one costs 430 pounds. In Germany the cheapest DA17-70mm costs 400 pounds.
On Friday the 27th I was in London and bought my DA17-70mm at CameraWorld for 349,99 pounds.
The price difference is quite big. Why?