George Lazarette

Joined: 14th January 2004

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

George Lazarette
I'm not sure why prime lenses should be "significantly superior" on digital. Do you mean digital is superior to film when using a prime lens, or a prime is superior to a zoom?

If the latter, I don't think many people will argue, except that what applies to digital also applies to film. If the former, why?

As for modern zooms, I agree absolutely. There is no doubt that massive computing power has transformed zoom lens design, whilst primes were already too good, in many cases, to permit of further improvement.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on new Macro lens at 10/09/2005 - 21:30

George Lazarette
My view is that there is not much more (if any) CA on digital than with film, but manufacturers try to persuade us that digitally-optimised lenses are better because that way they sell more lenses.

I'd be very interested to see some real-life side-by-side comparisons of the same lens in the same conditions shooting on to both film and a digital sensor.

Mind you, I think the new lenses are extremely good, but that is more because they are computer-designed than because they are digitally-optimised.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on new Macro lens at 09/09/2005 - 21:04

George Lazarette
It would be interesting to put the lens on a film camera with very high-res slide film, and examine the slides closely under high magnification. My bet is that you would find CA there too. It's only because it is so easy to subject digital images to critical scrutiny that we notice defects on digital that we wouldn't be aware of on film.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on new Macro lens at 09/09/2005 - 12:40

George Lazarette
Some people think the 200mm macro is the best lens Pentax ever produced. It is priced accordingly.

I have both the FA 100 f2.8 and the A 100 f4. Both are superb, and I have never noticed the slightest sign of CA on either.

The F lens is thought to be optically the same as the FA.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on new Macro lens at 08/09/2005 - 22:33

George Lazarette
From Boz:

This system works as follows. The main mirror which is semi-transparent in the middle lets a fixed amount of light pass to a small auxiliary mirror at its back. This mirror redirects the light to a light sensitive CCD-sensor which makes a decision on whether the image is in focus, and then transmits an electrical signal to the auto focus chip. This chip calculates the required amount and direction of rotation of the AF motor.

The "in focus" analysis is based on phase detection. The light rays which are deflected by the auxiliary mirror are passed through an infra-red filter and then through a lens system that splits the image in two. If the image is in focus, these two images match.

If the lens is focused too far, the two images have a greater distance on the CCD line, if it is focused to narrow these two images have a shorter distance then in the ´zero´ position. Out of this image-, phase-shifting the computer calculates the number and direction of rotations for the auto focus motor.

It is not possible to stop right now from a full speed focusing to the exact point. So the speed is reduced before the right focus point is reached. The computer of the camera subdivide the number of turns to reach the right focus point. A photo interrupter in the lens count the impulses and send it back to the camera. The camera compares the actual value with the rated value. A certain number of steps before the rated value is reached the speed of the auto focus motor is reduced. To the motto "Trust is good — control is better" the computer starts a control measuring.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on mz5 flash popup doesn't work! at 15/11/2005 - 10:26

George Lazarette
Sticking my neck out, I think it's quite probable that the Super Tak 85mm f1.8 is essentially the same lens as the K 85mm 1.8. The latter is highly regarded, so the former should be very good.

I would expect the others to be good, too. In those days, Pentax cared more about quality than cost.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on M42 85MM, 105mm, 120mm? at 30/08/2005 - 21:29

George Lazarette
The filter shouldn't degrade the image on a digital sensor any more than it does on film.

Personally, I try to avoid the use of filters unless I actually need them. I know they help to protect the lens, but they inevitably interfere with the light path, and I would prefer to take care and risk damage than (slightly) impair the quality of all my images.

But it's a very personal choice. In rough conditions outdoors I will fit protective filters, but by default, I don't.

Pentax multi-coating is in fact extremely hard. When they first brought it out, they advertised it with pictures of cigarettes being stubbed out on the lens!

Of course, if you're using Sigmas, it's another story.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on UV filters on Digital *istDs at 30/08/2005 - 16:06

George Lazarette
This is a somewhat belated reply, but I would confirm that the O80C gives a very dreary light at normal distances, compared to the 280. Close-up, (its intended use), it's fine.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Macro flashes - any good? at 13/09/2005 - 00:33

George Lazarette
I think John is right. A ring-flash is an excellent starting point, but another light source as well will lift the picture.

An interesting point for DSLR owners is that you can use the Pentax AF080C (which nominally fits lenses which take 49mm filters) with the FA 100 2.8 (which takes 58mm filters). Because of the crop-factor, it works fine using a 58-49 stop-down ring without vignetting. This wouldn't (I suspect) work with film bodies.

George

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Macro flashes - any good? at 30/08/2005 - 15:25

George Lazarette
That first link is an especially clear and simple explanation of how the camera deals with the data it captures, and of the differences between the various file types.

Good find.

George

Comment by George Lazarette posted on JPEG, TIFF and RAW at 29/08/2005 - 15:45

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo