George Lazarette

Joined: 14th January 2004

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

George Lazarette
Quote:
If everybody could please take a deep breath and calm down, I'll explain. I have been making photos for 25 years. I love film (and all its artifacts, such as grain) and until now have been suspicious of digital - and all its artifacts. Whether you're talking about image or sound, digital artifacts are abrupt, intrusive, inorganic, ugly, especially compared to the gorgeous randomness of analog, as seen, for example, in film grain. And, too, I like to tightly crop my images, which makes this all the more relevant.

Now, looking at samples of the output of various late-model DSLRs I can see that a few, particularly some Nikons, are close to approximating that smooth, organic, analog feel. However, having handled both the Nikons and the K10D, I prefer the shooting feel of the latter. Unfortunately, it seems plainly obvious to me that at the pixel level (and after all, digital images are ultimately comprised of pixels) there's still a jagged, digital look.

I, personally, don't like that. It doesn't make me a troglodyte, or psychologically impaired. As far as I am aware I do not possess perverse personality quirks, such as posting screeds of replies to a forum thread without once attempting to seriously address the issue at hand.

However, my question has been answered, in a way. I perceive that the K10D is capable of inspiring great loyalty in its owners, which inclines me ever more towards taking my first step into digital with the Pentax platform. Just maybe not with this camera.
You've been looking at small JPEGs, produced you know not how, by people you do not know, with an agenda of which you are unaware, and you think you have seen some imperfections (unnoticed by most other people), and you have decided (without any justification) to attribute the cause of them to the camera, not to any of half a dozen other possible agents.

Well, that's up to you. But it's not an intelligent way to assess a camera. In my view.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on IQ fix in K10D Firmware update? at 30/08/2007 - 12:03

George Lazarette
At the end of the day, all that I worry about is whether, in the right circumstances, my camera body and lens can produce pictures that make people go "Wow!"

All my Pentax DSLRs have been fully capable of that, and nobody has ever commented adversely on image quality. Quite the reverse, in fact.

When they don't go "Wow!", it's invariably because of the limitations of the cameraman, not the kit.

I find the whole business of pixel-peeping to be almost perverted. It's certainly got nothing to do with photography. Psychology, perhaps.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on IQ fix in K10D Firmware update? at 30/08/2007 - 09:44

George Lazarette
Quote:
George Lazarette wrote:


Oh, please. Spare us the pseudo-science.

G
You may be right. I'm just paraphrasing the Photozone review. I suggest you read it for yourself, then you can disagree with it directly.
This is what bugs me. You quote this stuff without having the first idea what it means.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on IQ fix in K10D Firmware update? at 30/08/2007 - 08:12

George Lazarette
Quote:

Now it so happens that for my sins I'm a typography buff so I was especially disappointed in the results with the labels and batteries on the DPReview site, and confirmed by this image here: http://www.photozone.de/8Reviews/dslr/pentax_k10d/iso/iso100_acr37.jpg (large file). On the can, the fine red lettering and the black outline on "Repel" look really crude to my eyes. Frankly, I think it looks bad.
You don't have the first idea whether the perceived problem is because of the lens, the software, the label itself, or any other possible cause. But in typical DPReview style you have taken a tiny detail, blown it out of proportion, then jumped to conclusions.

Quote:
Now, you can accuse me of pixel peeping, but for the life of me, I can't see that any resolution benefits from a weak AA filter can outweigh such an obvious disadvantage.
Oh, please. Spare us the pseudo-science.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on IQ fix in K10D Firmware update? at 30/08/2007 - 02:01

George Lazarette
Quote:
johnriley wrote:
Quote:
Has anyone else in these parts with a 16-45 noticed anything about its CA that would justify a description of "very pronounced", at the wide end presumably?
Not in normal use. It's not really a problem.
Even on a big print, wide open, at 16mm? At the edges?

I want one... 'cos I really like the idea of 16mm... but only if I can really use it there, if you see what I mean.

Edit... It's a funny thing, this digital lark. But I really think I should expedite getting hold of a scanner and starting to go through all my negatives to see what I was happy with in the old days. I've gone straight from film (ME Super, mostly) with very mediocre glass, to the K10D, with the potential for far, far more demanding criteria.

The idea of a big enlargement of a tiny piece of a negative, to see whether there was any CA in the corners, would never have occurred to me.

How things change, eh?

But I do see much more these days. Even when I'm not looking for it. Tell me that's a good thing, please....
It depends what you are seeing. If you are seeing things that aren't there, or are totally insignificant except to a nutcase, then it's not good.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on IQ fix in K10D Firmware update? at 30/08/2007 - 01:41

George Lazarette
Quote:
That seems a bit harsh - on DPReview and the people, like me, who use it! I doubt anybody at DPReview would claim that they are making great art with their test cameras. They are simply putting them through a battery of tests to try and ascertain relative performance in different areas. The site is a great resource for someone who is about to stump up for an expensive camera and wants to avoid any nasty surprises.

Besides, I would submit that the issue we have been discussing is readily discernible at less than 100%. It goes to the heart of a camera's performance, that is, its ability to produce smooth, natural images in a range of situations.

I'm not in the least hostile to Pentax. If I don't buy the K10D on the basis of this (as I see it) "flaw", I will probably hold out for the next model in hopes that it has been addressed.

Cheers

Peter
I am sorry to have to break this news to you, but you are suffering from a serious condition known as the DPR Curse. It is manifested by an inability to see the wood for the trees. Psychologically, it's a form of projected hypochondria, wherein the sufferer experiences delusions that inanimate objects around him are diseased.

DPReview has been found to be highly addictive to some personality types, especially masochists.

The only known cure is total abstinence - from DPReview.

However, there is some good news. You are an atypical DPR addict, in that you seek to find out about an item before you buy it. This is at variance with normal DPR behaviour, where typically the addict buys something, then immediately complains about it within hours of receiving it.

You have already shown signs of wishing to break the evil grip that DPR has over you by posting on this forum, which is a haven of good sense and rationality. Indeed, some of our contributors actually take pictures just for the fun of it.

You may doubt me, but it is true.

So, are you a worrier, or a photographer? A snooper, or a snapper?

Throw off your chains, buy a K10D, and take some pictures.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on IQ fix in K10D Firmware update? at 29/08/2007 - 23:27

George Lazarette
Quote:


I agree with you that the reviews are often dreadful, but that doesn't take anything away from the value of an objective assessment of the characteristics that are measurable.
This particular test site is better than some, but to use the word "bug" in this context is not objective - in my view.

Before I buy a lens (except my most recent purchase, which I bought almost solely on the reputation, and my personal experience, of Pentax * lenses), I always read what other users have to say - here, on Stan's site, and especially on the PDML (Stan being a bit out of date).

Some users I rate more highly than others. I give more credence, for example, to the views of competent photographers who have owned or used lots of lenses. Our own JR is an example.

I pay almost no attention to reviews because I know no reviewers who are both competent and objective. There may be some, but I don't know them.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on IQ fix in K10D Firmware update? at 29/08/2007 - 18:42

George Lazarette
Quote:

In fairness, photozone.de is very complimentary about the 16-45, and indeed about the K10D generally.

It says:

photozone.de wrote:

"The Pentax SMC-DA 16-45mm f/4 ED AL is an impressive standard zoom ... with a bug.
But it's NOT a bug. ALL lenses display some CA if you push them hard enough. Even my wonderful Ltd lenses show CA occasionally (but of course, it's limited)!

It is possible that some samples of the 16-45 exhibit the problem more than others, but the important fact is that experienced photographers who use the lens for taking photographs, rather than doing "tests", are more than happy with it.

It's how the equipment performs when taking pictures that counts, and the sort of nonsense you have just quoted makes me very irritated.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on IQ fix in K10D Firmware update? at 29/08/2007 - 17:44

George Lazarette
Many of the pictures submitted to this site were taken with the K10D.

Look at them and see if you can see any problems.

In the real world, there IS no problem. But reviewers always have an agenda, and will come up with a load of techno-babble to be confuse and worry people.

DPReview appeals to a particular sort of troglodyte. Such people crouch in darkened rooms with large magnifying glasses pressed to flickering screens and claim to see artifacts that are invisible to the naked eye.

They take pictures in complete darkness at high ISO, and claim to see patterns in the gloom. This isn't photography, but it's how they get their kicks.

The other site you mention claims there are probems with the 16-45 lens. Oh yes? Tell that to the people who use it everyday and rave about it.

If you say where you are, it's quite possible that somebody here will live fairly near, and be prepared to let you handle their K10D, take a few pics, and judge for yourself.

Years ago, reviewers were competent and objective. There isn't one, it seems, who fits that description today. Certainly, none that I trust.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on IQ fix in K10D Firmware update? at 29/08/2007 - 14:11

George Lazarette
Quote:
Thanks - that was quick. So, as I understand your reply, the obvious flaws in DPReview's RAW sample (http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/PentaxK10D/page22.asp, eg top crop, see gaps in the swashes at left and right and general roughness) are faults in the RAW conversion? Just to play devil's advocate for a second, if that is so, wouldn't the same faults be evident in ALL the DPReview RAW captures?
Don't try and judge a camera by looking at small JPEGs produced by a person who is paid to sell Canons.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on IQ fix in K10D Firmware update? at 29/08/2007 - 12:36

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo