George Lazarette

Joined: 14th January 2004

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

George Lazarette
Quote:
I didn't realise that PEF files are compressed DNG files - I assume this is a lossless compression like WINZIP?

At that sort of money I am very tempted by a GX10 - I think I am finding the 6 megapixels in the K100 a bit frustrating now.

I must see what I'd get for a year old K100D.

Mike
If you are the sort of person who goes out once or twice a week and takes 50 shots each time, then there is nothing wrong with a GX10.

If you are a studio photographer, shooting 200 pictures an hour, then the Pentax is the only sensible choice.

Which are you closer to?

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on pentax k10 samsung gx 10 at 16/06/2008 - 00:25

George Lazarette
Quote:
George Lazarette wrote:
Quote:
George Lazarette wrote:
I have to say that I am a little discombobulated by Simon's figures. They suggest that the Samsung camera IS compressing DNGs, whilst the Pentax we know does not.

Just to confirm, Simon, what is the size of a typical DNG on your GX10?

G
George,

They're 16.1 MB in size, doing the maths this looks spot-on....

4GB card shows 3878mb in the "format" menu..

3878 / 16.1 = 240.8 (241 rounded up)


If the K10D is showing 242 & definitely compresses the .PEF then it sounds like it must use the .DNG file size to calculate available card space/shots ?
simon
That suggests that it tells you the card is full when it is not. Hmm.

G
Sorry George not sure what you mean , looks correct to me, only spare space is 0.2mb which wouldn't be enough for another shot ?

simon
If both systems are saying there is space for 120 images on a card, then either the camera is stopping you at 120 PEFs, even though there is space on the card for more; or you are only going to be able to take say 80 DNGs before the card is full (not 120 as stated); or, as Tyr says (and I assume he is right), the camera allows you to shoot 180 PEFs despite saying you are only permitted 120.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on pentax k10 samsung gx 10 at 15/06/2008 - 23:02

George Lazarette
Quote:
George Lazarette wrote:
I have to say that I am a little discombobulated by Simon's figures. They suggest that the Samsung camera IS compressing DNGs, whilst the Pentax we know does not.

Just to confirm, Simon, what is the size of a typical DNG on your GX10?

G
George,

They're 16.1 MB in size, doing the maths this looks spot-on....

4GB card shows 3878mb in the "format" menu..

3878 / 16.1 = 240.8 (241 rounded up)


If the K10D is showing 242 & definitely compresses the .PEF then it sounds like it must use the .DNG file size to calculate available card space/shots ?
simon
That suggests that it tells you the card is full when it is not. Hmm.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on pentax k10 samsung gx 10 at 15/06/2008 - 14:03

George Lazarette
I have to say that I am a little discombobulated by Simon's figures. They suggest that the Samsung camera IS compressing DNGs, whilst the Pentax we know does not.

Just to confirm, Simon, what is the size of a typical DNG on your GX10?

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on pentax k10 samsung gx 10 at 15/06/2008 - 13:43

George Lazarette
If the card will take 250 DNGs, then it will take significantly more PEFs.

Unless Samsung has quietly started compressing DNG files.

I have just looked, and on my K10D, DNGs average 16.5MB, whilst PEFs average 12.75MB. That's nearly a third bigger.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on pentax k10 samsung gx 10 at 15/06/2008 - 13:31

George Lazarette
Quote:
George Lazarette wrote:
It's exactly the same mechanically, but there are differences in the software. AFAIR the Samsung does not support PEF files, only DNG, which are not compressed.

That would be enough in itself to put me off.

G
Sorry George but Im not up to speed regarding the different formats of the files can you tell me why this would put you off the camera. As I undrestand your reply it's the photo processing soft ware that is the issue and not the camera itself, or have I miss read your reply.
DNG files are not compressed, and are therefore much bigger than PEFs, which ARE compressed. When you have to move files around, or archive them, the difference is quite noticeable.

As far as taking pictures is concerned, it's not a problem.

As stated above, this issue wouldn't in any way put me off buying the GX10, which is an excellent camera. But given the choice I would plump for the Pentax.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on pentax k10 samsung gx 10 at 15/06/2008 - 13:02

George Lazarette
Quote:
On a PC it doesn't take 4GBs worth of PEF files any shorter time to download than 4GBs worth of .DNG ?
Faulty reasoning here. Obviously 4GB of either will take the same time, but in that 4GB you will have 250 PEFs or 150 DNGs. (Figures right off the top of my head)

Quote:
IMHO its not sensible for the OP to base a decision to buy a camera on whether it supports .DNG or .PEF - the features of the K10D & GX10 are identical & both are great cameras, if the OP wanted the K10D but can't source there's no reason for him not to get the GX10, unless of course "badges" are an issue
I don't disagree. I said: "It's not enough to stop me buying a GX10 if no K10D were available. "

I know memory is cheap, but time costs more than it ever did.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on pentax k10 samsung gx 10 at 15/06/2008 - 12:53

George Lazarette
Quote:
George Lazarette wrote:
It's exactly the same mechanically, but there are differences in the software. AFAIR the Samsung does not support PEF files, only DNG, which are not compressed.

That would be enough in itself to put me off.

G
I have to disagree with George here,

I own the GX10 & just don't see any issue with .DNG. I've seen several poster making similar comments but from my experience any "concerns" are completely unfounded.

It uses a little more memory space but with SD cards/hard drives now very cheap this isn't an issue either

Hopefully George will clarify his "issue"

simon
Well, it's quite simple. DNG files are significantly larger than PEFs. That means you have to have more memory cards, change them more often, and hang around for longer while they download.

When I first got my K10D I tried DNGs. Soon went back to PEFs.

It's not enough to stop me buying a GX10 if no K10D were available. But all else being reasonably equal, I would happily pay a £50.00 premium, if not more, to have PEFs.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on pentax k10 samsung gx 10 at 15/06/2008 - 12:23

George Lazarette
It's exactly the same mechanically, but there are differences in the software. AFAIR the Samsung does not support PEF files, only DNG, which are not compressed.

That would be enough in itself to put me off.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on pentax k10 samsung gx 10 at 15/06/2008 - 11:03

George Lazarette
Quote:
I'm glad to hear you're taking the advice.
So I'll give you some more....
after practicing shooting from different angles, and with different lenses, and different exposures, aperture/shutter combinations...

you'll want to learn to "See the light".

for available light shooting (no flash) try this:
get a small block (anything as long as it is a cube and (you can make it) white.

hold the cube up in the palm of your hand. turn in a circle until you can see three sides of your cube are all different shades of white. (sometimes helps to squint, and look through your eyelashes).

that is the direction your camera should be shooting at to get the best natural light. (I often see buildings that way, and place my subjects on the shady side of buildings where the light has that 3 dimensional quality).
now look for a subject that is sitting in that light.

(start by using this tip in shade or overcast conditions, in bright sun, you'll need scrims, diffusers and reflectors to control contrast...same idea but more complicated).
I like that, Don. Great idea.

G

Comment by George Lazarette posted on Sunken Boat at 16/06/2008 - 00:10

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo