Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
simonkit wrote:
As much as I like my K5 Pentax doesn't hit the spot when it comes to compacts, sorry...the new Sony RX100 will soon be my carry everywhere compact

Simon
Have you tried a Q, Simon? If not, you might be pleasantly surprised. I certainly was.

While the IQ of the RX100 might be excellent, I can guarantee that the handling and useability won't be in the same league. This is what makes it such fun and encourages you to shoot - something my LX3 (good as it is) never really did.

At the risk of sounding like a fanboy - far from not hitting the spot with compacts (though of course the Q is a MILC), Pentax have actually set the standard as far as small camera ergonomics are concerned. It's quite amazing how much they've packed into such a small package. Yes, the IQ would ideally be even better (though it isn't bad at all), but the Q has made me realise how important ergonomics are.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Q over quality compact? at 18/01/2013 - 19:00

Dr. Mhuni
Now I feel like Tippi Hedren in the phone box.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on i feel like alfred hitchcock at 18/01/2013 - 18:03

Dr. Mhuni
There's an interesting Flickr group devoted to the Q which shows off its capabilities as a candid camera rather well here:

link

Give or take the odd deer (:shock it's more consistent than most Flickr pools I've looked at.

I particularly like this:

link

Shame the guy feels the need to emblazon his name on the top, though I quite like the fake shadow.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Q over quality compact? at 18/01/2013 - 17:44

Dr. Mhuni
I think the OP has a point. I'm beginning to feel like Tippi Hedren.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on i feel like alfred hitchcock at 18/01/2013 - 17:40

Dr. Mhuni
I can thoroughly recommend two (free) exhibitions I visited when in London recently, both (handily) at Somerset House. This: link, which someone posted a thread on last year (which I can't find now); and this: link. The former has fantastic images by some top street photographers (including one of the colour genres' Daddies, Joel Meyerowitz) - the Alex Webb's in particular were a relevation; was less enthused by a couple of togs taking a more conceptual approach. Tim Walker is to fashion photography what Tim Burton is to film and his exhibition was impressive too and a lot of fun (great for kids - my daughter loved it). In addition, the venue (Somerset House) is a superb example of grand London architecture.

The Ansel Adams at Greenwich is good too, but you have to pay for that!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on London exhibitions at 12/01/2013 - 10:37

Dr. Mhuni
My first pp-ed shot from the Q + 01 (re-sized to 800px for PUF):

Comment Image


Watford overground (guess where I'd been:wink

Overall I'm quite pleased. Not DSLR quality - I doubt the K5 would have any blocked up dark areas, and the general detail retained would have been significantly better (the hair on the guy on the left is distinctly mushy, for example, when viewed at full size). But this is a decent performance in pretty challenging conditions (settings: 1/30 @ f2.8 & ISO400). Particularly given that the shot has been fairly significantly cropped (what you see is probably around 2/3 the original size). At full size (after cropping, that is), the tread on the guy's trainer on the right is surprisingly clear. It did require more sharpening than usual, but it could take it. Also the white balance (not a strength of the Q) wasn't accurate - though this is easily adjusted in PP (especially in RAW).

At the very least, I think this demonstrates IQ-wise what a handy take-everywhere camera the Q is for street shooters. Image quality's decent enough and its diminutive size opens up all sorts of possibilities which would either be impossible or ill-advised with a larger camera. I wouldn't have been too bothered taking the above with a larger camera , but would have been more self-conscious doing so and would also have probably attracted greater attention; and I've taken many photos with the Q that I wouldn't have dreamed of taking with a larger camera.

Re. the lens sizes. Adrian has a point about the difference between the 01 and 02 lenses on camera. The 01 + Q is a tiny package, and very handy for this reason. But the 02 is by no means large. I would feel a little anxious about the LCD putting a camera in my pocket in any case. Instead I use a camera bag attached to my belt. I got one of these from SRS: link. Perfect for the Q, which fits body down with the 01 and lens down with the 02. It makes for a discreet package either way.

As Adrian points out a fast wide prime is a desirable addition to the range, which I would prefer to the 02. The 06 telezoom looks pretty decent - check out shots posted by RaistD (I think that's his name) on the getDPI.forum. I guess stability would be more of an issue at this length - though at least it's constant f2.8 (wish the 02 had this).

Adrian's also right about it not being a DSLR replacement. While I could see myself being reasonably happy travelling with just the Q (actually taking a Q would most likely result in being more photographically active), I wouldn't if I had serious photographic intentions on any trip. Most likely I'd take more than just the Q - but I am notoriously bad at travelling light. On my recent visit to London I had some photographic opportunities with the Q that wouldn't have existed without it (as I likely wouldn't have had any camera with me otherwise). The results - in quite challenging lighting - don't appear bad at all on first inspection even if they are not of the quality I might have captured with a larger sensor camera. In better lighting I'd have fewer reservations about the Q, but I do shoot a lot in low light conditions. Another benefit of the Q btw is as a handy tool to investigate photo ops that might be returned to with a larger camera.

Re. the Q vs. the MX-1 or similar cameras, the faster aperture is desirable, but I find the tiny form factor a big plus with the Q; and wonder if the compacts would provide such photographer friendly handling as the Q, which is a joy to use.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Q over quality compact? at 12/01/2013 - 10:17

Dr. Mhuni
I got an unboxed 01 lens off Chris at SRS last week. I don't know if he has any more. If he does, I'd imagine he could offer the twin lens kit for somewhere in the £300+ region to a PUF member. The 02 zoom is currently on offer at £129 - so I guess it all depends on whether there are any Q + 01 kits left. If you fancied the 15-45 zoom (f2.8 constant, which is nice) Milamber, you might get all three for not that much more than your £500 budget.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Q over quality compact? at 10/01/2013 - 19:20

Dr. Mhuni
Hi Michael,

I used to live in Dar es Salaam. Never got as far as Mtwara (only to Lindi and then turned right to Nyasa!). It's a beautiful part of the world. I always fancied the crossing to Mozambique near you, which was marked on my map as 'By canoe', but as you know Bongoland's a long way from Mtwara and I never found the time to do it.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Q over quality compact? at 10/01/2013 - 17:31

Dr. Mhuni
I also picked up a Q recently and haven't regretted it at all - even though it was an impulse buy. After handling one at SRS when collecting a K-mount lens I just couldn't resist the charms of the Q. I don't think I've had more fun with a camera - it just makes you want to take photos (and as a result encourages experimentation). The handling and ergonomics are superb. IQ isn't up there with a DSLR of course, but then it's a different type of camera. It does seem to out perform my LX3, which itself is no slouch in the quality compact field (I don't know how much the LX7 has advanced from the LX3 IQ-wise - my impression was that the advances were more in lens speed and reach than IQ, though I may be wrong) - and it is a much more enjoyable camera to use (the LX ergonomonics/interface haven't changed much since the LX3 I think). I have yet to process any shots and to see how they respond to pp-ing, as I've just got back from Europe and am now downloading the LR3 update for Q files, but looking at them in Silkypix they seem very good for a compact and far better than I expected. The Q even does reasonably well in low light situations (which I was concerned about) - especially with the 01 lens.

The Ricoh top end compacts seem to get similarly good feedback as small cameras that enthusiasts enjoy, but I'd be surprised if they offered the bang for the buck that the Q offers at current prices (Blythman is right to point out that reviews tended to be negative because they were reviewing a £600 camera - which, nice as it is, the Q isn't). You can pick up the body plus the 01 prime and 02 zoom for around £300 now, which is a bargain IMO (the zoom represents the only serious wide angle option at the moment and is optically decent if a bit slow for me (f2.8-4.5); the 01 is sharp and fast - though f1.4 would have been even nicer - and its tiny size makes it the ideal companion for the Q).

I anticipate I'll be using the Q much more than I expected. It is such an enjoyable and intuitive camera to use. Given what the Pentax engineers managed to come up with in such a small package, it makes you wonder what on earth they were thinking of with the K-01? A scaled up Q could have had the impact that the Fuji X100 had.

@ Michael Blue - are you based in Tanzania? If so, where?

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Q over quality compact? at 10/01/2013 - 17:01

Dr. Mhuni
Now sold.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on FA50 f1.4 at 02/01/2013 - 22:15

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo