Dr. Mhuni

Joined: 13th December 2007

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Dr. Mhuni
Quote:
I had always been impressed with my 18-55, maybe I have an exceptionally good one, I dont know.
I came to the conclusion a while back that there must have been quite wide variation in this lens (I'm talking about the one that came with the K10D/100D, not later incarnations). There's such diversity of opinion about it. Spotted this before I even bought my camera - having read loads of reviews of both cameras, reviewers were split between those who praised the kit lens and those who criticised it (especially for vignetting). And this seems to be reflected by the similarly conflicting views of Pentax owners.

Mine performed fine in the centre and from about 30mm. But at a wide angle it vignetted badly at any aperture, and wide open the performance wasn't good at any length.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax DA 16-45 at 24/09/2009 - 18:36

Dr. Mhuni
Road_Dancer wrote:
try and read each post in the best possible light, and to write yours with the understanding it may be read in the worst possible light.
Sounds like excellent advice to me!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Whether to go ahead at 24/09/2009 - 13:39

Dr. Mhuni
I've been wondering of late how Forum members have acquired the expertise they have and over what period of time they have acquired it.

Having come to the Pentax DSLR fold (I did have a nice little Optio with which I used to shoot slide a while back) relatively inexperienced as a photographer, my learning curve over the past couple of years has been pretty steep. However, I do feel I've made a fair bit of progress - even if I'm still often frustrated by my inability to obtain the shots I want, both before and after capture. And I was wondering what the most effective way of advancing my ability might be.

For what it's worth, I'd say the following have contributed to my development as a photographer in roughly equal measure:

a. Reading photography how-to books.
b. Forum participation - notably in the weekly and fortnightly comps.
c. Looking at other photographers' work analytically in books, galleries and on the web - both good (more enjoyable) and not so good.
d. And of course, it should go without saying but I'll say it anyway, taking photographs and processing them.

Other paths I might have followed but haven't are club participation (never was an option in Addis Ababa, though is here in Colombo) and structured courses (online or otherwise). I also haven't used online resources for budding photographers much either. I would be curious about others experience of all of these.

However, this isn't only addressed at those who have come quite recently to photography but also those with many years (even decades) of experience. In fact, I'm probably especially curious about those who have honed their expertise - both in capturing and post-processing - over a long period of time. I'm also curious about how many people built up their knowledge base through use of film cameras, and how many (relative newcomers presumably) though digital phtography.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Your photo-biographies at 24/09/2009 - 13:34

Dr. Mhuni
Darkmunk wrote:

Must get some work done, but maybe we can do some comparative tests?
Not my favourite activity, testing, but if you really want to I'd be happy to oblige. Though hasn't yours been rather compromised by the fall?!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax DA 16-45 at 24/09/2009 - 11:44

Dr. Mhuni
Darkmunk wrote:
Quote:
looking well after it, caring for it etc. etc.
Ha ha ha....oh Lidy, you don't know me very well yet
Didn't you see his shot in last week's comp, Lidy!

Maybe you got two bad copies, Darkmunk.

By the way, seeing as you don't like the 16-45, maybe you could use this as your designated sailing lens!

Interesting what you said about the 50 f1.4. I thought fast primes were supposed to outperform zooms significantly when it comes to focusing.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax DA 16-45 at 24/09/2009 - 09:41

Dr. Mhuni
Re-reading my post, I perhaps ought to clarify that the 16-45 hasn't been used much - despite briefly being a default lens - because I bought the 17-70 only a couple of months afterwards (tempted, as I said, by an effective price of £230 for the DA17-70 - those were the days:lol.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax DA 16-45 at 24/09/2009 - 06:16

Dr. Mhuni
Another vote for the DA16-45. I actually haven't used it that much since I bought mine but have been very pleased with the results - it's a significant step up from the kit in terms of performance and in the extra 2mm, which is great. Contra to Darkmunk's experience mine performs pretty well from wide open - not in the same class as the 12-24, but way better than the 18-55. (Perhaps you have a bad copy Darkmunk?)

It was my default lens until I returned to the UK last Xmas and was too tempted by the versatility - and £50 cashback + VAT refund - of the DA17-70. However, at current prices there's no question I'd go for the DA16-45. The 17-70 is a tad sharper, has a more useful range (though I sometimes miss the extra 1mm), and is much better built (the 16-45 being on a par with the kit lens) - but it's not worth twice the price, which it is now.

Was going to sell my 16-45 earlier this year, but in the end decided that the £185 quid I was offered wasn't enough to prevent me keeping it. Mostly because I thought it would be good to keep as a back up if something was to happen to the SDM on the 17-70 (was reading about problems with this at the time) here in Colombo, where it would be difficult to obtain any replacement. But also because I'd simply developed a fondness for it!

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Pentax DA 16-45 at 24/09/2009 - 05:08

Dr. Mhuni
Mannesty wrote:
mikew wrote:
Aren't these all a little wide for landscapes unless you're looking for the ultra wide skies?

Mike
I think so. I prefer my 16-50mm and use the 12-24mm either when space is tight or the scale of the subject (large building) requires it.
I actually find the 12-24 quite a useful landscape lens. The width can come in handy, but the superior performance up to 24mm over any other lens I have is even better.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Is width everything? at 22/09/2009 - 08:16

Dr. Mhuni
I went through this process a while back - see the following thread, which has some very useful feedback in it: link

As you'll see from my last comment in that thread, I went for the DA12-24 and haven't regreted it. It's a superb lens. Good as the Sigma might be - and many swear by it - I find it hard to believe it could perform as well as the Pentax. Take a look at the reviews of the Tokina version of the 12-24 (basically the same lens), the Sigma, and the Tamron 10-24 in the dpreview lens review section for an independent view.

On the down side, the current price is loopy (particularly when you can get the Tokina version in Canikon mounts for almost half the price). However, you should be able to get a reasonably priced copy with the Samsung badge. Also, both the Pentax and Samsung versions have of late appeared quite often in the classified section on this website - so you might check there first.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Is width everything? at 22/09/2009 - 05:03

Dr. Mhuni
Interesting comments Mecrox, and thanks for judging - but you might want to paste this into the comments space in the competition section. Many entrants who might not spot this here would, I'm sure, like to read your judging rationale.

Though I fear you may not see this until after a day negotiating builders.

Comment by Dr. Mhuni posted on Weekly Competition #115 - Yun at 21/09/2009 - 07:48

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo