All Forum Comments
Comment by Critical-i posted on Studio flash dilemma at 15/11/2008 - 13:02
You'll find loads of pics on the net taken with a Sigma 10-20mm that are brilliant and fascinating. Any slight colour cast can be corrected, if you even notice it.
I'm hoping the Tamron 10-24 will be at least as good, because the extra range would be useful.
I'm just going on what I see when I take shots side by side between Sigma, Tamron and Pentax lenses. You probably wouldnt notice otherwise.
Comment by Critical-i posted on Tamron v Sigma at 14/11/2008 - 19:45
Comment by Critical-i posted on Tamron v Sigma at 14/11/2008 - 01:52
I got this link off another forum. It's written mainly for Nikon, but makes interesting reading (if not downright gloomy) for Pentax users. It's quite long but worth a read so stick with it. Hopefully his predictions are about as good as mine when picking my lottery numbers..
http://www.bythom.com/2009predictions.htm
If you mean they are based on pure guesswork, then you should be reassured. He knows nothing about Hoya, Pentax or their business plans.
Comment by Critical-i posted on 2009 Predictions....... at 12/11/2008 - 13:42
Comment by Critical-i posted on I want to buy a 20 D in a shop at 12/11/2008 - 01:19
For instance, if you are trying to take photos of a bird in flight, then SR won't help get you a sharper image of the bird relative to a moving background.
The camera should not realise that it is moving in a particular plane once there is no acceleration or deceleration in that plane - in other words just after you have started to pan and are up to speed.
So for example if the bird was flying evenly from left to right and you were panning well except for some up and down wobbles, I think the camera should not be fooled by the panning but should compensate for the wobbles. It should work with diagonal panning as well.
Comment by Critical-i posted on Shake reduction at 10/11/2008 - 16:24
It was the statement "The AF accuracy of the tested sample was mediocre with a quite significant back-focus problem at 50mm" which rang true with me. While mine performs very well for portraits and close objects for landscapes the AF is often disappointing particularly at infinity.
It is also the only lens in my collection that I have had any issues with lens-flare.
Glyn
Comment by Critical-i posted on DA* 16-50mm Review at 10/11/2008 - 16:19
Corners and edges are not so good wide open its true, though I dont see the same CA issues stopped down as Klaus does.
But what sets this lens apart is the way the colours pop out. Back to back with just about any Sigma or Tamron lens the Pentax results have a vibrancy that the others cant match. So, despite its faults it just has a certain something and quite nice bokeh too.
Not all the best lenses do best on test charts I guess.
Comment by Critical-i posted on DA* 16-50mm Review at 10/11/2008 - 15:43
[IMG]http://i477.photobucket.com/albums/rr139/RobbieB_album/IMGP7269.jpg[/IMG]
This was taken the other day with the 17-70 SDM. It was taken with AF and I used the centre AF point but doesn't look quite sharp to me. Does this image show any signs of the lens being faulty?
Cheers
Rob
Youd need to post a 100% crop to show how sharp it was. Just crop a (roughly) 800X800 pixel square from the centre and save it without resizing.
Comment by Critical-i posted on pentax 17-70 sdm at 10/11/2008 - 15:18
Is it called a Horseman because you need a packhorse to carry one and a man to take the picture?
No problem with tilt and shift perspectives there I would guess. Have fun.
Comment by Critical-i posted on New toy at 04/11/2008 - 23:12


I've not done any serious studio work since my college days (a vey long time ago) and have no 'proper' lighting at the moment to do any.
I have a portable flash arsenal of 2 X AF540FGZ, 2 X AF360FGZ, AF500FTZ.
Question: Is it feasible to use either the 360's or 540's, atop stands fitted with hot shoe flash brackets and reflective or shoot through umbrellas? Are these flashes powerful enough?
If I were to need/want 'proper' lighting, does anybody have any experiences, good or bad, of the Elinchrom D-Lite 2 kits.
My main interest will be product photography where a light tent would be inadequate, and staged macro photography. I can't see myself entering the world of portraiture, glamour, fashion etc where people are the subject.
However getting them to work well with modifiers is more of a pain because there is no way to point them directly in the centre of an unbrella. Also umbrellas are not really the best for product photos because they create quite sharp highlights. I use the Lumiquest promax system for diffusion and their snoot for location work which works ok if you dont need to be to precise, but the modifiers you get with a proper setup are much more useful.
I have the elinchrom DLite2 kit and a couple of BX400s. The Dlites are great. Quite portable and a very even colour temperature even at low power settings. With proper strobes you do get more exposure control, much faster recycling, modelling lights, masses of modifiers etc. The BX's are more in the pro league but apart from being able to take heavier softboxes there are few downsides to the Dlites except the lack of a fan. If things get a bit hot they will simply switch off though so far its never happened to me. I think the 4's have a fan.
The problem with many cheaper chinese systems is the lack of accessories. Bowens and Elinchrom really do have everything.
For macros I think you are better off with a ring light.