bychan

Joined: 30th March 2009

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

bychan
milamber wrote:
There have been several threads lately about ND filters, largely following the series of superb landscapes posted. Plenty of advice about which manufacturer is best and why, but is there anywhere someone can point first time ND filter users like me at.

I'd like to take one with me travelling next week, but don't want to buy loads of different ones just yet until I have a go and see the results. I understand how they work and how many stops a given filter will reduce, but don't know what effect this would have in practice.

I was pretty poor at equations at school, but presumably there must be some equation that would let me work out the effect of the filter?

I was out early this morning in the mist. It was just getting light with the sun not up, but I still couldn't expose for longer than around half a second, even at f36.

How do I work out what exposure time I would have had with a given ND filter attached?

Ideally I would like to take just one with me, but don't know which would be most useful. Either that or get a Cokin set, but the reviews on those are variable. I can't justify a Lee set or similar at this stage.

The variable ones look convenient, but in my experience you usually pay for that in quality.

I should add that I am not all settled yet about which lenses I will end up keeping. I have a DA 18-250 and FA 50 for this trip, but that could easily change afterwards!

Any help appreciated.
milamber
Speaking from personal experience, I recommend that you go for a Cokin P filter holder, plus a gradual neutral density filter. Off the top of my head I don't know how many options there are, my personal copy being a P 121S.

I always carry this setup with me (holder, adaptor rings plus the filter). Yes, it does give off a slight colour cast, but on the plus side I've taken shots with it that wouldn't have been possible otherwise (blown out skies).

I'va also got a proper Cokin P ND filter (can't recall the model), I think I've used it twice since it was bought

In my opinion the GND is an invaluable tool for landscapes.

Another word of advice, if purchasing such a setup, is to go for the 3rd party holders and adaptor rings off e-bay. I have both, and the 3rd party ones are much cheaper whilst doing exactly the same job

Kood filters are supposedly of a smiliar quality to the Cokin ones, these might be a tad cheaper as well.

All in all a good way to get started, without costing the earth.

Regards
Adrian

Comment by bychan posted on ND filters explained for novices at 09/05/2012 - 00:21

bychan
A couple of used ones at SRS

link

Regards
Adrian

Comment by bychan posted on WTB: K20D body at 01/03/2012 - 19:04

bychan
Hyram, indeed the sea was much rougher than is depicted in these images.

Thanks all.
Adrian

Comment by bychan posted on Trefor Seascapes at 24/01/2012 - 01:30

bychan
Thanks Andrew.

Feel free to pop-in if you're in my neck of the woods

Regards
Adrian

Comment by bychan posted on Trefor Seascapes at 22/01/2012 - 20:44

bychan
Thanks David.

Adrian

Comment by bychan posted on Trefor Seascapes at 20/01/2012 - 17:52

bychan
japers45, thankfully the Sigma isn't showing any ill-effects

The entrance to the pier is blocked off by a big metal fence, a small part of which can be seen in 2 and 5. Personally I found this to be distracting if composing images further in this direction.

Thanks for the feedback.

Regards
Adrian

Comment by bychan posted on Trefor Seascapes at 18/01/2012 - 00:31

bychan
Thanks all.

Regards
Adrian

Comment by bychan posted on Trefor Seascapes at 17/01/2012 - 00:34

bychan
Some local seascapes taken during rough weather over the holiday period.
The old pier has taken a battering this winter, and as can be seen many of the supporting beams have now falled off (the top section has also started to buckle).

I got a bit too close to the action on one of the shots, and got a bit wet for my troubles

1
Comment Image


2
Comment Image


3
Comment Image


4
Comment Image


5
Comment Image


All with the K5 and Sigma 18-50.

Regards
Adrian

Comment by bychan posted on Trefor Seascapes at 15/01/2012 - 21:33

bychan
The Sigma 18-50 also offers very close focusing functionality, whilst also retaining the constant f2.8

Not many come-up on the classifieds mind you..

It gets a big thumbs-up from me

Regards
Adrian

Comment by bychan posted on Thoughts on replacing Tamron 17-50 f2.8 with 17-70mm F2.8-4.5 DC Macro at 12/01/2012 - 01:39

bychan
thespirit3, don't think about it, please do it, you will have no regrets.
I've had my K5 since the end of May, it's frozen-up on me about 5 times (only 'issue' encountered).

I have the reassurance that I bought it from SRS, who's after sales service if called upon are of the highest standard.

A great friend of mine paid 7K for a Canon lens, after he sold his house.
He got to use it 3 times before the Big C claimed him just over 2 years ago, at the ripe old age of 45.

Live life now, go for it whilst you can

Regards
Adrian

Comment by bychan posted on K-X to K-5 upgrade worthwhile? at 27/12/2011 - 03:37

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo