Blythman

Joined: 13th September 2010

All Forum Comments

Topics Created Topics Contributed Forum Comments Photo Comments

All Forum Comments

Blythman
Like them all Simon. If I had to pick a favourite, it'd probably be the 2 herons

Comment by Blythman posted on Wild things at 20/07/2014 - 12:47

Blythman
Not much light this morning, so used the K5 as opposed to the K3

DA 300, f4, 1/320, ISO 1250

Comment Image
Sunday morning breakfast by Alan Wennington, on Flickr

Comment by Blythman posted on Sunday morning breakfast at 20/07/2014 - 12:46

Blythman
Horst wrote:
Alan wrote:
Quote:

With the same size sensor, its like focusing on an animal (say a bird, 6 metres away) with a 300mm lens. and then from the same distance focus on the same bird with a 200mm lens. Assuming you want the eye sharp, and all other things being equal,which lens do you think would give you the most keepers?
The eye will be sharp, no matter what lens you use, if it is correctly focused.

However you will get a better definition with a 300mmlens, because the eye is spread over more pixels.
but this is only relevant if you use the same size sensor for both lenses.

Regards, Horst
But with which lens are you more likely to nail the focus. The lens where the focus point is taken up by the eye and maybe other parts of the head, or the lens where the focus point takes in the shoulder too?

Comment by Blythman posted on Why bother? at 20/07/2014 - 11:03

Blythman
Horst wrote:
Blythman wrote:

Quote:
Assuming that the AF point is the same size on each sensor then, it can be more accurately set on APS-C. So you might have the eye in focus with the crop and out of focus with the FF as on FF it covers a larger area of the animal
Hello Alan.
Focus is only 2 dimensional, forget depth of field.

Say the animal stays at right angle to you, and half of it covers the APS-C size sensor, Then with FF it will of course cover, say 3/4 of it.

Even if you had a FF lens with not very good edge sharpness, when you crop it back to the APS-C size, (16Mp) it will be exactly the same.

If the animal looked at you, and you had the eye in focus, everything else would be out of focus anyway, except all the items which are at eye level at the time.
The exact Ficus is only at one depth position. Irrelevant if you use the lens at f 0.5 or at f64.

Regards, Horst
With the same size sensor, its like focusing on an animal (say a bird, 6 metres away) with a 300mm lens. and then from the same distance focus on the same bird with a 200mm lens. Assuming you want the eye sharp, and all other things being equal,which lens do you think would give you the most keepers?

Of course in your example where the animal fills the frame, then we wouldn't need longer lenses than we already have. However, most wildlife photographers in the real world always wish they had more focal length

Comment by Blythman posted on Why bother? at 20/07/2014 - 10:31

Blythman
Horst wrote:
[b] you then crop it to the 16Mpl area and you have exactly the same image with the same quality as your APS-C camera.
Not necessarily.

Assuming that the AF point is the same size on each sensor then, it can be more accurately set on APS-C. So you might have the eye in focus with the crop and out of focus with the FF as on FF it covers a larger area of the animal

Comment by Blythman posted on Why bother? at 20/07/2014 - 00:18

Blythman
Thanks Mike.

Its very positive in good light. Got quite a few of these reed warblers out of focus prior to the light improving

Comment by Blythman posted on Reed Warbler at 18/07/2014 - 09:49

Blythman
Algernon wrote:
You could remove the glass from an old 2x AF TC.

--
Good idea Algi

Comment by Blythman posted on Reed Warbler at 18/07/2014 - 07:31

Blythman
Very nice too. Not a bad stick either

Comment by Blythman posted on Honeyeater at 18/07/2014 - 07:29

Blythman
tyronet2000 wrote:
Cracking shot Alan
Thanks Stan

Algernon wrote:
Excellent capture. You could try a small extension tube to get closer. I used to use a 9.5mm Ricoh one (no contacts) with a Pentax-A 300mm.
--
Mmmm sounds like a plan. Not in this instance, because I want the AF. Sometimes only lands for seconds, and there's four sticks which is ridiculous.

It could be very useful on the tripod for flutterbys though

Comment by Blythman posted on Reed Warbler at 17/07/2014 - 12:40

Blythman
bforbes wrote:
Nice one Alan. Do you think the 560 has increased the number of opportunities for "good shots" over your Sigma 150-500?
Less opportunity for "good shots" Barrie because of the lack of flexibility. But more opportunity for "excellent" shots.

For example, at the weekend I shot a Kingfisher with the DA 560. It was a big crop, but even so, the detail in the image was excellent. I was with 2 guys. One with Nikon gear, who was using a 300mm f2.8 and a convertor, and one with a Canon 300mm f4. They both got the same shot, but couldn't get the detail I had.

However, the Kingfisher flew closer. Too close for me to focus on. I would have been able to with the 150-500. Likewise I could with my DA 300, which was on my K-5. Incidentally the other guys were nice about me scaring it off as I tried to change over

I do find the lens quite restricting. I tried it a couple of times on the Barn Owls, where I was shooting in the open, but now use the 300 with the 1.4x due to changing position a lot. Toying with getting a monopod which may change things. Although looking at the price of decent sized carbon ones I'm a bit wary in case I waste my money.

Comment by Blythman posted on Reed Warbler at 17/07/2014 - 10:11

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo