All Forum Comments
Comment by Belinda B. posted on Weekly Competition # 39 "Wildlife" at 07/04/2008 - 00:09
Judging to follow shortly.
p.s. the Pentax server clock is slightly slow.
Comment by Belinda B. posted on Weekly Competition # 39 "Wildlife" at 06/04/2008 - 23:57
.....................................................................and I am hoping that there will not be too many more entries
Comment by Belinda B. posted on Weekly Competition # 39 "Wildlife" at 06/04/2008 - 21:57
Photographs of human beings acting wildly are excluded
Good luck everyone
Comment by Belinda B. posted on Weekly Competition # 39 "Wildlife" at 31/03/2008 - 20:17
Many, many thanks for my 1st Place and for your judging.
I am thrilled
I had lit the woodburning stove on Easter Monday because it was so cold and then thought that it might make an interesting photograph for the competition, once the logs had largely burnt through.
Running flat out, the stove produces 16kw, but it was a lot less when the photograph was taken
My favourite was John Riley's entry, although Hyram's was not too bad
I shall set the next topic within the next few hours.
Comment by Belinda B. posted on Weekly Competition #38 Long Exposure at 31/03/2008 - 19:17
Comment by Belinda B. posted on Weekly Competition #38 Long Exposure at 24/03/2008 - 19:05
What red lifering?
I too had to search for the red object which I think is a small child's inflatable dinghy.
I was looking to achieve a strong contrast between the dull grey scene and the bright child.
There was not much scope left for cropping, since the child is almost at the bottom of the original picture and some railings guarding the edge of a concrete ramp, where I am standing, needed to be cropped out
Comment by Belinda B. posted on English Summer ? at 20/03/2008 - 21:10
Comment by Belinda B. posted on English Summer ? at 19/03/2008 - 20:34
Many thanks to Rob for the judging.
Comment by Belinda B. posted on Weekly Competition #37 Movement at 24/03/2008 - 19:02
Comment by Belinda B. posted on Weekly Competition #37 Movement at 22/03/2008 - 08:46





Before starting my comments I would just like to say that I have never attempted anything like this before and I have not ‘interrogated’ the images in Photoshop, so my comments are based on how I see the photographs on my monitor, which I believe is fairly well adjusted.
Just one other point, I do appreciate the problems of trying to photograph wildlife and very often it is a question of ‘grabbing’ the shot or not getting anything at all. The option of moving to the left or back or changing lens, very often is not an option.
No debate this week about whether the submitted images comply with the theme of the competition.
So, on with the judging :-
Serendipity - Guinea Fowl
Nice picture with lovely detail on feathers. But looks as if the beak is slightly out of focus – these critters will move their heads when you think you’ve got them nicely lined up. Might also have been better if taken ‘portrait’ rather than landscape or cropped, which would also have positioned those lovely big feet to advantage! Nice lush, green grass.
GaryMoffat - Stag
You can see the problem with the fading light that you mention, so there’s just not quite enough sharpness to ‘lift’ the subject out of the background. The high ISO has presumably created the graininess of the image, which seems to suit the subject matter and the background? Overall, the brown tints and grizzled white face staring out at you work very well indeed. Such a handsome animal.
Promhandicam - Giraffe
Where were you standing to take this photo? Despite your avatar, are you really a Pentax toting giraffe yourself, just snapping a friend in the game reserve? Sharp focus and the head stands out very well against the mottled trees in the background with nice colour balance but I find the twigs around the neck slightly distracting. A contender!
Gwyn - Zebras
Nice family grouping with lovely texture on the coats and youngster clearly interested in what you were doing! Composition might have been improved without the large bush/tree on the horizon, growing out of the adult zebra’s neck and the foreground foliage is slightly distracting.
Ikillrocknroll - Seagull
Despite your lack of enthusiasm for it, nearly a very good photo! The colours are intense with that unbelievable blue you sometimes find around sea, sky, boats and marinas. What looks like a boat’s forestay running diagonally through the picture is not a problem below the gull because it gets lost against the background but could have been ‘edited out’ above the gull’s head for the finished picture. The cropping of the body and lack of a bit more framing under the feet mars the composition. Definitely buy some longer lenses!
Justgetoutandride - Stag
You say it’s been heavily cropped, so the photo must have been huge originally! Could be a bit sharper on the deer, of course, which doesn’t stand out against the background – perhaps not helped by the B&W. Would brown/red tints have worked better?
Daniel Bridge - Ladybird
Excellent composition, pin-sharp and lovely colours. The shiny carapace of the wings and the downy texture of the leaf are almost tangible. A contender!
Deecy - White monkey
Definitely a rather disgruntled-looking subject here! Not quite in focus – the texture of the fur doesn’t show up well enough for a great photo. I’m not sure about the cropping of it – the slightly odd shape doesn’t help the composition.
ChrisE - Baboon
Lovely close up, catching the coat beautifully. I know that tweaking the photo later isn’t always the right thing to do but it might have been better with the eyes brought out a little more to create that intensity of expression that animals can have, and the composition is slightly spoiled by the knoll in the distance on the right of the photo which prevents the head being more silhouetted against the sky.
Amilner - Longleat giraffes
Nice scene of these extraordinary creatures, although you won’t (I hope) mind me saying it’s not the greatest composition and not helped by being a scanned image and by what looks like a typically grey English summer’s day. As it was taken back in 1986, one of this group could well be the grandfather or grandmother of Geraldine Giraffe, born 2003 at Longleat, who features on their website. More useless information: the males can run at 35 mph, stand over 16 feet tall and, rather fittingly, a group of giraffes is called a ‘tower’!
Chirpy - Great Crested Grebe
Real precision picture with lovely, muted colours, amazing reflection and contrast between the smooth water and wake that the Grebe creates. Nice detail including water beading off the Grebe’s back. A very slight niggle; I think I would have cropped ˝ inch off the LH side of the picture and, if possible, shown just a little more of the wake. Another title contender!
Mannesty - Spanish Marbled White Butterfly
You have a great eye for a really iconic picture. Brilliantly captures extreme delicacy, ballerina-like poise, colour, light, and detail. Good contrast between subject matter and the background. Yet another title contender!
Iceblinker - Greylag Goose
Handsome plumage and lovely colour tones. The pebble detail is very good and the background fades away just right but the bird’s head is perhaps just a fraction too buried and shaded.
Amoringello - Heron
Superb bird. Unlucky, skewered fish! Did you wait for hours or were you lucky? Lovely subtle colours. The fish is slightly out of focus but you can’t hang about when presented with a spectacle like this, can you? The RH side of the picture is a little bit empty and might have been cropped and perhaps a bit more foreground beneath the heron’s feet would have been beneficial.
Mille 19 - Robin
What a great little chap (or chap-ess). Feisty, alert character of the subject comes over well, set-off by orangey-red colouring in the background to match the shirtfront. Not quite pin sharp but you must have been some distance away when taking this with your zoom. Slightly distracting watermark. Another contender.
Clarky - Insects
Two for the price of one although I think you should really have decided on one or the other because it is a bit distracting to have the two images. But lovely sharp pictures, with good colour, as we have come to expect of you!
Browngo 1 - Another robin!
Good clarity and visual balance in this composition but I wonder how true the colour is? I’ve never seen a British robin with the ruff of yellow/orange neck feathering. I’m no expert though! I’m not at all sure about the solid, bright green background.
Unlocker - Owl
Nice photo (although the subject doesn’t look amused; definitely a baleful eye). Good composition and colours excellent, with gorgeous background that ‘lifts’ the overall image. Not quite as sharp as it might be. Another contender.
Pschlute - Lemur
Very nice, well-composed portrait with the eyes really communicating and the fur is touchable. Simple but slightly dull background.
Dr. Mhuni - Starling
Your photo was worth waiting for (given the difficulties you had in posting this on the site). The body of the bird stands out well amongst the twigs but it’s slightly unfortunate the head isn’t so well silhouetted, which would have been the ideal. A touch more cropping all round might have helped.
Prieni – Turtle
Really like the break in shadow/light on the sand. Pity you couldn’t have arranged for the turtle to be heading in the other direction, which would have brought the head into sunlight. Nice track detail and overall, creates strong image of slow, lumbering effort. Another contender.
Nice unobtrusive watermark.
Nimitz – Fly ?
Striking image. The head lacks detail but excellent contrast between the subject and almost abstract background. How do you manage to use flash on insects without them buzzing off? Another contender?
Jps – Spiderlings
Extraordinary, almost surreal and, for a scanned image, there is a good level of detail. Because there is no main image in focus, one’s eye tends to move around the picture to try to find a centre of attention.
Niblue – Robin
Nice composition; I like the way you’ve left the bright colour streak on the LH margin and great that you have caught this bird singing. Fairly good detail but I wonder about the accuracy of the red colouration?
Kal 10 d – Butterfly
Interesting image, almost graphic art but, for me, the background is a little too dominant – the butterfly needs to stand out more clearly by toning down the backdrop slightly? Sharp and nice detailing.
McBrian – Insects
Another striking image with very good detail. The dry, papery ears of wheat (?) contrast well with the slightly glistening, brown insects. The background merges slightly too much in places with the insects themselves. Another contender.
Tyr – Fieldmouse
Delightful subject but could, perhaps, have cropped the picture to focus on the rather hidden ‘wee beastie’. Hope you get the lens sorted.
Terje-1 – Love in the Sunset
Amorous avians! Not quite sharp enough to show feather detail and heads are unclear. Not sure about unnaturally warm colours. Cropping the sides might help as the sky doesn’t add much to the composition.
HowardJ – Kashmiri Goat
Good level of detail and nice colouring given it’s a scanned image. Composition would have been improved by wider perspective to LH side (tail almost chopped off!) and slightly less on RH side.
Don – Fox
“What big teeth you’ve got”. Good image and colours, and excellent composition. High level of detail but not quite pin sharp and nicer if the eyes stood out a bit more. The LH side backdrop seems a little dark and the whole looks slightly spoiled by two or three small dots and streaks of something - presumably light and could be reflections off raindrops? Is it a scanned image?
Malo 1961 - Swan
Unusual, very rounded shape to this image of a swan and it’s a shame that the extremities are slightly chopped off. Good detail on head and neck but limited on main body.
MX veteran - Robin
Another singing robin, which is nice although the head on view makes it relatively difficult to see this! I find the large expanse of sky detracts from the central figure and perhaps closer cropping would have helped.
LiamD - Squirrel
Good to see a red squirrel, which is too rare a sight for most of us. Unfortunately, I find this picture too busy; not only is the background fairly cluttered, which detracts from the subject, but the border and lettering then intensifies the ‘competition’ for knowing where to look.
Hefty 1 - Hedgehog
This is a nice shot os a garden friend. Nice natural setting and colours. Would have been nicer had the left eye been clearer but, overall, a good natural scene. A useful tip about boiled eggs, as we have a friendly hedgehog that passes through our garden!
Lilly - Snail
Now here’s one with a difference! A very interesting take on the subject. A really nice composition and the ancient grave stone is well captured with excellent detail. I think that I would have picked this out as another high quality Lilly photograph even without your name attached. However, given that the theme is wildlife, I feel that the snail plays too much of a supporting role.
Gartmore (daughter) - Frog
Wow – an entry just a few minutes before midnight and then resized about a minute before the deadline. ! I am glad that you resized it as I was scrolling up and down and side to side. A delightful bright green frog with a good amount of detail. I assume the glistening skin is a result of flash ? Uninteresting background – a rendered wall ? so further cropping might have been advisable. A lower viewpoint would have enabled the right eye to be more visible but overall a most commendable first submission. Welcome to the forum and keep on posting more photographs.
Thank you all for entering and congratulations to everyone for a very interesting set of images. Unfortunately there can be only one winner though!
The results :-
1st Place Chirpy’s Great Crested Grebe
2nd Place Daniel Bridge’s Ladybird
3rd Place Mannesty’s Spanish Marbled White Butterfly
Highly commended strictly in order of submission:
o Promhandicam’s Giraffe
o Mille 19’s Robin
o Unlocker’s Owl
o Prieni’s Turtle
o Nimitz’s Fly
o McBrian’s Insects
So many congratulations to Chirpy, who now has the pleasurable task of setting the next competition and the unenviable task of judging it.