But is it art!
Overexposed beach image. Highly saturated.
Liked by
maxshutter
Carol8345
drofmit
Uploaded15/09/2016 - 19:39
CategoryDigital Art
Unique Views / Likes43/3
TagsN/A
Posted 19/09/2016 - 17:00
Link
Well deserved for the title alone haha. Congratulations
'Photography...it remembers little things, long after you have forgotten....' (Aaron Siskind)
Posted 19/09/2016 - 17:06
Link
Mag07 wrote:
Well deserved for the title alone haha. Congratulations
Agree with Magdalena, well done.
Well deserved for the title alone haha. Congratulations
Posted 19/09/2016 - 17:28
Link
nope.... not for me either but nothing like a photo to get some discussion going! I feel its lacking in enough depth to constitute a pleasing composition - perhaps if there was more negative space in top half? the burnt out sky/clouds isnt easy on the eye
Learn how to live and you'll know how to die; learn how to die, and you'll know how to live.
Check out ones photographs on Flickr!
https://www.flickr.com/photos/awprentice/
Check out ones photographs on Flickr!
https://www.flickr.com/photos/awprentice/
Posted 20/09/2016 - 12:17
Link
QuestionableCarrot wrote:
nope.... not for me either but nothing like a photo to get some discussion going! I feel its lacking in enough depth to constitute a pleasing composition - perhaps if there was more negative space in top half? the burnt out sky/clouds isnt easy on the eye
However, if you look at it as if it was a watercolour and not a photo......? nope.... not for me either but nothing like a photo to get some discussion going! I feel its lacking in enough depth to constitute a pleasing composition - perhaps if there was more negative space in top half? the burnt out sky/clouds isnt easy on the eye
I like it... but it would need to be very large and on a wall by itself...
it is an interesting picture.... a photo graph... a light illustration!
It has in fact been listed under the "Digital Art" category....
and it was deliberately done....
not like some of my "washouts"... the "oh damn, wrong aperture/filmspeed!"...
or, in some cases, both!!
Never be afraid to talk about your techniques...
"Give a thousand photographers...
the same camera, lens and scene...
and you'll always get a thousand different takes!!"
Anon.
"Give a thousand photographers...
the same camera, lens and scene...
and you'll always get a thousand different takes!!"
Anon.
Posted 21/09/2016 - 20:44
Link
I can very well see this as some minimalist watercolour, etc., but a "photograph" in the traditionally accepted sense should be rather graphic and obviously something that is immediately perceived as (with some tweaks) coming out of a "camera". What I say may be all very subjective, but it remains to be proven that someone seeing this printed — out of the context of the PentaxUsers site — would immediately recognise it as being a "photograph". It has its own qualities, but the technique is not obviously "photographical". It could be imagined as a photo of some paintings and, if so, where is the "eye" of the photographer? We reach the point where the extreme possibilities offered by the computer make things move into the domain of "digital art" (the rightly chosen category in this case), and one might consider that "digital art" is a field of its own where the camera just offers the raw material for a totally different intention. This may be considered to be all waffle, but there is something here which (for all its intrinsic merits) I feel is not quite in its place as the "PHOTO" of the week. Prove me wrong and narrow-minded. Which of the great photographers of the past and present wold immediately recognise this — out of context as being a photograph? Computer technology can work wonders, but it seems to me that the photography of the camera-lugging, lens-choosing, subject-seeking kind should remain as close to the spirit of the paper and dark-room times. The computer is another kettle of fish which offers vast possibilities, but... Should I start using just my iPhone and Mac? The photo in question remains interesting in itself, but... The category of "digital art" — should, to my mind, be obliterated from the list.
Posted 23/09/2016 - 21:16
Link
Grodgeman wrote:
I can very well see this as some minimalist watercolour, etc., but a "photograph" in the traditionally accepted sense should be rather graphic and obviously something that is immediately perceived as (with some tweaks) coming out of a "camera".
Why, pray? I can very well see this as some minimalist watercolour, etc., but a "photograph" in the traditionally accepted sense should be rather graphic and obviously something that is immediately perceived as (with some tweaks) coming out of a "camera".
Photography is "painting with light"... yes, this one is very minimalist... but no more so than some of the B&W photographs on display in Bradford....
especially, for example, the early ones using egg albumen and strange, highly toxic chemicals!!
The camera and lens is just one part of our armoury.
And, you do not need a camera to take a picture...
a simple pinhole will capture an image!
However, we now have the advantage of being able to create a "light picture" without resort to chemicals...
we can create all sorts of effects using computer technology...
HDR being an example...
properly used, HDR can recreate a image far closer to the way our brain translated the input from our eyes, than a single camera image ever can.
That is a digital art process in a computer.... as is "focus stacking" to create a highly impressive D.o.F.... our wonderful eyes do that totally automatically.
As you say, "one might consider that "digital art" is a field of its own where the camera just offers the raw material for a totally different intention."
So very true... but this was done in the old analogue days... with net curtain placed between the film and the paper....
or two pictures printed onto the same paper.... etcetera.
We merely have the advantage now of different effects, digitally created by programming geeks, that we....
as the author of the picture, can use to alter an image to our hearts content.
For example, Redfield Fractalius is one such program... one of many such 'plug-ins' that people happen to enjoy using...
and go out, camera in hand & lenses in bag, seeking suitable images....
because many ordinary pictures do not work well as a subject for tweaking this way....
does that make that person any less a photographer, because some of their material deliberately tends toward the abstract!
In the main, I am a wildlife photographer... but even some of those have, later, been "digitally altered" to create a photograph of a different type....
In trawling through my slides last winter, I found a picture of a stream, taken contre-jour in the mid-60s, that had faded....
because the developing process was an Ilford 'bleach-out' one and not a Kodak 'dye-additive' one....
that picture has been transformed into what I consider to be a rather nice green and sepia 'impressionist' photograph....
with an awful lot of white space!!
BUT it is still an analogue era, photographic slide!
Photo Graphy is a highly subjective media....
used from the factual "as-accurate-as-possible" pictures I need to take, in order to correctly record the wildlife species in a particular area....
to totally abstract pictures that show no detail, just colours, shapes or "light textures"....
but, it is still photography that has created the image....
along with....
the imagination of the photographer.
Never be afraid to talk about your techniques...
"Give a thousand photographers...
the same camera, lens and scene...
and you'll always get a thousand different takes!!"
Anon.
"Give a thousand photographers...
the same camera, lens and scene...
and you'll always get a thousand different takes!!"
Anon.
Posted 24/09/2016 - 18:26
Link
Thanks for the reply. All the points you make are valid. And yet... I suppose that I am just too conservative and to close to what I feel to be the spirit of the site - Pentax User. The line between a 'photograph' and an offering of 'digital art' is a fine one. One might suppose that the viewer has an intuitive appreciation of which is which and know where to draw the line between the two. As I see it, 'digital art' is essentially computer produced and the photographic camera is accidentally and can not necessarily be its origin. Many graphic artists start off with a blank computer screen. A photo may undergo retouching and 'tweaking' on a computer, but the effect does - to my mind - have intuitive limits. One feels what a 'photograph' is and is not. The plate in a scientific or technical publication is evaluated in terms of information and it can be well or badly done. A photographer can spend a lot of time perfecting photos of diverse articles for a supermarket flyer, but until these photographs are presented by themselves as 'photographic art' they are seen as simple visual description. The viewer does not 'think' or 'feel' about them. And, as I write, I realise that you are probably right in defending the category of 'digital art'. Perhaps what bothers me is when the technique pushes the image too far from what the camera has produced and the purely aesthetic qualities of the image make the camera itself irrelevant. Some - if not most - of the photos I have taken and which i - personally - prefer, were and have been taken with a simple Canon A650 Powershot or some Sony Cyber-shot. Scruples and literalness prevent me from posting them on the Pentax site, though (from the purely semantic point of view) a 'Pentax User' means a person who uses a Pentax and does not literally (though it does in spirit) demand that the photo be taken with a Pentax. There is the spirit of things, the subjective appreciation and obligation. I take back from my comments anything you may not agree with, congratulate you (without any irony - though slight envy) on your success and maintain my conservative desert island view of photography - no electricity = not much more else than chemicals). Here, in France (EU), we do have electricity and, therefore, computers, but I, personally, adhere to the chemicals/darkroom view of things. The pre-digital photographers could do marvels with that. I need computers, and shall not throw them away. To get back to our photo, it has pleased many visitors (re-congratulations) and you do sat (I think) that the processing got somewhat out of hand. Perhaps it's just too minimal. But, on the other hand, that's what art is all about. Your picture is not what I should have dared or wnted to post - though I do have a number of similar 'failures' (the French word 'ratage' is, here, better) and I accordingly, say aloud "Well done! But..."
Posted 25/09/2016 - 22:05
Link
On a lighter note...
the photograph was chosen by one of the team responsible for the "Picture of the Week"
But, you, like me. are in France... here, with a "fosse toutes eaux".... darkroom chemicals are a no-no.... so I too require a computer as my darkroom.
This has opened a whole new field for me.... I haven't created anything, yet, like oldhat's picture above...
nor have I explored HDR, RAW or stacking... there just isn't the time at present!!
But there are plug-ins I can allow to chunter on in the background while I do something more important.
Those I like.... but even Natural History photography seems to be heading into the art field.... according to the magazines I subscribe to.....
But here, in deepest rural France.... our connection with the outside world is patchy... forcing more reliance on the home network.
So, I cannot throw my computer to the wind!!
Photography is an interest to be enjoyed.... it is more than a mere hobby, afterall!
Keep taking your interesting, thoughtful and though provoking pictures....
I, for one, will be following.
Grodgeman wrote:
I...maintain my conservative desert island view of photography - no electricity = not much more else than chemicals). Here, in France (EU), we do have electricity and, therefore, computers, but I, personally, adhere to the chemicals/darkroom view of things. The pre-digital photographers could do marvels with that. I need computers, and shall not throw them away. .....though I do have a number of similar 'failures' (the French word 'ratage' is, here, better)
Firstly..... it wasn't my photograph.... I answered because your point of view interested me... I...maintain my conservative desert island view of photography - no electricity = not much more else than chemicals). Here, in France (EU), we do have electricity and, therefore, computers, but I, personally, adhere to the chemicals/darkroom view of things. The pre-digital photographers could do marvels with that. I need computers, and shall not throw them away. .....though I do have a number of similar 'failures' (the French word 'ratage' is, here, better)
the photograph was chosen by one of the team responsible for the "Picture of the Week"
But, you, like me. are in France... here, with a "fosse toutes eaux".... darkroom chemicals are a no-no.... so I too require a computer as my darkroom.
This has opened a whole new field for me.... I haven't created anything, yet, like oldhat's picture above...
nor have I explored HDR, RAW or stacking... there just isn't the time at present!!
But there are plug-ins I can allow to chunter on in the background while I do something more important.
Those I like.... but even Natural History photography seems to be heading into the art field.... according to the magazines I subscribe to.....
But here, in deepest rural France.... our connection with the outside world is patchy... forcing more reliance on the home network.
So, I cannot throw my computer to the wind!!
Photography is an interest to be enjoyed.... it is more than a mere hobby, afterall!
Keep taking your interesting, thoughtful and though provoking pictures....
I, for one, will be following.
Never be afraid to talk about your techniques...
"Give a thousand photographers...
the same camera, lens and scene...
and you'll always get a thousand different takes!!"
Anon.
"Give a thousand photographers...
the same camera, lens and scene...
and you'll always get a thousand different takes!!"
Anon.
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


31 posts
17 years
Firenze-Italia