Wide angle question/favour
Posted 21/04/2009 - 11:37
Link
Daniel Bridge wrote:
If you're looking for a comparison between what you have at the moment (a 28-200 zoom), and a 10mm lens, then you need comparison shots at 10mm and 28mm. Forget about 42mm. It's irrelevant.
By the way, you will see a massive difference. If I had the time, and it wasn't 12.45am, I'd take a couple of shots to show you. Maybe tomorrow...
Dan
Ok why is it irelevant as surley my field of view will be 42mm not 28mm?foxycce wrote:
However I would like it to be compared with something for comparison, against my sigma 28mm(obviously 42mm on cropped sensor)
You still haven't quite grasped focal lengths yet I don't think (reading this thread again).However I would like it to be compared with something for comparison, against my sigma 28mm(obviously 42mm on cropped sensor)
If you're looking for a comparison between what you have at the moment (a 28-200 zoom), and a 10mm lens, then you need comparison shots at 10mm and 28mm. Forget about 42mm. It's irrelevant.
By the way, you will see a massive difference. If I had the time, and it wasn't 12.45am, I'd take a couple of shots to show you. Maybe tomorrow...
Dan
or 15mm not 10 mm so losing some and gaining some as so to speak , this is where the comparison thery came from, But yes i appriciate i just compare the original sizes
Posted 21/04/2009 - 11:37
Link
I'm very curious where always comes the confusion from, is it our fault maybe?
We had focal lengths in elementry school so you know it's lens specific. A magnify glass for example also has a focal length, does it change depending the size of paper you're using on?
We had focal lengths in elementry school so you know it's lens specific. A magnify glass for example also has a focal length, does it change depending the size of paper you're using on?
Posted 21/04/2009 - 11:46
Link
Foxy field of view (FOV) you don't write in MM als for field of view you need to know the distance of that field from the lens so I'm curious about your calculations.
Angle of view (AOV) doesn't need an distance from the field to the lens since it doesn't have a field and to calcualte FOV you need AOV.
here is the formula for angle of view.

(α ) angle of view
(d) (sensor) dimension
(f) focal length
do you also wanna have the formula for focal length?

R1 and R2 radii of curvature
(n) refractive index
(d) Thickness of the lens
(f) focal length
As you can see no image size to be found in that formula
Angle of view (AOV) doesn't need an distance from the field to the lens since it doesn't have a field and to calcualte FOV you need AOV.
here is the formula for angle of view.

(α ) angle of view
(d) (sensor) dimension
(f) focal length
do you also wanna have the formula for focal length?

R1 and R2 radii of curvature
(n) refractive index
(d) Thickness of the lens
(f) focal length
As you can see no image size to be found in that formula
Posted 21/04/2009 - 11:48
Link
Just compare like-for-like
If you are comparing lenses on the same body, then compare 28mm against 10mm or 12mm.
If you were used to using a 28mm on 35mm film and want that on digital then compare the angle of view - so your old 28mm on a 35mm film body would give the same AoV as 18mm on digital.
Looking at your kit list, I suppose your original question should have been "How much wider is 10mm compared to 18mm?" (since you already have the 18-55 kit lens). Answer - appreciably wide, but not necessarily more useful (See my reply about 12mm for portraits!... think there was a couple of images on another thread that showed the face distortion at 12mm...)
Matt
If you are comparing lenses on the same body, then compare 28mm against 10mm or 12mm.
If you were used to using a 28mm on 35mm film and want that on digital then compare the angle of view - so your old 28mm on a 35mm film body would give the same AoV as 18mm on digital.
Looking at your kit list, I suppose your original question should have been "How much wider is 10mm compared to 18mm?" (since you already have the 18-55 kit lens). Answer - appreciably wide, but not necessarily more useful (See my reply about 12mm for portraits!... think there was a couple of images on another thread that showed the face distortion at 12mm...)
Matt
http://www.mattmatic.co.uk
(For gallery, tips and links)
(For gallery, tips and links)
Posted 21/04/2009 - 11:56
Link
Here are some images that show the kind of edge distortion you'll get (Googled these - with Nikon & Tokina lenses... but you'll get the idea)
1) http://static.photo.net/attachments/bboard/00I/00IM8t-32857184.jpg
2) http://static.photo.net/attachments/bboard/00I/00IM8r-32857084.jpg
3) http://www.billmajoros.com/photoalbum/categories/new/WideAngle/frames/dog-3.html
That said, there are situations where 12mm and wider is useful. You have to weigh up whether it's worth the price of the 10-20 or 12-24
... of course, for portraits you can always use your feet and the 18-55 and just move further back
Matt
1) http://static.photo.net/attachments/bboard/00I/00IM8t-32857184.jpg
2) http://static.photo.net/attachments/bboard/00I/00IM8r-32857084.jpg
3) http://www.billmajoros.com/photoalbum/categories/new/WideAngle/frames/dog-3.html
That said, there are situations where 12mm and wider is useful. You have to weigh up whether it's worth the price of the 10-20 or 12-24
... of course, for portraits you can always use your feet and the 18-55 and just move further back
Matt
http://www.mattmatic.co.uk
(For gallery, tips and links)
(For gallery, tips and links)
Posted 21/04/2009 - 12:04
Link
Gwyn wrote:
Here are two I took last year. Though not quite from the same spot they do show the difference between 10mm and 18mm.
[IMG]http://i28.photobucket.com/albums/c205/Bargwynbu/Goosenecksweb1.jpg[/IMG]
@10mm with the Sigma 10-20mm
That's one thing i love about the 10-20mm Gwyn the perspectives you get on the skies is fantastic.Nice image Gwyn
Here are two I took last year. Though not quite from the same spot they do show the difference between 10mm and 18mm.
[IMG]http://i28.photobucket.com/albums/c205/Bargwynbu/Goosenecksweb1.jpg[/IMG]
@10mm with the Sigma 10-20mm
Posted 21/04/2009 - 12:09
Link
It seems crop factor, focal length and field-of-view are difficult concepts to explain with words and example photographs alone.
Is there a series of good diagrams on the web to make it all clearer?
Is there a series of good diagrams on the web to make it all clearer?
~Pete
Posted 21/04/2009 - 12:11
Link
Quote:
It seems crop factor, focal length and field-of-view are difficult concepts to explain with words alone. Is there a series of good diagrams on the web to make it all clearer?
Here is a document and diagram that I did waaaay back in 2003 It seems crop factor, focal length and field-of-view are difficult concepts to explain with words alone. Is there a series of good diagrams on the web to make it all clearer?
http://www.photon.me.uk/matt/cameras/pentax/istd_focal.htm
Matt
http://www.mattmatic.co.uk
(For gallery, tips and links)
(For gallery, tips and links)
Posted 21/04/2009 - 12:16
Link
sanderscapes wrote:
That's one thing i love about the 10-20mm Gwyn the perspectives you get on the skies is fantastic.Nice image Gwyn
Thankyou!
That's one thing i love about the 10-20mm Gwyn the perspectives you get on the skies is fantastic.Nice image Gwyn
Posted 21/04/2009 - 12:20
Link
MattMatic wrote:
Here is a document and diagram that I did waaaay back in 2003
http://www.photon.me.uk/matt/cameras/pentax/istd_focal.htm
Excellent. I hope that's useful for Foxy. But if you're still confused, Foxy, just concentrate on what a certain focal length provides on your digital camera and forget about film cameras for the time being if you're not using one.
Here is a document and diagram that I did waaaay back in 2003
http://www.photon.me.uk/matt/cameras/pentax/istd_focal.htm
~Pete
Posted 21/04/2009 - 15:56
Link
MattMatic wrote:
Just compare like-for-like
If you are comparing lenses on the same body, then compare 28mm against 10mm or 12mm.
If you were used to using a 28mm on 35mm film and want that on digital then compare the angle of view - so your old 28mm on a 35mm film body would give the same AoV as 18mm on digital.
Looking at your kit list, I suppose your original question should have been "How much wider is 10mm compared to 18mm?" (since you already have the 18-55 kit lens). Answer - appreciably wide, but not necessarily more useful (See my reply about 12mm for portraits!... think there was a couple of images on another thread that showed the face distortion at 12mm...)
Matt
This is exactly what i meant. I Confuse myself
Just compare like-for-like
If you are comparing lenses on the same body, then compare 28mm against 10mm or 12mm.
If you were used to using a 28mm on 35mm film and want that on digital then compare the angle of view - so your old 28mm on a 35mm film body would give the same AoV as 18mm on digital.
Looking at your kit list, I suppose your original question should have been "How much wider is 10mm compared to 18mm?" (since you already have the 18-55 kit lens). Answer - appreciably wide, but not necessarily more useful (See my reply about 12mm for portraits!... think there was a couple of images on another thread that showed the face distortion at 12mm...)
Matt
Posted 21/04/2009 - 15:57
Link
what i did mean was
How much wider is 10mm compared to 28mm?"
However this has now been answered
How much wider is 10mm compared to 28mm?"
However this has now been answered
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



3062 posts
19 years
England Inside leg: 34
However I would like it to be compared with something for comparison, against my sigma 28mm(obviously 42mm on cropped sensor)
I appreciate that you don't understand what the crop factor is all about (despite attempts to explain it from forum members), but you don't need to understand it when using your Pentax digital SLR, regardless of whether your lenses are designed for film or digital.