What "Normal" lens for K-7
Posted 11/07/2010 - 21:08
Link
mecrox wrote:
The best all-rounder is most likely the DA 35mm f2.8.
I wouldn't disagree. I owned it for a while and thought it the best single all-rounder lens one could put on a camera. But for me it was never a matter of having only a single lens and so I grudgingly traded it on. The best all-rounder is most likely the DA 35mm f2.8.
mecrox wrote:
Second up would be the FA 35mm f2.0. But because it is no longer made and is much sought after, I think you'd have to be careful not to overpay for a second-hand example whether Pentax or Samsung.
I think at $500 it goes for too much. The DA35 has a lot more usefulness and is built better. I don't own a single (non-Limited) FA lens since I dislike their look and feel.Second up would be the FA 35mm f2.0. But because it is no longer made and is much sought after, I think you'd have to be careful not to overpay for a second-hand example whether Pentax or Samsung.
mecrox wrote:
I have an SMC A 28mm f2.8 (manual focus). It's OK for black and white but I haven't found it up to the standards of my limited lenses. Time to move on.
I agree completely. I prefer the Vivitars to this lens, which seems antiquated.I have an SMC A 28mm f2.8 (manual focus). It's OK for black and white but I haven't found it up to the standards of my limited lenses. Time to move on.
mecrox wrote:
I would not buy an FA 31mm. I think it is far too expensive for what it is, and personally I would not feel much at ease strolling around with such expensive kit.
If it was 28mm I would have bought it to go with the other two FA Limiteds in my bag. There is something about them that transcends other lenses.
I would not buy an FA 31mm. I think it is far too expensive for what it is, and personally I would not feel much at ease strolling around with such expensive kit.
Posted 11/07/2010 - 21:31
Link
dougf8 wrote:
Why on the "other" site does the 30mm F1.4 Sigma get 9.7 rating?
I don't know, but I can guess.Why on the "other" site does the 30mm F1.4 Sigma get 9.7 rating?
1. Often people only write a review if they like a lens. There is a lot less incentive to write up a lens you find disappointing. For instance, the 21 different Pentax FA lenses are rated from 8.42 to 10.0, a very narrow range considering the full ten point scale. An average lens should be rated a 5, but who really does this?
2. Many people are not exacting in their lens requirements. I don't mean this to be a negative reflection on them, it's a simple statement of fact. Pretty well any lens can take a good picture and pretty well any major brand lens is good enough for most people.
3. Combined with this is a lack of perspective. Someone might buy a lens and find it sufficient and write it up as a 10/10. Likely those who rate the Sigma in this way have not tried the FA31 to compare. Given the price, I do not blame them for this either! But I prefer to take my advice from sites and individuals that have compared the lenses directly.
4. More experienced shooters tend to rate lenses lower, since they have higher expectations and more experience. This seems obvious when I look at the many average and even substandard shots folks post in defence of their favourite lenses.
5. The focal length might be dead-on what people want to use, compared with other lenses they have. This lens is near normal and so has appeal based on that fact, totally apart from how well it does as a normal.
6. The reviewer's usage might conform to exactly what the lens is good for and nothing else. In the case of the Sigma 30, low-light portraits, with the subject in the centre, would work a treat. Who cares about soft edges and vignetting then? They are actually bonuses! But one would not want to use it for shots of walls and landscapes -- in these use cases the FA31 would blow it out of the water.
For these reasons I have never given much credence to the lens ratings at Pentax Forums. The reviews themselves are far more useful than a single number.
Posted 11/07/2010 - 21:46
Link
rparmar wrote:
6. The reviewer's usage might conform to exactly what the lens is good for and nothing else. In the case of the Sigma 30, low-light portraits, with the subject in the centre, would work a treat. Who cares about soft edges and vignetting then? They are actually bonuses! But one would not want to use it for shots of walls and landscapes -- in these use cases the FA31 would blow it out of the water.
Maybe you just had a duff copy - this is a completely random picture from a site visit I did on friday - full size so people can look for themselves : link (Very low light, flash used, straight out of Lightroom no tweaks beyond default lens correction).6. The reviewer's usage might conform to exactly what the lens is good for and nothing else. In the case of the Sigma 30, low-light portraits, with the subject in the centre, would work a treat. Who cares about soft edges and vignetting then? They are actually bonuses! But one would not want to use it for shots of walls and landscapes -- in these use cases the FA31 would blow it out of the water.
Clearly the edges are softer than the centre and there is vignetting in the corners. Oh...wait, no, there isn't any difference...
I'm sure the FA31 would be nicer. But as it would have cost me FOUR times the price the Sigma did, one would hope so!
Still shooting in the dark (literally and metaphorically)...
Posted 11/07/2010 - 21:53
Link
MrCynical wrote:
Depends on your priorities, but anything in the 28-35mm should do. Your in-production options are:
*Sigma 30mm f1.4 - fastest lens here and also the cheapest (relatively speaking). It has no resolution to speak of in the far corners wide open (and isn't great at borders either), but at f1.4 your extreme corners are going to be blurred (ie bokeh) anyway
*FA31 Limited - fabulous, but it's £1000. If you have £1000 to spend on photo gear (and don't, for some reason, want the DA*50-135 ), the FA31 is widely regarded as one of the best prime lenses ever made.
*DA35 Macro Limited - not a fast lens (only f2., but if your primary use for it will be outdoor/street work it is very well regarded indeed. It also has the advantage that, though 35mm isn't a great macro focal length, you never have to worry about the minimum focus distance for normal shots! Only weakness might be the slow autofocus, however unlike the others on this list it has Quick Shift (ie you can turn the MF ring while in AF mode) so you can give it a helping hand if it decides to hunt.
Of the used options, the FA35 is just under a stop faster than the DA35 and just over a stop slower than the Sigma. It's supposed to be very sharp wide open (ie it's likely sharper at f2 than the Sigma is at f2). Since it's only available used, you'll (perhaps rather obviously) pay less than you would for a new copy of the other lenses.
Thanks, I'm contemplating the FA 35.
Depends on your priorities, but anything in the 28-35mm should do. Your in-production options are:
*Sigma 30mm f1.4 - fastest lens here and also the cheapest (relatively speaking). It has no resolution to speak of in the far corners wide open (and isn't great at borders either), but at f1.4 your extreme corners are going to be blurred (ie bokeh) anyway
*FA31 Limited - fabulous, but it's £1000. If you have £1000 to spend on photo gear (and don't, for some reason, want the DA*50-135 ), the FA31 is widely regarded as one of the best prime lenses ever made.
*DA35 Macro Limited - not a fast lens (only f2., but if your primary use for it will be outdoor/street work it is very well regarded indeed. It also has the advantage that, though 35mm isn't a great macro focal length, you never have to worry about the minimum focus distance for normal shots! Only weakness might be the slow autofocus, however unlike the others on this list it has Quick Shift (ie you can turn the MF ring while in AF mode) so you can give it a helping hand if it decides to hunt.
Of the used options, the FA35 is just under a stop faster than the DA35 and just over a stop slower than the Sigma. It's supposed to be very sharp wide open (ie it's likely sharper at f2 than the Sigma is at f2). Since it's only available used, you'll (perhaps rather obviously) pay less than you would for a new copy of the other lenses.
Posted 11/07/2010 - 21:55
Link
dougf8 wrote:
Why on the "other" site does the 30mm F1.4 Sigma get 9.7 rating?
Are people buying 2nd hand copies that are duffers?
If you had a crap copy and wanted rid, you just keep schtum and sell it, leaving the buyer to work it out?
Or are these new copies with some variation?
It was new.
Why on the "other" site does the 30mm F1.4 Sigma get 9.7 rating?
Are people buying 2nd hand copies that are duffers?
If you had a crap copy and wanted rid, you just keep schtum and sell it, leaving the buyer to work it out?
Or are these new copies with some variation?
Posted 11/07/2010 - 21:57
Link
rparmar wrote:
The FA 31, fine lens that it is is just too expensive for my purposes (still looking for one though). 28mm would be ideal but the FA 35 probably is the best of the bunch at the price.
mecrox wrote:
The best all-rounder is most likely the DA 35mm f2.8.
I wouldn't disagree. I owned it for a while and thought it the best single all-rounder lens one could put on a camera. But for me it was never a matter of having only a single lens and so I grudgingly traded it on. The best all-rounder is most likely the DA 35mm f2.8.
mecrox wrote:
Second up would be the FA 35mm f2.0. But because it is no longer made and is much sought after, I think you'd have to be careful not to overpay for a second-hand example whether Pentax or Samsung.
I think at $500 it goes for too much. The DA35 has a lot more usefulness and is built better. I don't own a single (non-Limited) FA lens since I dislike their look and feel.Second up would be the FA 35mm f2.0. But because it is no longer made and is much sought after, I think you'd have to be careful not to overpay for a second-hand example whether Pentax or Samsung.
mecrox wrote:
I have an SMC A 28mm f2.8 (manual focus). It's OK for black and white but I haven't found it up to the standards of my limited lenses. Time to move on.
I agree completely. I prefer the Vivitars to this lens, which seems antiquated.I have an SMC A 28mm f2.8 (manual focus). It's OK for black and white but I haven't found it up to the standards of my limited lenses. Time to move on.
mecrox wrote:
I would not buy an FA 31mm. I think it is far too expensive for what it is, and personally I would not feel much at ease strolling around with such expensive kit.
If it was 28mm I would have bought it to go with the other two FA Limiteds in my bag. There is something about them that transcends other lenses.I would not buy an FA 31mm. I think it is far too expensive for what it is, and personally I would not feel much at ease strolling around with such expensive kit.
Posted 11/07/2010 - 22:00
Link
flossie wrote:
Clearly the edges are softer than the centre and there is vignetting in the corners. Oh...wait, no, there isn't any difference...
I'm sure the FA31 would be nicer. But as it would have cost me FOUR times the price the Sigma did, one would hope so!
Mine was probably a (much) worse than average copy; it was unusable except as a paper weight.
rparmar wrote:
6. The reviewer's usage might conform to exactly what the lens is good for and nothing else. In the case of the Sigma 30, low-light portraits, with the subject in the centre, would work a treat. Who cares about soft edges and vignetting then? They are actually bonuses! But one would not want to use it for shots of walls and landscapes -- in these use cases the FA31 would blow it out of the water.
Maybe you just had a duff copy - this is a completely random picture from a site visit I did on friday - full size so people can look for themselves : link (Very low light, flash used, straight out of Lightroom no tweaks beyond default lens correction).6. The reviewer's usage might conform to exactly what the lens is good for and nothing else. In the case of the Sigma 30, low-light portraits, with the subject in the centre, would work a treat. Who cares about soft edges and vignetting then? They are actually bonuses! But one would not want to use it for shots of walls and landscapes -- in these use cases the FA31 would blow it out of the water.
Clearly the edges are softer than the centre and there is vignetting in the corners. Oh...wait, no, there isn't any difference...
I'm sure the FA31 would be nicer. But as it would have cost me FOUR times the price the Sigma did, one would hope so!
Posted 11/07/2010 - 23:19
Link
dougf8 wrote:
Or are these new copies with some variation?
Most modern Sigma lenses (the 105 Macro seems to be an extension, possibly the 70 as well) still have this affliction.
Or are these new copies with some variation?
Posted 12/07/2010 - 00:08
Link
To put it in perspective I compared it with my Sigma 17-70 f2.8-4.5, a consumer grade zoom with a reputation for softness whereas the 30mm is a professional grade prime lens. The zoom wide open (f3.5) at around 28-30mm was so far superior edge & centre it was beyond belief.
Posted 12/07/2010 - 02:04
Link
flossie wrote:
this is a completely random picture from a site visit I did on friday - full size so people can look for themselves
Any lens in the world could have taken that picture. If that's your standard then you are right, the Sigma is perfectly capable.
this is a completely random picture from a site visit I did on friday - full size so people can look for themselves
Posted 12/07/2010 - 07:38
Link
MrCynical wrote:
Exception?? I hope so as I bought one.
dougf8 wrote:
Or are these new copies with some variation?
Most modern Sigma lenses (the 105 Macro seems to be an extension, possibly the 70 as well) still have this affliction.Or are these new copies with some variation?
Lurking is shirking.!
Posted 12/07/2010 - 08:00
Link
rparmar wrote:
Its a crap picture to remind myself what a gaustly corridor looks like so I can come back in a few weeks and make it look less gaustly (what pays for these toys in the first place). Its not a piece of photographic art, I never said it was anything of the sort. What it does show is that the lens is the same on the edge as the centre as the corners - and its a picture of a wall, which you said noone would use that lens to do flossie wrote:
this is a completely random picture from a site visit I did on friday - full size so people can look for themselves
Any lens in the world could have taken that picture. If that's your standard then you are right, the Sigma is perfectly capable.this is a completely random picture from a site visit I did on friday - full size so people can look for themselves
It stays on the camera as my default lens when I do site visits like this for two reasons - because its a "normal" lens (I can look at the FoV as well as be sure there's no distortion or telephoto effects), and because its cheap and small. A DA-21 or DA-40 were alternatives but couldn't get near the same price without going 2nd hand, and for something needed for work in a hurry at the time that wasn't an option.
Still shooting in the dark (literally and metaphorically)...
Posted 12/07/2010 - 08:11
Link
Flossie, I have to say it's not a good photo for assessing the merits of the lens however it appears better than the one I bought but markedly worse than my 17-70 Sigma.
This is a Pro grade prime lens?!!!
This is a Pro grade prime lens?!!!
Posted 12/07/2010 - 12:39
Link
flossie wrote:
Its a crap picture to remind myself what a gaustly corridor looks like so I can come back in a few weeks and make it look less gaustly (what pays for these toys in the first place). Its not a piece of photographic art, I never said it was anything of the sort.
Neither did I say anything about "photographic art" -- please don't take me the wrong way. I was merely saying that it is not a suitable photo for evaluating a lens. You need a flat field from corner to corner and lots of detail (how else to evaluate sharpness?) plus natural light (or controlled studio light), lowest ISO and camera stabilised on a tripod. Even then it is very, very difficult to get right since the focal plane has to be exactly parallel to the subject, the lighting must be exactly even, etc.Its a crap picture to remind myself what a gaustly corridor looks like so I can come back in a few weeks and make it look less gaustly (what pays for these toys in the first place). Its not a piece of photographic art, I never said it was anything of the sort.
Then one needs to process from RAW in a neutral fashion with no added processing and present 100% crops for examination.
This is why I said your shot was insufficient.
Personally I don't go around setting up such shots either, and can only evaluate a lens fully after a good deal of actual use. Until that time I trust proper tests and the consensus of users who are as strict as I am.
If this lens works for you, great! We all have different needs and standards. Cheap, small and normal are all good reasons for you to use it. But if you like the Sigma 30 in the corners I think you would be shocked and amazed by the DA16-45.
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


2917 posts
17 years
another place
Are people buying 2nd hand copies that are duffers?
If you had a crap copy and wanted rid, you just keep schtum and sell it, leaving the buyer to work it out?
Or are these new copies with some variation?