Weekly Competition #115 - Yun

davidtrout
Posted 19/09/2009 - 17:00 Link
Martin, I take your point about some sort of filtering entries if the numbers get too high for a judge to cope with them. But I don't know how you would go about it.
david
Malo1961
Posted 19/09/2009 - 18:37 Link
David,
As I mentioned before, there probably is the technical possibility to connect the weekly competition section or/and the gallery to a minimal number of posts on the forum. All it takes is the will to implement it.

Another way is creating a disclaimer that has to be read and approved/signed for, which will pop-up before a picture is uploaded to the competition.
This disclaimer could be as short or long as it takes. Think about the already known rules like Pentax cameras only, or committing yourself to leave feedback for all entries if you are the judge and perhaps some encouragement to show appreciation for the man/woman who took a big effort in judging that competition.

Remember, there are numerous competitions you can enter on the web. A lot of them have prizes. They have one thing in common. You can enter without further involvement and the judging is mostly done by more than one person. And yes...I know we are talking about a totally different volume of entries in that example.

Opposite to those competitions we have the principle of the PUF format.
The prize? 30 seconds of fame and the kudos/appraisal afterwards. After that....... You can start with climbing Mount Judge!!
(which is getting higher and higher)

Lets not turn the competition into some sort of extended C & C dumping ground.
IMO EPHOTOZine already provides such a possibility on their own forum. Divided in several sub categories.
So...A different taste for anyone is available.

Is it therefore to much to ask, in trying to keep the competitions within the spirits of the PUF community itself. Because......PUF is made by all the members who participate. Not those who sit quietly on the sideline and don't have the intention to get involved.

I'll be quiet now.
Best regards,

Martin.


Curious about my photography?? Just Follow the Light.
Edited by Malo1961: 19/09/2009 - 18:40
bforbes
Posted 19/09/2009 - 19:33 Link
I can see that this would prevent new starters from entering competitions until they had "proved their credentials” if that is what you want. Alternatively could you set a limit for the interval between the date of the competition and the date of the last post? Thus trying to prevent long periods of inactivity followed by a chance competition entry.
johnriley
Posted 19/09/2009 - 19:44 Link
I would want to encourage newer members to enter, not exclude them.
Best regards, John
RR
Posted 19/09/2009 - 19:44 Link
bforbes wrote:
Alternatively could you set a limit for the interval between the date of the competition and the date of the last post? Thus trying to prevent long periods of inactivity followed by a chance competition entry.
Not a practical solution as far as I can see. A quick "nice photo" or "I agree" in a random thread & you're then free to enter. This would devalue the forum more than the comp.
Malo1961
Posted 19/09/2009 - 19:47 Link
I see it otherwise Barrie. It would prevent people with No intention at all to get involved on this forum to enter the competition.

Compare it to a camera/photographic club. You don't drop off your pictures for a competition and leave
without ever beiing in touch with other members.
No.....First you introduce yourself, ask around, get in contact with other people. Members get to know you and vise versa.
You get involved because you choose to be part of that community.
Than you start thinking about joining a competition.
Best regards,

Martin.


Curious about my photography?? Just Follow the Light.
bforbes
Posted 19/09/2009 - 19:48 Link
you could say the same about a set number of posts before entry
GlynM
Posted 19/09/2009 - 19:52 Link
I think somebody needs to stand up for the occasional contributors. I'm not sure I completely qualify but although I have been around here for nearly 4 years I only have 196 posts, including this one, so I guess that makes me an an occasional. I submit to both competitions fairly often and have won one weekly competition and have therefore judged another.


If I remember there was a lot of discussion, including a lot of discontent, when the weekly competition moved out of the forum into the gallery and this lead to the conception of the forum based fortnightly competition. I think both competitions serve this community well.

I think we should see the weekly competition as a way of getting people into the forum. Ok there will always be those that don't want to stray outside the gallery but even if it introduces one or two that is one or two that we would not have otherwise got. I think applying any forum based constraints will bring the shutters down. You don't have to participate in both competitions. If the gallery based competition is not working for you then why not only inhabit the forum based competition?

What are these worries about the amount of work the judging takes? Not long ago we used to think it was a complement to the judge if their subject attracted more than around 30 entries. I was really pleased to get 38. Those that choose to participate should know that they have a responsibility if they win. If this is not clear then perhaps the rules need to be publicised a bit more. As already mentioned its a lot easier if the judging work, where possible, is spread throughout the week. Tongue-in-cheek, if your worried about the number of submissions then set a less inclusive subject although I guess there is a very fine and difficult balance needed to make this work. There can be no acclaims for the setter of a subject that attracts no submissions


Glyn
Darkmunk
Posted 19/09/2009 - 20:06 Link
It's a tricky one isn't it?
Each time someone posts in this thread I find myself agreeing with them
Remember we're talking about the future here tho'. I don't think anyone has any real issue with the amount of work we currently face. I had my doubts I could take that much time again, but I know I will happily do it again if I ever win.

But next year... who knows?
It really would become an irksome task if we didn't know 50% of the entrants.
bforbes
Posted 19/09/2009 - 20:07 Link
Malo1961 wrote:
I see it otherwise Barrie. It would prevent people with No intention at all to get involved on this forum to enter the competition.

Compare it to a camera/photographic club. You don't drop off your pictures for a competition and leave
without ever beiing in touch with other members.
No.....First you introduce yourself, ask around, get in contact with other people. Members get to know you and vise versa.
You get involved because you choose to be part of that community.
Than you start thinking about joining a competition.
I'm not a member of a camera club but I imaging there is a higher level of commitment involved by virtue of having to turn up in person. A forum like this needs very little commitment to join, but how you would raise the entry bar I have no idea. Maybe a fee or mandatory subscription to the magazine.
George Lazarette
Posted 19/09/2009 - 20:14 Link
GlynM wrote:
There can be no acclaims for the setter of a subject that attracts no submissions
Glyn
Oh, I don't know. Seems like an eminently sensible objective to me.

Early in my career I used to mark exam papers to help make ends meet. It's a dreadful job. Judging the competition isn't that bad, but it's quite a task, especially if there are a lot of entries and you want to do your best by each entrant.

I think that Martin is miffed (quite understandably) by the lack of manners shown by those who take part and then fail to acknowledge the effort that goes into judging. Sadly, I think that this is just part and parcel of modern life, and any effort at a cure is going to be worse than the disease.

G
(Note to self: must remember to enter some competitions)
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
gartmore
Posted 20/09/2009 - 10:40 Link
I think part of the joy of this competition is it's informality and I wouldn't want to introduce anything that would discourage new members from taking part. As George says, there is a general lack of manners these days.
Ken
“We must avoid however, snapping away, shooting quickly and without thought, overloading ourselves with unnecessary images that clutter our memory and diminish the clarity of the whole.” - Henri Cartier-Bresson -
Galoot
Posted 20/09/2009 - 11:56 Link
Oops !!! ( re. my entry for this weeks competition )

I grabbed a frame from the web to enhance the fact that the Spotmatic is a film camera, unfortunately, the quoted exif is from this imported frame. The actual 'Spot' picture was taken with my Pentax-DS and the 18-55mm kit lens, NOT some sort of Olympus?

I await a good slapping, and the judges scorn
Karl
Posted 20/09/2009 - 12:37 Link
I don't really see what you can say to the person who has done the judging apart from aknowledging the effort they have put in.

If you don't agree with their judgement I don't think it is correct etiquete to say anything because their decision is final and you have to respect that.
https://pentaxphotogallery.com" target="_blank">https://pentaxphotogallery.com/images/black_link_small.jpg" alt="See my photos featured in the PENTAX Photogallery" />
Malo1961
Posted 20/09/2009 - 12:51 Link
Karl wrote:
I don't really see what you can say to the person who has done the judging apart from aknowledging the effort they have put in.
Just check the posts that are there, and you have a idea

But....Its not about what is said. Its about the simple fact that a increasing number of participants ( with zero postings on their name)
just join the competition and are never heard off afterwards.
I mean.....why do people enter competitions?
But I'll guess George and Ken already mentioned a plausible cause.
Best regards,

Martin.


Curious about my photography?? Just Follow the Light.
Edited by Malo1961: 20/09/2009 - 12:51

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo