USB Storage with DSLR

iceblinker
Posted 25/06/2009 - 22:54 Link
I wonder again: why can't I plug an ordinary hard drive into my network router at home? The router is a computer, so to speak, so some firmware could be added to make it compatible with an ordinary hard drive if it was that easy.

It would be tremendously useful, yet it's not done. Why not? Why do I have to buy a NAS drive instead?
~Pete
iceblinker
Posted 25/06/2009 - 23:00 Link
Same question with the Logitech Squeezebox (music system) - which again you could call call a "computer". Why can I not plug an ordinary hard drive or memory stick into that?

Again, it would be extremely useful. There's got to be a good reason why it's not done.
~Pete
polchraine
Posted 25/06/2009 - 23:06 Link
To connect a USB stick to a camera is not an easy option.

In simple terms you have a masters and slaves and whereas a master can talk to a slave but a master cannot talk to a master and a slave cannot talk to a slave.

A PC is a master and has a hub with several outputs using the "Standard" 15mm x 5 mm flat connector. Whereas a remote device such as a printer, scanner or remote drive is a slave and if connected by a loose cable will have a different "type B" connector.

If a camera was to be able to talk to a USB stick then it would need an internal "hub" and a second connector of the standard USB size and would need to meet the USB standards which includes that capability to provide 500mA to an attached device. That would put an unacceptable load on the PC.

Personally, I don't think we will see them on DSLRs in te foreseeable future.
.
K20D, *istD, MZ-S, Super-A, ME Super, MX
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, DA* 300,
DA 50-200, FA 24-90, FA 20-35,
M 400-600, A 50 f1.4, A 28 f2.8, A 70-210, M 35-80, M 50 f1.7
A x2S teleconverter and a few others ...
Unlocker
Posted 25/06/2009 - 23:25 Link
Which is why I think a 2nd SD card slot in the grip would be a better idea!

See here!
Galoot
Posted 26/06/2009 - 00:26 Link
I could connect my DS to my iPod, which was basically a 60GB hard drive, via a small adaptor provided by Apple.

Unfortunately, the transfer speed was so slow, USB 1.0, I think, that the iPod and camera batteries, were both drained before the transfer from a 512MB card was complete.

So there is a way of down loading to an external hard drive.
Anvh
Posted 26/06/2009 - 01:24 Link
iceblinker wrote:
I wonder again: why can't I plug an ordinary hard drive into my network router at home? The router is a computer, so to speak, so some firmware could be added to make it compatible with an ordinary hard drive if it was that easy.

It would be tremendously useful, yet it's not done. Why not? Why do I have to buy a NAS drive instead?
My dad has a router with an usb port, he now has his printer on it but it can also be used to connect an external harddisk so yes it comes down to support.

polchraine wrote:
If a camera was to be able to talk to a USB stick then it would need an internal "hub" and a second connector of the standard USB size and would need to meet the USB standards which includes that capability to provide 500mA to an attached device.
Yes the standard might be a problem, since it needs to deliver the powersuplly but I'm now typing this on a keyboard that is connect through a mini-usb and i've an adapter to make it a normal usb so there are more ways to Rome. Apple is using a lot of weird connections so why not Pentax?

The 500mA could also come from the net if everything comes together correctly with the connector i won't see a problem there or is it in the standard that it need to come from the master device itself or that the connector type A needs to supply that power?
We Dutch like to find the ways between rules
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
iceblinker
Posted 26/06/2009 - 11:58 Link
Anvh wrote:
My dad has a router with an usb port, he now has his printer on it but it can also be used to connect an external harddisk so yes it comes down to support.
Are you sure an ordinary hard disk can be used with it? Is the router very expensive?
~Pete
Unlocker
Posted 26/06/2009 - 13:01 Link
iceblinker wrote:
Anvh wrote:
My dad has a router with an usb port, he now has his printer on it but it can also be used to connect an external harddisk so yes it comes down to support.
Are you sure an ordinary hard disk can be used with it? Is the router very expensive?
Have a look at an airport extreme. It's certainly doable, like most things are, just needs support and the will to do it.
iceblinker
Posted 26/06/2009 - 14:12 Link
And the expense. The Airport Extreme router costs well over a hundred quid, whereas an ordinary router costs £15 to £50.

I can believe Pentax cameras could be made to work directly with hard drives too, but at what cost? That is the question.
~Pete
Edited by iceblinker: 26/06/2009 - 14:13
Bob and his Pentax
Posted 26/06/2009 - 14:19 Link
Hi Stefan

There are devices which can connect 2 USB storage devices back to back in order to copy from one to the other. An example of this may be found on Amazon

One device could be your camera and the other a USB memory stick or even a USB hard drive. Of course while the transfer is happening you cann't use the camera and you have no positive way of checking that the transfer is OK.

For me given that memory cards are so cheep (eg Toshiba 8GB SDHC for under £10) I'm going to stick with useing a large number of SDHC cards - and although I do copy used SDHC cards to a Vosonic standalone card reader/harddisk/viewer I consider the card to be my master until the pictures are on the PC and backed up.
Good luck

Bob

Pentax user since 1978, Digital since 1997.
Kit includes: K-7, K20D, K10D, *istDS, full set DA* lens, etc
Anvh
Posted 27/06/2009 - 22:37 Link
Thank you Bob didn't knew those things exist, they look handy.
Wished they had a readout screen so that you can see if it went alright and things like that, just like you said.

SDHC certainly are becoming cheap but still they are for more expensive then and harddisk or USB-stick so that's why it might be an interesting option.
Certainly whit movie mode on the camera it might go quite fast with storage room.
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
rparmar
Posted 29/06/2009 - 14:15 Link
iceblinker wrote:
I wonder again: why can't I plug an ordinary hard drive into my network router at home?
Well, that's an easy one. A hard drive is just a stupid hard drive. A NAS is a full computer with its own operating system and knowledge of interfaces needed to communicate with hard drives. It's smart. Those smarts cost more money.

Back to the OP, there are indeed host USB hard drives one can use to dump data from SD cards and the like. But they are many times more expensive than a simple portable USB drive.
Listen to my albums free on BandCamp. Or visit my main website for links to photography, etc.
rbubbly
Posted 01/07/2009 - 07:57 Link
This might be a better way to do this.
Wolverine FlashPac 80GB Portable Hard Drive and Card Reader

link

The Wolverine FlashPac is a battery powered hard drive with a built in card reader to enable you to transfer the contents of a memory card to the hard drive. Wolverine FlashPac 80GB Portable Hard Drive and Card ReaderIt's almost the essence of a single function device. It copies memory cards to the hard disk and that's it. It does the job very well but it doesn't display the images or display the names of the stored files. Of course you can connect the drive to a PC via a USB 2.0 interface and do anything you can normally do with hard disk data files, such as move, copy, view, rename and delete them. When attached to a PC it's simply another system hard drive.
Rbubbly
K20D, *istDL, MZ5, MX and MV
Leuven Belgium
iceblinker
Posted 01/07/2009 - 09:35 Link
rparmar wrote:
iceblinker wrote:
I wonder again: why can't I plug an ordinary hard drive into my network router at home?
Well, that's an easy one. A hard drive is just a stupid hard drive. A NAS is a full computer with its own operating system and knowledge of interfaces needed to communicate with hard drives. It's smart. Those smarts cost more money.
Indeed. It's been suggested that a Pentax DSLR is smart enough to communicate with an ordinary hard drive if only it had a few more lines of firmware. Would you agree or disagree with that?
~Pete
greynolds999
Posted 01/07/2009 - 09:38 Link
I always worry about putting cards anywhere other than in my camera. I had a bad experience where a card reader (built into my laptop) corrupted all my read-only SDHC cards. I realise that this could happen just as easily in the camera but I hope I would notice sooner!

So I've just ordered the Belkin USB Anywhere as it might do exactly what I want (put the iPod to disk mode, plug iPod and Camera in then copy). Might have just saved myself £100 on another hard drive.

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo