Test (water as a lens) - PP

HarisF1
Posted 25/10/2021 - 23:35 Link
Here are a few versions of an image I shot today. I'm nowhere near where I'd like to be in terms of understanding composition and framing so any kind of comments would be useful.

1. Mono, tight crop
Comment Image


2. Colour, tight crop
Comment Image


3. Colour (tweaked), tight crop
Comment Image


4. Colour, wider crop
Comment Image


5. Mono, wider crop
Comment Image


Comments welcome.
All the gear with no idea
bforbes
Posted 26/10/2021 - 13:55 - Helpful Comment Link
Just a thought?

Comment Image
HarisF1
Posted 26/10/2021 - 14:14 Link
Interesting, I hadn't thought of this. It looks a lot more abstract this way, thank you.
All the gear with no idea
Posted 26/10/2021 - 14:26 Link
What lovely results from a somewhat 'left field' of thought. I must admit to liking the blue to the B&W. All still fabby though. I also liked bforbes' contribution as well.
Be well, stay safe, but most of all, invest in memories
Edited by Urbanmeister: 26/10/2021 - 14:29
pschlute
Posted 26/10/2021 - 16:42 Link
I like them all. How about a tighter crop ?
Edited by pschlute: 26/10/2021 - 16:42
Lubbyman
Posted 26/10/2021 - 17:01 Link
Good for a first attempt .

The bforbes version works best because the image in the water drop is immediately recognisable so the eye is drawn to it. With the original version, some thought is needed before recognising what it is.

Even in the bforbes version, I find that there's too much competing for attention. Would it have been possible to get the water drop with the image located in front of the dark part of the background so it is framed by the dark, point bit? Or having the drop a bit further to the left, so it's half way between the rising dark bits of the background and therefore more symmetrical?

Looking forward to seeing the result of the next band of rain moving in from the Atlantic!

Steve
HarisF1
Posted 26/10/2021 - 17:22 Link
Lubbyman wrote:
Good for a first attempt .

The bforbes version works best because the image in the water drop is immediately recognisable so the eye is drawn to it. With the original version, some thought is needed before recognising what it is.

Even in the bforbes version, I find that there's too much competing for attention. Would it have been possible to get the water drop with the image located in front of the dark part of the background so it is framed by the dark, point bit? Or having the drop a bit further to the left, so it's half way between the rising dark bits of the background and therefore more symmetrical?

Looking forward to seeing the result of the next band of rain moving in from the Atlantic!

Steve
Lovely, I'll try and think more about light/dark in future shots. Lets have a bit more rain then
All the gear with no idea
HarisF1
Posted 26/10/2021 - 17:52 Link
pschlute wrote:
I like them all. How about a tighter crop ?
Here are a few crops - finding it difficult because of how some drops are much brighter than others/distracting.

6. Colour
Comment Image


7. Mono
Comment Image


8. Colour, inverted, tighter
Comment Image


9. Colour, inverted, tightest crop
Comment Image
All the gear with no idea

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo