Something to think about........

Malo1961
Posted 26/02/2009 - 19:21 Link
Hi all,
To my big surprise, after logging in today I noticed a new Member ranking system. Wowwwwww........Pentax Pro Master seems to be the title now.
Not so long ago I saw some remarks appear in a thread, about the:How do you become a site veteran question. Some tongue in the cheek jokes were made, some funny suggestions were done. But........never was I under the impression it would be taken seriously.
Oh boy......was I proven wrong.

Now I don't want to come over like a super critical person, who hasn't got anything better to do, than complain, moan, wine etc.....
But after reading several postings about this subject, it seems nobody takes it very serious.

Now...to let the fox loose into the hen.......
Has there actually been some thinking about why there should be a ranking in the first place?
Because, let's face it, 1000 + postings and you are a PPM. What does that mean,if any. (nothing IMO.)
Picture the next scene. A year from now, a newbie decides to join.
And finds himself surrounded by all those masters. Quite intimidating

If you want to have a indication about so called experienced members,you should guess the joining date and number of postings should do the trick.
If there has to be a ranking system, wouldn't it be better when the powers in charge try to think about a system, that actually means something and add some real value to this forum. Maybe something in the line of a specialist ranking.
Without shortening anybody, and just as an example I like to mention Mattmatic. Who has contributed so much expertise regarding flash issues. Give him a title like flash specialist. Or Clarky, who contributed so much in the field of macro. And there are a lot of others equally fit for such a title.
IMO that would add some real value to the forum and beginners who still have to find their way, around here.

So please, skip that ridiculous ranking, or at least give every member the choice, to have it visible or not. And if it is not to much trouble......,Concentrate on real improvements. Like the new posts bug, who still makes new posts disappear after a new logging in, the heretic behaviour when placing smilies, the fact that when subscribed to a thread, suddenly the notification tool switches to off or the implementation of the automated notification tool in the gallery and weekly competition.

Best regards,
Martin.
Best regards,

Martin.


Curious about my photography?? Just Follow the Light.
Darkmunk
Posted 26/02/2009 - 19:28 Link
I agree Martin, and this designation will also have little meaning if applied to the cut and paste merchants who say so very little with their million words.
What is it based on? does anyone know?
Edited by Darkmunk: 26/02/2009 - 19:30
Anvh
Posted 26/02/2009 - 20:25 Link
Good comment Martin and you're quite right.
To go on over your idea, I've a suggestion.

Might it be an idea that you can chose your title yourself out of a number of option. Those options would of course be based on types of photography, skills, how long you have been a pentaxian and things like that.
Of course its not perfect but atleast it gives your more information about a fellow member then what there is now.

Darkmunk wrote:
I agree Martin, and this designation will also have little meaning if applied to the cut and paste merchants who say so very little with their million words.
What is it based on? does anyone know?
It's based on the number of new posts, so everytime i make an new comment it counts as 1 post.
Because I write this in an edit now it wouldn't count as an post.
Does this answer your question?
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
Edited by Anvh: 26/02/2009 - 20:27
Malo1961
Posted 26/02/2009 - 20:33 Link
Don't take that suggestion part to serious, Stefan.
I was merely using it as an example of what could be more useful .
As opposite to that ridiculous title I have to live with, now.

But to be honest, I rather have them, concentrate on really important changes, fixing bugs etc...

Martin.
Best regards,

Martin.


Curious about my photography?? Just Follow the Light.
Father Ted
Posted 26/02/2009 - 20:35 Link
Good points Martin.

Apparently I am Pentax Pro Master also.
Now, with the best will in the world, I'm no master of my Pentax yet. I just spend too long on forums

But, a beginner may think I know more than I actually do because of my title.

Maybe if the categories didn't suggest photographic knowledge, just site experience?
Getting there! Thanks to you guys

Pentax K3ii, Pentax K10d, Kit lens ( 18-55mm ), 50mm f1.7 lens, Tamron 70-300mm lens, Prinzflex 70-162 manual lens, Various old flashes.
Aiki
Posted 26/02/2009 - 20:43 Link
Martin,
You sound very sensible

Veteran sounded odd, now its much more odd.
I hope it was just a joke ....all these titles.

I wonder how big is the team who does all that work about the forum? Fixing bugs etc....
Aiki

----
Pentax K20D; SMC DA 18-55mm II kit; Sigma AF 70-300/4-5.6 APO DG MACRO
GIMP Flickr
PPG
Anvh
Posted 26/02/2009 - 20:56 Link
Ah okay Martin
I haven't thought about it at all but it was just the thing that came up when I readed your comment.
The bugs would be much harder to fix then to change the ranking so let them have there fun

But you're completly right about the intimidating part so some changes would be welcome in me eyes.

Father Ted wrote:
Apparently I am Pentax Pro Master also.
Now, with the best will in the world, I'm no master of my Pentax yet. I just spend too long on forums
The same here Father Ted
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
Oggy
Posted 26/02/2009 - 21:09 Link
...and I am a pentax master. Yeah right.

On another forum where I lurk, anyone with over 1000 posts gets the title "Needs to get out more".
Comment Image
bforbes
Posted 26/02/2009 - 22:05 Link
I like two of Martins ideas
1. to reflect a members special interest in their title.
2. to be able to say i don't want a title
Edited by bforbes: 26/02/2009 - 22:05
pandora
Posted 26/02/2009 - 22:06 Link
My name is still site veteran, I honestly expected it to have changed to Novice which I personally think would have been more appropriate
K5,Pentax DA*300mm,Pentax HD DA 560mm.
johnriley
Posted 27/02/2009 - 00:19 Link
Most forums have a ranking system, and it's just a bit of fun that takes seconds to install, so don't worry about it taking the IT department away from more important things.

Over at ADAPS we have a similar ranking system, I have one on my forum and so does my son Mike on his. Mike's is based on Advanced D&D Monk titles, so Grand Master of Flowers would be the Big Cheese there....

As regards the bugs, the green new posts buttons should be fixed by now, unless anyone knows differently...
Best regards, John
Malo1961
Posted 27/02/2009 - 05:48 Link
No John, They aren't fixed. I can push the button, See 15 new postings, and when I read one, close the page and turn back again to new posts, everything is gone.

And regarding the ranking system? If it only takes seconds to install, please take another few seconds to remove this ridiculous titles.
Or ...at least give the members a choice, to have it visible or not.

Martin.
Best regards,

Martin.


Curious about my photography?? Just Follow the Light.
johnriley
Posted 27/02/2009 - 09:28 Link
Quote:
No John, They aren't fixed. I can push the button, See 15 new postings, and when I read one, close the page and turn back again to new posts, everything is gone.
I think there may be a clue here. When you say close the page that implies that you have left the site, so when you return the buttons have reset. The button means "new posts since last visit" and not "unread posts" so when you read one you need to read the rest before you leave, otherwise they will indeed disappear.

Is this what is happening?

Quote:
And regarding the ranking system? If it only takes seconds to install, please take another few seconds to remove this ridiculous titles.
Or ...at least give the members a choice, to have it visible or not.
Many people thought it ridiculous to be a veteran after only 30 posts and then...nothing further after that. So a structure of names has been put in as it's been mentioned by several people quite a few times. Life doesn't have to be dull.

Does it really matter? Most seem to have taken it with light hearted amusement, but if you don't want it then do please make a Report.
Best regards, John
Aiki
Posted 27/02/2009 - 09:57 Link
[quote:3496ace15f="johnriley
Many people thought it ridiculous to be a veteran after only 30 posts and then...nothing further after that.
Does it really matter? Most seem to have taken it with light hearted amusement, but if you don't want it then do please make a Report.[/quote]It was strange to become a veteran so SOON. There is really no need for so MANY titles. That was the point I guess

It would be really nice, if we can choose ourselves, if we want to see our title or not.
As it was said: joining date and nr of posts gives more info than the title. Title is just --making fun.
But sometimes we are serious as well

Anyway, titles do not make us give up posting
you can never find a solution that EVERYBODY agree 100%
Let,s just cool down
Aiki

----
Pentax K20D; SMC DA 18-55mm II kit; Sigma AF 70-300/4-5.6 APO DG MACRO
GIMP Flickr
PPG
Deecy
Posted 27/02/2009 - 10:01 Link
Speaking as a venerable member who is rife on other non photographic forums I know that seeing long-termers & a high post counts does intimidate new people & we don't need them.. that's the rankings not the newbies
www.blessingphotography.co.uk

2x K20D, 2x K10D, istDS, 2x AF 540FGZ & Pentax lenses + back-up kit

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo