SDM failures horror stories

johnwhit
Posted 06/07/2010 - 07:24 Link
I've got the DA*16-50/2.8, DA*200/2.8 and DA*300/4 all are well used the DA*300/4 is probably my current most used lens, never had a problem. If you think Sigma HSM is any better, check this out:

http://www.lensrentals.com/news/2009.11.01/lens-repair-data-35

"•The Tamron 70-200 f2.8 is joining the Sigma 120-400 and 150-500 (45% failure rate) in the Lensrentals Hall of Shame: lenses we no longer carry because their failure rate is so high we just can’t afford them. Almost half of them have failed, usually after 3 to 6 months in service."

Regards,

John
PPG link

In LBA hiatus.
johnriley
Posted 06/07/2010 - 07:37 Link
I wouldn't be looking to independent lenses for increased reliablility, nor would I be influenced by the anecdotal tales of failures.

There are a lot of SDM lenses out there and we don't really hear of large numbers of problems. The Internet does mean that those problems that exist are certainly well documented.
Best regards, John
flossie
Posted 06/07/2010 - 08:19 Link
johnriley wrote:
There are a lot of SDM lenses out there and we don't really hear of large numbers of problems. The Internet does mean that those problems that exist are certainly well documented.
This may be true. But the fact remains that SDM Pentax lenses fail in a manner and numbers than non-SDM Pentax lenses do not, and when they do, you are left with a £1,000 manual lens, because they block you from using the "backup" Screwdrive that exists on the lens anyway!

Is this connected with the lack of (genuinely) new lenses from Pentax and the dramatic price-rises? almost certainly - all those warranty repairs will have destroyed their profit margins as well making them redesign anything new - expect "SDM 2" or even some new marketing phrase altogether if/when new zooms come out. - even if they are exactly the same, they have a bad reputation that Pentax will want to shed.

Having said that... using the google-ometer :

"canon usm failure" 20,700 results (79%)
"nikon swm failure" 3,260 results (12%)
"pentax sdm failure" 2,050 results (7%)

So its not a uniquely-Pentax issue, all supersonic motors are intrinsically more likely to fail, and not with the classic "Bathtub" curve, either, but much more likely to fail mid-life than non-SS lenses.

Although, going by market share and total lenses sold, the google numbers aren't in proportion - Pentax users seem to either moan a lot more than Canon/Nikon users (unlikely!) or have had worse luck...
Still shooting in the dark (literally and metaphorically)...
Edited by flossie: 06/07/2010 - 08:21
Gwyn
Posted 06/07/2010 - 09:16 Link
For what it is worth (and slightly off topic :blush there is speculation on the "other forum" that the new camera will not have screw AF at all. Maybe that is why Sigma are producing HSM lenses for Pentax.

They also speculate that in body shake reduction will be missing too - hence the OS Pentax lenses from Sigma.

But then again quite a few think Sigma will buy Pentax.

Love the rumours over there, especially from those claiming to be in the know.
flossie
Posted 06/07/2010 - 09:40 Link
Gwyn - I'd take more than a pinch of salt with what is said in the "rumours" forum over there! At least people are rating the worst of the blatent trolls as "one star" threads It is quite amusing sometimes though...if you like illogical conclusions mixed with pure imagination...
Still shooting in the dark (literally and metaphorically)...
fatspider
Posted 06/07/2010 - 09:46 Link
Bad news has always traveled faster than good news.
My Names Alan, and I'm a lensaholic.
My PPG link
My Flckr link
piotro
Posted 06/07/2010 - 10:04 Link
Mine 60-250 still focuses smooth and slow, ahh.. it is normal, not horror .
johnriley
Posted 06/07/2010 - 10:05 Link
I'm happy to report I did not have any SDM failures today....doesn't sound great as news stories go!

The statistic is right by the way, but very misleading as I don't own any SDM lenses....beware statistcs as well.
Best regards, John
terje-l
Posted 06/07/2010 - 10:20 Link
Well put, John!
Best regards
Terry

K20D, Optio I10, DA 18-55 1:3.5-5.6 AL II, A 1:1.7/50, D FA 1:2.8/100 Macro, Sigma 70-300 1:4-5.6 APO DG Macro, Pentax AF 360FGZ
Anvh
Posted 06/07/2010 - 13:01 Link
flossie wrote:
This may be true. But the fact remains that SDM Pentax lenses fail in a manner and numbers than non-SDM Pentax lenses do not, and when they do, you are left with a £1,000 manual lens, because they block you from using the "backup" Screwdrive that exists on the lens anyway!
Actually I find it very good they do that.
The AF does not stop working for nothing and no one for sure can tell it's just the SDM motor. What if a gear is misalign (which Pentax said cause for a lot of the problems with the DA*16-50) and you start using the camera AF motor, how long will that work till it either wreck your lens further or burn out the motor inside the camera?

flossie wrote:
So its not a uniquely-Pentax issue, all supersonic motors are intrinsically more likely to fail, and not with the classic "Bathtub" curve, either, but much more likely to fail mid-life than non-SS lenses.
Good point, I mean how much would the ultrasonic motor Pentax use differ from the rest, they probably buy them at the same factory
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
aybee
Posted 06/07/2010 - 19:22 Link
Well I think I already replied to the original thread here and also added my bit to the other forum.

My anecdotal account is of a SDM failure on my 16-50mm. Now as I'd read all the forum posts on this exact problem I too thought like John it was just hot forum air... until mine failed within a week. So from my perspective I had a 100% failure rate. It was a used example and LCE had it fixed (motor replaced) within 5 days so I'm happy enough. I would never buy one of these on Ebay though, only from a dealer or a trusted source.

So because of this experience I cannot help being disillusioned by SDM, those stories are by no means nonsense, if anything is to go wrong it's likely to be the SDM.
Alan B
Edited by aybee: 06/07/2010 - 19:22
MrCynical
Posted 06/07/2010 - 20:06 Link
flossie wrote:
Having said that... using the google-ometer :

"canon usm failure" 20,700 results (79%)
"nikon swm failure" 3,260 results (12%)
"pentax sdm failure" 2,050 results (7%)
Given that Canon have more than ten times the market share of Pentax, that isn't actually an acquittal!
George Lazarette
Posted 07/07/2010 - 00:33 Link
Anvh wrote:
George, I doubt that the KAF3 lens (SDM only) is more complex then screw-driven lens, I even dare to say the opposite might be true.
It's the lenses that support both systems that I was referring to. As you have pointed out, the SDM-only lenses appear, anecdotally, to be more reliable.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
George Lazarette
Posted 07/07/2010 - 00:50 Link
MrCynical wrote:
flossie wrote:
Having said that... using the google-ometer :

"canon usm failure" 20,700 results (79%)
"nikon swm failure" 3,260 results (12%)
"pentax sdm failure" 2,050 results (7%)
Given that Canon have more than ten times the market share of Pentax, that isn't actually an acquittal!
But do they sell more than ten times as many USM lenses?

We have no idea, so any assumption is baseless.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Dr. Mhuni
Posted 07/07/2010 - 05:38 Link
johnriley wrote:
I wouldn't be looking to independent lenses for increased reliablility, nor would I be influenced by the anecdotal tales of failures.

There are a lot of SDM lenses out there and we don't really hear of large numbers of problems. The Internet does mean that those problems that exist are certainly well documented.
I take your point about the sometimes distorting perspective of bad feedback on the internet, John. However, I think it's pretty clear that the 50-135 has issues. To take the results from the other thread - that invited positive (which on a Pentax forum is likely to be quite forthcoming) and negative feedback - of the 24 people to have mentioned owning the 50-135 9 had had some sort of problem (and of the others many had not had the lens long). I know it's not scientific, but having read about the lens' problems frequently elsewhere I'd say this was probably an accurate reflection.

So far I have only bought Pentax lenses (and am very happy with them), but in this case I can't help thinking I will opt for the Sigma 50-150. Of course, this lens might have issues too - though I have read nothing along these lines (other than front focusing which can be adjusted on my K20). It's true, though, that there are very few of these lenses about in the Pentax mount because of the dominance of the DA*. I guess I should take a look at some Canikon forums for feedback.

The Sigma does have a 3 year warranty in the UK though (not much use in Sri Lanka, but still). Also - the bottom line - the DA* is about 50% more expensive at current SRS prices.
Mhuni

500px

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo