Public Photography ban?

kcmadr
Posted 21/02/2007 - 19:02 Link
"The UK Govt are about to propose restrictions on photography in
public places which could make street photography and documentary
photography against the law."

A quote from DP Review's forum.

Is this true?
LiamD
Posted 21/02/2007 - 20:04 Link
Hi,

I wasn't looking for this, but I found it anyway..

http://petitions.pm.gov.uk/Photography/

which stems from this..

http://www.phooto.co.uk/rights.shtml

It looks more as though there is a sort of conspiracy theory going on. The main point seems to be about the protection of children, which is obviously understandable. I've had a quick look through the common's website, but can't see an actual bill in process, for instance though.

HTH

Cheers

Liam
Liam


"Make your hands respond to what your mind demands." Jesse James

Best wide-angle lens? Two steps backward. Look for the 'ah-ha'. Ernst Haas
johnriley
Posted 21/02/2007 - 21:13 Link
It might be a hit over the top, but Sue and I signed the petition just to show support for fellow photographers.

What happened to the photographers in the story given was totally out of order. You do not have to have a reason to be in a public place and you don't need anyone's permission to take photographs. If anyone tries to delete your pictures against your wishes they are probably committing an assault.

Of course it's always a good idea to remain courteous at all times, but we haven't had any problems ourselves. Has anyone else?
Best regards, John
Gwyn
Posted 21/02/2007 - 22:46 Link
In Holland it IS illegal to take someone's photo without their consent. Furthermore you need their written consent to publish it - including on your own website. In practice it very rarely happens that someone takes offence. I did once when someone photographed me when I was walking my dogs - we had an argument about loose dogs and kids. My dogs were loose, as they were allowed to be, his kid, in a pushchair was unattended while he was off in the wilderness taking pics. He accused me of letting my dogs attack his brat. Anyway my dogs were no where near his brat, and I said he should pay more attention to his kid. He then stated taking photos of me. i said stop and delete them - he refused, so I got out my phone to call the police. He deleted them then! And I made sure he had done by formatting his disk. Mean of me but .......
Taliety
Posted 21/02/2007 - 23:06 Link
As part of the C&G course I'm doing, we had to submit a 10 photo assignment of "faces, places and events" or "motion". My wife chose F,P & E at the Market, and I chose Motion about town. Both involved taking a lot of pictures of people and public places. Most people and public places presented no problem.

We had to get permission to take photos in the local shopping mall from the marketing manager, and I got stopped (quite rightly) for taking pictures of a kiddy's roundabout. After explaining what it was for, that the roundabout would be blurred out and the kids not identifyable, and producing a college headed note, I was allowed to continue. It was getting quite dark by then.

I also took some photos of the Town Hall at dusk with light streams from the traffic. With a full load of equipment, I fealt very vulnerable, and kept my backpack on whilst backed up to a large letter box to protect me. On the way back to the centre to meet the wife, there was a disturbance, which I thought I would capture. However, after a drunken threat, I headed off quite rapidly before I became a focus of attention.
Cheers

Malcolm

Life? Don't talk to me about life!
MattMatic
Posted 22/02/2007 - 09:31 Link
Quote:
And I made sure he had done by formatting his disk.
Always recoverable with Zero Assumption or similar product.
Formatting is never the end of the images on SD/CF media... but then most don't realise that
Matt
stevo
Posted 22/02/2007 - 10:25 Link
Quote:
We had to get permission to take photos in the local shopping mall from the marketing manager
Inside a shopping mall you're probably on private property, so you would need permission.
Quote:
and I got stopped (quite rightly) for taking pictures of a kiddy's roundabout.
What on earth is wrong with photogaphing a roundabout? Certainly nothing legally, assuming that it's in a public place.

There's a good summary of the law and photography at http://www.sirimo.co.uk/ukpr.php.

Steve
fatspider
Posted 22/02/2007 - 12:45 Link
We wouldn't be facing this problem if the British judicial system wasn't a joke, paedolphiles let back out onto the streets, and housholders jailed for protecting thier property etc, plus innocent photographers both verbally and physically abused because some zealous orifice had been wound up by an idiot Lord Mayor.

Leeds hosts a big Fair every year (St Valentines Day Fair) and its an excelent opprtunity for photographers, did I go this year? not on you nelly!
There is no way I am subjecting myself to the risk of both verbal or physical abuse from the aformentioned zealous orifices, especially when the police would fail to do anything about it because their current standpoint seems to be "he thought you was photographing his kids so acted accordingly" or "he didnt know he was commiting assault by ripping the film from your camera"

Well excuse me mr policeman but if I get stopped in the car and one of my tyres is below the legal limit I cant claim "I didn't know" Under UK law IGNORANCE is no excuse.

Sorry for the rant, but this subject really gets me wound up.

PS I also signed the petition.
PPS I dunno, but maybe the paperwork for dodgy tyres is easier than the paperwork for assaults?
PPPS No offence Pete, I know not all Coppers are the same.
My Names Alan, and I'm a lensaholic.
My PPG link
My Flckr link
old timer
Posted 22/02/2007 - 14:27 Link
Quote:
....and I got stopped (quite rightly) for taking pictures of a kiddy's roundabout
I understand your position and, given the state of our officialdom, I would have no wish to mix it with a bunch of heavies whether official or not.

But why "quite rightly"? Why shouldn't you or anybody else, take photos of roundabouts with or without children. It should not be the taking of photographs that is a problem, but rather the use of them.

If I take a picture of a horse, it does not mean I am going to sexually molest it, or if a tree then I am not going to try and have sexual relations with it, or if a pig then I am not going to go out in the middle of the night and rape it so why if I take a picture of a child (even as part of a more general scene) do I have to risk being branded as some sick child molester.

The lunatics have taken over this country and it will not be long before we have to get permission in triplicate and attend a 30 minute interview before we can even break wind.

There, I have had my rant as well.

Do I feel better for it? No

Regards
Graham
Keep up the good work
Graham

I'll think of something someday.
George Lazarette
Posted 22/02/2007 - 23:20 Link
Quote:
Quote:
....and I got stopped (quite rightly) for taking pictures of a kiddy's roundabout
I understand your position and, given the state of our officialdom, I would have no wish to mix it with a bunch of heavies whether official or not.

But why "quite rightly"? Why shouldn't you or anybody else, take photos of roundabouts with or without children. It should not be the taking of photographs that is a problem, but rather the use of them.
Quite so, Graham. Old Timer, man is born free, but everywhere he is in chains. Don't let the imbeciles warp your brain, and thereby enslave you.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
gartmore
Posted 23/02/2007 - 09:29 Link
OK so maybe this was, in retrospect, a dumb thing to do but it has given my chums endless amusement...

Every couple of years or so my daughter's school has a photo taken of the entire school which is quite an impressive undertaking with a sort of grandstand for 600 people and shot on 10x8, it takes place in a public park. I was walking along the equally public adjacent road and took a pic of the scene with man with a real full-frame camera and his head under a dark cloth in foreground entire school in background. Now, unbeknown to me at the time, the police were called because 'a man with a camera was lurking in the bushes'. When my 11 year old daughter says who the man is she was asked what sort of camera her dad used. What can this possibly mean? Does a Pentax 645 make you more or less of a danger to society than someone with a Nokia phone?

The deputy head phoned me to complain, claiming I had committed a crime and a further offence under the data protection act, I kid you not.
I pointed out that no crime had taken place and that anyone wanting pictures of girls in running shorts etc could obtain them freely from the school's own web site.

The whole world has gone bloody mad and I've signed the petition too.

Ken
Ken
“We must avoid however, snapping away, shooting quickly and without thought, overloading ourselves with unnecessary images that clutter our memory and diminish the clarity of the whole.” - Henri Cartier-Bresson -
Mannesty
Posted 23/02/2007 - 11:06 Link
I was taking a few shots of the architecture of a shopping mall here in spain and I was asked (told) by a security person (female) to stop taking pics. I asked why?, as you do. She said 'the management' don't allow it.

What she didn't know was that I had taken a few pics . . . . in the gents toilets. Take a few moments to titter . . . .

. . . to continue, my reason (perfectly innocent, honest) was that the designer of this gentleman's space very obviously had a wicked sense of humour. I should state at this point the their were NO OTHER 'USERS' in the loo's at this time.

My wife tells me, and no, I didn't visit the ladies, that similar images of young men were displayed in the their loo's too.

I just wish I'd had my 12-24mm DA with me. I used my 16045mm DA for these.

I think most of you will appreciate these pics. They are purely record shots, I didn't want to make it too obvious by setting up the tripod and I've used Adobe Lightroom to process them and get them on to the web.

Image 1
Comment Image

Image 2
Comment Image
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
MattMatic
Posted 23/02/2007 - 11:16 Link
Quote:
a further offence under the data protection act
Rubbish.

Schools love to quote this one. It's utter nonsense.
There's a couple of PDFs on www.ico.gov.uk - just have to find the url...
Here:
http://www.ico.gov.uk/upload/documents/pressreleases/2004/new_guidance_on_taking...
and
http://www.ico.gov.uk/upload/documents/library/data_protection/detailed_speciali...
and
http://www.ico.gov.uk/upload/documents/pressreleases/2005/press_release_photogra...

I carry copies with me just in case

Matt
gartmore
Posted 23/02/2007 - 12:42 Link
Thanks, Mannesty, those really made me laugh - perhaps we should start a 'true confessions' section on this forum.

Matt, thanks to you too, excellent information.

Ken
Ken
“We must avoid however, snapping away, shooting quickly and without thought, overloading ourselves with unnecessary images that clutter our memory and diminish the clarity of the whole.” - Henri Cartier-Bresson -
stevo
Posted 23/02/2007 - 18:09 Link
Quote:
Quote:
a further offence under the data protection act
Rubbish.
Quite. Personal use of information is specifically exempt from the act, as is use for the purposes of journalism, literature or art.

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo